Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi banned the media from talking to players this week, so Penn State coach James Franklin seized the opportunity and quickly invited some members of the Pittsburgh media up to Happy Valley to do stories on the Nittany Lions.

Narduzzi called this a huge game; Franklin made sure to downplay it by saying everyone else seems to think this is a big game, but he’s not sure.

Some Pitt fans put together a blog and offered to sell shirts that read “Joe Knew,” and Penn State’s athletic director called Pitt’s athletic director to express concern about the shirts and the two fan bases.

Ah yes, it must be a rivalry week — or at least that’s what the actions of Pitt, Penn State and their fans keep telling us. But here’s what people seem to be missing: Pitt-Penn State isn’t the same rivalry that it once was, and it will never be that again. No amount of contrived anger on social media, forced narratives on message boards, ideas for signs (or shirts), media bans and all the other stuff that has gone on can or will change that.

Advertise with us

This rivalry was once one of the greatest in all of college football. At its height, it featured two teams in the national championship discussion, but those days are long gone and aren’t coming back.

This year’s game should be fun, it should be exciting, it should be a great game between two teams that should play every year. However, I think people are going to be disappointed if they don’t just try to enjoy it for what it is: a competitive game between two teams tied to each other by geography but these days not much else.

This “rivalry” was killed by Joe Paterno. It was killed by Oval Jaynes and that whole crew. It was, basically, killed by adults who put their own egos in front of what was best for football fans in Pennsylvania. Blame isn’t important to me — Penn State people will tell you it was the administration at Pitt and guys like Jaynes, and Pitt people will say it was all Paterno.

None of that matters. What matters is the rivalry as it was will never be again, and no amount of forced emotions will change that. Here are the reasons why:

1. As much as “recruiting” is at stake, if you look at the past 20 years, Pitt and Penn State don’t butt heads nearly as much for players as they once did. It just isn’t the case. Penn State doesn’t come to Western Pennsylvania nearly as much as they did in the 1970s and 1980s, mostly because there aren’t as many players here as there used to be. In the old days, a big part of the rivalry was fueled by those recruiting wars and by a lot of players who grew up playing against each other on both sides. Penn State has very few players from the WPIAL and City League. Frankly, Ohio State and Notre Dame have become more active and a bigger threat in Western Pennsylvania in recent years. The winner of this game will have “bragging rights,” but I don’t see it being some great windfall in recruiting because there just aren’t that many players that these two teams are head-to-head for any more.

Advertise with us

2. Players who played in this rivalry grew up watching it and understood how important and intense it was. When they got to campus, they were schooled by older players about just how important it was. That’s not the case with these players. The last time Pitt and Penn State played was 2000, when the current senior class would have been about 6. My son, who plays for Pitt and is a redshirt sophomore, actually went to a Pitt-Penn State game in 1999. He was 4 and can’t give me many of the details other than that he had his face painted for it. The point is that these players haven’t grown up watching Pitt-Penn State games and haven’t played in them, either. By the time both sides figure out how intense the games are supposed to be, the series will be off again. Students from both schools kind of understand they aren’t supposed to like each other, but again, most of what I’ve seen seems to be contrived anger and emotion.

3. This will be the first time that Pitt and Penn State will play each other without Paterno on the sideline since 1949. Even before the Jerry Sandusky scandal, Paterno was polarizing and seen as the enemy by Pitt fans. If Paterno was still walking the sidelines, it would be different, but he isn’t. Instead, it’s Franklin, who irritates some with his Todd Graham-like chest pounding and back patting. But let’s face it: Franklin hasn’t been around long enough for most people to develop a healthy dislike yet. And I suppose some Penn State fans are still angry at Narduzzi for his role in that intense and angry Land Grant Trophy rivalry game Penn State and Michigan State play, but I’m going to go out on a limb and say they are far and few between.

4. The game won’t go on. It will go on for four years and then never be played again, or at least not any time in the near future. It’s like toying with fans — giving them a taste, and just when the rivalry seems to be up and running again, yanking it away from them. There are no plans for it to resume, either, and looking at both schedules in the future, it probably couldn’t resume until at least about 2025. So, let’s go with that year. From 2000-25, a span of 25 years, Pitt will have played Penn State four times. A rivalry? Four games in 25 years? Just for comparison’s sake, in that same period Pitt will have played South Florida, Connecticut and Cincinnati 10 times. Think about that —10 games against noted rival South Florida, four against Penn State in 25 years.

5. Not only does Pitt rarely play Penn State in football, the two schools rarely play in pretty much everything except wrestling. Frankly, I wonder if they’d even wrestle against each other if there weren’t so few college wrestling teams out there. It’s absolutely asinine to me that the men’s and women’s basketball teams don’t play each other — just downright stupid. There is no good reason for that, but because they don’t, there just aren’t many opportunities for the fans to interact with each other.

I’m not trying to rain on the parade, and I know this is going to be an exciting weekend for a lot of people. I’m sure it will be a great game, as these two teams are evenly matched. I’m very glad they’re playing again and wish they would extend the series for the next 40 years. But forgive me if I’m having a hard time (I grew up in the suburbs of Pittsburgh in the heart of Pitt-Penn State territory and lived in a divided neighborhood on the subject) drudging up those old feelings of the rivalry that once was because that time has passed.

It just isn’t the same as it used to be. It will never be the same, and that’s a shame because at one time it was, as I wrote, one of the great rivalries in college football.