The Cubs played and won two 13-inning games in the past week. But the length and result are where the similarities between the two games end.
And therein lies the problem with the final month of the Major League Baseball season. It is a much different game than the one played from April to the end of August because of expanded rosters (September call-ups).
The first of the Cubs’ two 13-inning games was against the Pirates last Monday, and if you remember, the Pirates lost it mostly because Clint Hurdle ran out of pitchers and thus had to let Jeff Locke pitch to the meat of the Cubs order.
The Pirates had taken a 7-6 lead in the top of the 13th and thus needed only to get three outs to win, but Hurdle had to run Locke, who is their worst pitcher, back out to the mound.
Locke had been bailed out in both the 10th and 12th innings by great defensive plays to throw out Javier Baez — the potential winning run — at the plate.
If Hurdle had anyone else available, he would have sent him out for the bottom of the 13th to face Dexter Fowler, Kris Bryant, Anthony Rizzo and company. But he didn’t, so Locke took the mound, faced five batters, failed to record an out and the Cubs scored twice to win the game.
Now fast forward to Sunday, when the Cubs and Giants played a 13-inning game and the Giants lost mostly because they couldn’t get hits (only four hits in the entire game), but that’s been their problem since the All-Star break so this was no surprise.
The difference, though, is that they were able to stretch the game out to the 13th, because after Johnny Cueto gave them seven strong innings, they used NINE relief pitchers to get through 5⅓ innings.
And they had three more available if needed, which is absolutely silly and, as Peter Gammons wrote, not exactly in line with the commissioner’s quest to speed up games.
The Pirates used six relievers in their 13-inning game, but their starter (Steven Brault) went only four innings and Locke was the last guy available.
So the Pirates used six relievers to get through nine innings and had nobody else available — which affected the defense they played in the 13th when Hurdle had to gamble with the infield up and a man on third and no outs instead of playing double play depth.
I’d even argue the Pirates’ 1-0 loss to Milwaukee Friday night was affected by the expanded rosters considering that the Brewers starter Junior Guerra was coming off the DL and on a pitch count and only went 3⅓ innings.
The Brewers tied a major league record that night by using seven total pitchers in a nine-inning game. That has only happened two other times, and both were games that took place after Sept. 1 roster expansion.
Hurdle is one of the largest voices in the game that the expanded rosters in September are not good for the game and change the game way too much at the most critical time of the year.
As a former player, he understands the value of rewarding guys in the minors who have had a good season with a call to the majors but believes there should be a better way to do it so the game doesn’t change so much.
“I have had a lot of experience as a player and have had experience to watch the challenges and opportunities [expanded rosters] bring from the managerial standpoint,” Hurdle said. “It does change the game. It is a completely different game from the one you play for five months. It makes it interesting, no doubt, and it gives you more opportunities to leverage situations or try to leverage situations and to use different skill sets to try and score runs and defend runs.
“However, my mindset, my opinion only is that it is an oxymoron that we do it one way for five months and then for the final month, we are just going to go to a different brand of baseball. I’ll make the adjustment, move on with it, but I don’t know how representative of the first five months it is.”
Hurdle makes a tremendous point. It may not sound like a big deal, but in baseball, a sport played nearly every day and one in which a pitcher’s arms and innings must be managed properly, it is a huge difference.
If Hurdle had 10 more pitchers sitting down in the bullpen, Locke probably doesn’t pitch three innings in Chicago, much less get rolled out there for his fourth when it was clear he was struggling and hanging on by a thread. The Pirates are in a fight for their playoff lives, and one or two games won or lost might make all the difference in the world at the end of the season.
You can’t have one set of rules in play the first five months of the season and a completely different set of rules in play for the most important month.
Teams such as Milwaukee, Cincinnati and Atlanta most often have horrible bullpens and can’t close out games during the first five months of the season, which is one of several reasons they fall to the bottom of the standings.
But in the final month, they can load up with pitchers and basically do what the Brewers did against the Pirates — use as many relievers as possible without any worry about the next day or running out of arms — and that makes them more competitive, which is flat out wrong.
I am not sure what the solution is, because I do think it is a nice reward that some younger guys get a chance to play in the majors for a month.
By the same token, football, a much more brutal sport, doesn’t feel the need to allow the 10 practice squad players join the team for the final month and the guys who are good enough to play in the NFL eventually make it there.
If anything, perhaps a very limited form of expanded rosters could be instituted and not change the game dramatically — something like team going from 25 to 29 players, but none of the four players added can have more than say 50 games of MLB experience.
This would mean clubs could still reward younger guys with a call-up and add some depth, but they would also have to continue to manage the roster the right way in September. That would include still utilizing resources such as the DL and optioning guys to and from the minors the same way they do all year as opposed to the way it is now where none of that is particularly relevant.
A limited expansion — severely limited — would also eliminate all these games general managers play with their rosters in the days leading up to September where they “option” guys but never really send them to the minors in order to free up roster spots.
There is no good reason teams should get the luxury of (up to) 40 players on their rosters in September when the game isn’t played that way all season long or in the playoffs.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.