Peyton Manning was one of the NFL players linked to performance-enhancing drugs and human-growth hormone by an Al Jazeera America report that surfaced late last season.

Manning met with the NFL to discuss the report, and according to a statement from the NFL “cooperated fully” with the league in its efforts to investigate the claims.

About three weeks ago, Manning was cleared by the NFL of any wrongdoing, and there was “no credible evidence Peyton Manning was provided with or used human-growth hormone or other substances banned by the league.”

James Harrison (along Mike Neal, Clay Matthews and Julius Peppers) was also named in the report. Rather than cooperate, has taken the advice of the NFL Players Association and declined to speak to NFL investigators about the issue. Now he is being threatened with a suspension if he doesn’t cooperate.

Advertise with us

Is it really that hard to figure this out?

I respect Harrison for standing up to what seems to be an unfair inquisition based on a report that has since been retracted. I respect the NFLPA for trying to take a hard line and make a stand against the NFL and the idea that the league — and more specifically the commissioner — can act as judge, jury and executioner without any real form of due justice. But the NFLPA gave Roger Goodell the power to do these things and can’t really complain about it until the next collective bargaining agreement.

Until then, the NFLPA would be far better off advising guys like Harrison to cooperate with these investigations, though I do think the NFL should come to Harrison, Matthews and company instead of making them go to New York. The way the letter sent by the NFL to the NFLPA is written makes it clear: Harrison won’t be suspended for suspicion of the use of banned substances if he doesn’t cooperate, he will be suspended for failing to cooperate. It seems like Harrison and the NFLPA are coming to the conclusion that, especially in light of the NFL winning in court against Tom Brady, the best course of action will be just to talk to the NFL and get it over with.

Harrison spoke to the media late this morning at training camp in Latrobe: “I’ll do what I have to do, they’ll do what they have to do, we’ll make that decision when the time comes. Nobody wants to be suspended, but you know...”

The NFL isn’t accusing Harrison and company of using PEDs, it’s doing its due diligence to look into a report about the use of PEDs among some of its players. If Harrison is innocent, he has nothing to hide and could have put this mess behind him a long time ago by sitting down and talking with league.

Advertise with us

When asked by the assembled media today why he is so hesitant to speak with the NFL, his answer had some merit and some valid concerns: “I mean, if that’s the case, then somebody could come out and say James Harrison is a pedophile. Are they going to suspend me, put me under investigation for being a pedophile just because somebody said it? I mean, I’m not going to answer questions for every little thing that some Tom, Dick and Harry comes up with.”

The answer? The NFL is your employer. If it hears bad things about one of its employees, it wouldn’t be doing its due diligence if it didn’t at least check into it. Remember the NFL isn’t accusing Harrison and company of using PEDs nor is the NFL threatening to suspend them for use of PEDs. The NFL is simply asking to talk to them about a report that came out, and they aren’t even going to do it under oath, which means Harrison could answer every question “no” and be done with it.

I’ve always found Harrison to be refreshing in his refusal just to conform for the sake of conforming but I also know he is a pretty intelligent guy and understands he doesn’t much of a leg to stand on here. His best course of action would be to just do the interview (though, I repeat, the NFL should come to him and not the other way around) and then work with the NFLPA over the next couple of years to prepare for a fight with the NFL in the next collective bargaining agreement.

The NFLPA gave the commissioner the power that he has, and, true, he has abused it in many ways. But now is not the time to make this stand as the NFL holds all the cards and the stakes are too high for Harrison, Neal, Peppers and Matthews to try to play a game of chicken.

Follow Paul Zeise on Twitter @PaulZeise.