San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick decided to sit on the bench instead of stand with his teammates during the national anthem a few days ago in order to protest what he calls the oppression of people of color in this country.
Probably the worst part of this “controversy” is that we’re spending a lot of time and energy discussing the actions of a guy who is a marginal NFL talent, a backup quarterback and one of the most overpaid players in NFL history. But beyond that, the second worst part of this is that it shows how ill-informed and/or confused most people are about such things as patriotism, the Constitution and what oppression really means.
If you want to know how we can go through presidential primary elections and end up with two awful choices, all you need to do is go on social media and read the “takes” of people about an issue like this one and it becomes very, very clear. Most people just aren’t smart enough or informed enough to understand an issue like this, and most people have a funny idea about what the Constitution actually says and what rights it grants.
Kaepernick should have his say and be free to do what he wants, and frankly, he isn’t un-American or unpatriotic because he doesn’t stand during the national anthem.
We would be better off if we cut all the pandering, over-the-top, psuedo-patriotism at sporting events, from the national anthem to “God Bless America” at the seventh-inning stretch to all of the other ways these leagues show just how patriotic we are and how much we love our country. It’s all just for show, and none of it has anything to do with whether we are patriotic, love our country and/or respect soldiers. I have no issues with soldiers being honored from time to time at games, but believe me, if the Pirates went an entire season and didn’t honor any soldiers, didn’t wear their Thursday uniforms and didn’t play “God Bless America,” it wouldn’t change how patriotic they are. Not even a little bit.
When the national anthem is played, it gives me a moment to pause and think about what a blessing it is to live in a free country and all of the sacrifices that have gone into to keeping it free. I appreciate its meaning. But I’m not sure why that has to happen before sporting events. Are you less patriotic when you go to an eatery and sit down to eat a meal and don’t have the national anthem played? How about when you go to the movies — do you have to stop outside the movie and listen to the national anthem before you go in? How about concerts? Does your boss make you stand and listen the national anthem before you are allowed to sit down and work? So, why do we do it at sporting events? More importantly, why are those who aren’t fully engaged or not participating being called unpatriotic or disrespectful of soldiers?
Kaepernick has a view that, right now, he isn’t proud of this country, and his way of expressing it is by sitting down during the national anthem. I don’t agree with his primary view or his reasoning, nor do I agree with his method — I think there are better ways to do it that don’t call so much attention to him — but I have no issues with what is a very simple protest. But again, if we didn’t force-feed patriotism on people by playing the anthem at sporting events, we wouldn’t have issues like this one to try to sift through.
Steelers tackle Alejandro Villanueva — an Army Ranger who did three tours overseas before his NFL career began — has a reasonable take on this issue, but even he falls into this trap as he talks about the soldiers who fought and died for our freedom. Yes, a lot of soldiers have fought and died for our freedom. They also fought and died for Colin Kaepernick’s freedom to protest, so he isn’t disrespecting them by carrying out that right. In fact, by using a peaceful protest to get his point across, he is actually paying the ultimate tribute to them, as he wouldn’t be able to do that in a society that isn’t free.
Kaepernick is using his platform to express his view on racial justice in this country — nothing more and nothing less — and I’m not really sure what the issue is. Conversely, those who have a different view aren’t “haters” or “racists,” they just happen to think that people should respect the national anthem and the American flag.
Freedom of speech is so often erroneously thrown around in these discussions. It doesn’t mean freedom from being criticized for your speech, nor does it mean your employer can’t discipline you for your speech. In other words, Kaepernick can make his stand, but when he takes a controversial stand, there will be blowback and there will be criticism. It seems like he has been very much a stand-up guy in that he has answered every question thrown his way.
If you want to be outraged about something involving Kaepernick, how about his $114 million contract that included $61 million guaranteed, despite the fact that he only had two decent seasons. He has since lost his starting job.
There are some who believe this action by Kaepernick was simply a smokescreen to make sure he pushes the 49ers to cut him because he is unhappy with his status as a backup.
Fox Sports’ Jay Glazer said Sunday that Kaepernick’s 49ers days may be coming to an end because he is just not that good at playing quarterback. That is the backdrop to this story. Kaepernick wouldn’t be the first or last athlete to do something controversial in order to force his team to allow him to become a free agent. I’m not saying that is the case here, but I would not at all be shocked if that is at least in part the motivation for this circus he’s created.
Kaepernick is a mediocre football player who has made a lot more money than he should have given his talents, and that is more fact than opinion. But whether he is patriotic is not relevant, nor can it be proven by this silly litmus test of how he acts during the national anthem.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.