The Pirates gave away Jung Ho Kang bobbleheads to the first 20,000 fans through the gate for this afternoon’s game against San Diego. Does anyone else think the Pirates didn’t think this one through too well?
Actually, the scary thing is that if you read quotes from Pirates spokesman Brian Warecki in this story by the Post-Gazette’s Stephen J. Nesbitt, they did think it through and still came to the conclusion that this was a good idea.
In case you missed it, Kang, a very popular player who is under normal circumstances worthy of a bobblehead, is currently under investigation for sexual assault after an incident that took place in Chicago in May.
Here are the nuts and bolts of the actual incident. The investigation has been ongoing ever since. Now, I understand he hasn’t been charged and is innocent until proven guilty, so spare me the legal eagle routine because this isn’t a court of law. The bottom line is that he hasn’t been charged with anything yet but he hasn’t been cleared of the charges, either. As such, the Pirates are having a promotion in honor of a player who is being investigated for a sexual assault. This is at a time when every league has become far more sensitive to domestic violence and sexual assault than they have ever been.
In Nesbitt’s story, Warecki says the Pirates’ opposition to violence against women is both “clear and strong” and talks about the organization’s involvement with the Pennsylvania Coalition Against Domestic Violence “No More” campaign. That’s all well and good, and frankly, when I first read it I thought that, in talking with the police and the commissioner’s office, the Pirates are very confident Kang will be exonerated. Why else would they take this stand to preserve something as dumb as a bobblehead promotion? I was OK with that explanation. Well, sort of. I figured the Pirates believed Kang’s legal situation would be worked out by now and they wouldn’t have to answer questions about why they’re having a promotion for him. Then, we come to find out that the Pirates may not be quite so confident that this will work out. They decided to hedge their bets and offer fans who decline to take the bobblehead a voucher good for an alternate item. I can’t make this up. The Pirates are acknowledging this is a really bad look without acknowledging it’s a really bad look.
There were two very reasonable ways this could be handled. The first is simple: postpone the bobblehead giveaway until Kang’s situation is resolved. Last time I checked, there’s no expiration date on bobbleheads, and Kang is signed for a couple more years. By postponing it, the Pirates wouldn’t be saying they think Kang is guilty, they’d be saying they want the legal process to play out and know this is a very sensitive subject.
Read More
The second solution is just as simple and maybe even more practical: if the Pirates were really concerned about losing the 10 people who might not have bought tickets without the promotion, how about offering the vouchers to everyone who walks through the door? Then, you can still have the Kang bobblehead giveaway at a later date after the investigation is resolved — assuming he is exonerated, of course.
The only wrong answer here is to give out bobbleheads of a guy who is being investigated for a very serious crime. Allowing a guy to play while he is being investigated is one thing, but honoring him with a bobblehead is a completely different thing. It’s the absolute wrong message.
This is an example of a potential public relations disaster that could have been avoided had someone been thoughtful enough to say this is a bad idea when it came down to deciding that the bobblehead show must go on. Think about it. What if Kang is charged tomorrow or next week? How do the Pirates explain that one?
It’s a situation that could have and should have been avoided had the Pirates just used better judgment and understood that sometimes perception does equal reality.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.