The Steelers play host to the Eagles tonight in their second preseason game but again they will do so without the services of their best players — Ben Roethlisberger, Antonio Brown, Le'Veon Bell, etc., etc.
I say good for Mike Tomlin and I hope — even though he said he wouldn't — he holds out the team's best defensive players as well.
And I hope he repeats this again next week against the Saints and in two weeks against Carolina.
There is no need for any of these guys to play in these preseason games and more importantly there is no need to put any of them at risk for injury.
I've written it several times — this team has the look of a Super Bowl contender, maybe is even the favorite in the AFC, and the only thing that can derail that is self-inflicted wounds.
We've already seen a few of those — Martavis Bryant being suspended for the season, Bell out for four games (possibly) — and that's more than enough.
What is the point of playing the best players in these games anyway, especially since they are veterans?
This isn't like baseball where guys need a certain number of at-bats against live pitching in spring training in order to get up to speed and ready for the season. I actually hope this trend of not playing top players in any preseason game — which, I assume Tomlin will play the starters next week for a series or two — grows and becomes the norm in the league.
That would actually be something about the preseason that makes sense.
The goals of the preseason are (or should be) simple — figure out who is good enough to make your team and who isn't, get the rookies up to speed and some reps in live games and get the veterans in shape and keep them healthy.
Anything beyond that is ridiculous.
I love when you hear people make the argument that “you have to play your QB and receivers some in these games because they need to develop timing” as if they aren't doing that in the 50 or so practices they have before the season starts.
Seriously, there is nothing that veterans (meaning, the players who are no-brainers to make the team) need to prove, and that's especially true for the the quarterback and receivers.
I would estimate by the end of this camp Roethlisberger will have thrown well over 200 passes to Antonio Brown between drills, 7-on-7s and scrimmages. The only thing that can get accomplished by playing Roethlisberger and Brown is that one of them could get hurt by some rookie or free agent defensive player from the other team trying to make a mark and make the team.
And the less the top players play in these preseason games, the more those rookies and free agents and veterans trying to hang on get to play and get evaluated.
I know a lot of people say they hate watching preseason games because it is a bunch of guys they have never heard of, but that's the only interesting part of the preseason in my book. The Steelers have, if my math is correct, probably 19 of 22 positions locked down and the other three are well down the road toward finding a starter.
So tonight's game (and the next two) is about finding depth and figuring out who among the rookies can help this year and see if there are some diamonds in the rough among the free agents.
It is also about finishing the special teams units and figuring out who the final two offensive linemen are.
That's why I find the preseason interesting, and it is also why I am glad Tomlin has decided to end this charade that these are real games and just sit his best players out all together.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.