It has been a long, hard season for the Pirates, and when that happens, it creates a lot of unrest among the fans, media and people around the team and ultimately leads to finger-pointing. In other words, who is to blame for this mess?
I have a pretty good pulse on who is getting the brunt of the blame in Pittsburgh sports, but in recent weeks the fans have seemingly begun to turn on Clint Hurdle. It’s as if he has something to do with this disappointment of a season. No offense, but that’s lunacy.
Hurdle should be considered for some manager of the year awards for somehow keeping this Titanic of a roster that he was handed above water. Oh sure, Hurdle does some things that drive you nuts, like the way he handles the bullpen, tries too hard to get his starting pitchers through five innings so they can get the win and constantly tinkers with the lineup. I didn’t like his handling of Andrew McCutchen last week with a roster that was short-handed due to injury already, either, though we aren’t sure that one didn’t come from above.
However, you can nitpick and second-guess every manager that has managed a game of baseball because there are so many different ways to look at every situation. I’m not a small-picture guy, never have been and never will be, especially when it comes to baseball, a sport of large sample sizes. And here’s what the big picture tells me about the job Hurdle has done:
The Pirates won 98 games last year and thus were seemingly a couple of moves away in the offseason from being right back in the mix among World Series contenders.
Management knew it needed to bolster its pitching staff, and instead of going out and getting a legitimately good pitcher — or re-signing J.A. Happ — opted for Juan Nicasio, Ryan Vogelsong and Jonathan Niese. Then it tried to say with a straight face this was an upgrade. To strengthen the bullpen and replace Joe Blanton, Antonio Bastardo and Joakim Soria, it decided to go with the AJ Schugel, Rob Scahill, Kyle Lobstein, Cory Luebke and whoever lost the Nicasio/Vogelsong competition coming out of spring training. Management knew the one area it had a hole in the everyday lineup was at first base and knew Josh Bell wasn’t ready. So, rather than getting a first baseman, it grabbed John Jaso, a journeyman who had never played first and has no power. I’ll say it one time: the Pirates would have been better off with Pedro Alvarez at first than with Jaso because at least Alvarez might close his eyes and hit a home run from time to time.
So, let’s review. Pirates management began the season by handing Hurdle a pitching staff with two legitimate starting pitchers, a journeyman with no power at first base and a bullpen that wasn’t nearly as good as it was at the end of last season. Then the season began and Hurdle’s best player — McCutchen — has stunk. One of the only two varsity pitchers he had — Francisco Liriano — has stunk. As has Jung Ho Kang. As has one of the few returning relievers he had coming back — Jared Hughes.
Think about this again. Hurdle was handed a team that wasn’t good enough, then had four of his best players underachieve badly.
Hurdle has somehow kept this team focused, on message, fighting and believing they have a chance to get a wild-card spot. Yet, despite the worst week the Pirates have had in a long, long time, they are still above .500 and within a few games of the wild card.
Still being in the race has a lot more to do with other National League teams being flawed and/or not very good, but the Pirates wouldn’t be in the race if they weren’t over .500. That’s a testament to the job Hurdle has done of keeping the core group of players engaged and focused on trying to win every night.
Hurdle will never be confused with an Xs and Os savant. He will never be applauded for his high level strategy, or how much of a thinking manager he is. His strength is and always will be his ability to manage, motivate and remain calm. His strength is his ability to convince his players that they aren’t as good as they think they are when they are rolling and aren’t as bad as they think they are when they get swept in Milwaukee.
He has had to spend a lot of this season convincing his players that Pirates management really does want to win the World Series even though everything it has done in the past 10 months would suggest otherwise.
I’m not saying Hurdle has been perfect this year, and I’m not saying he hasn’t made mistakes. But he clearly is one of the best things the Pirates have going for them. Considering the hand he has been dealt, he deserves a lot of credit for a job well done.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.