There have been many mixed reviews of the Steelers’ Kevin Colbert/Mike Tomlin drafts. But no season will be a bigger referendum on their ability to identify, draft and develop talent — especially on defense — than this year because the Steelers will rely on younger players at key positions.
The Steelers begin training camp Thursday as one of the favorites to win the AFC, as they should be. They have just about everything needed to win, especially on offense. They have a Hall of Fame quarterback, one of the best receivers in football, a good offensive line, a top-flight running back and a couple of really good defensive linemen. But their linebackers and secondary are a bit of a question, and that’s where the Colbert/Tomlin drafts come into play.
The linebacking corps features four first-round draft picks: Lawrence Timmons, Jarvis Jones, Ryan Shazier and Bud Dupree. All four have some questions to answer.
Timmons, Tomlin’s first first-round pick, is 30, was drafted in 2007, has been an effective player but never developed into the kind of dominant player the Steelers believed he would be. He made one Pro Bowl and was an All-Pro once. He is the Steelers’ best linebacker, and it’s pretty clear at this point what the Steelers will get from him.
Jones is running out of time and needs to prove he can play at a consistent level, much less a high level.
Shazier has been impressive, when healthy. He’s a bit undersized, and as a result his body seemingly breaks down too often.
Dupree showed flashes last year as a rookie but needs to take the next step this year.
All four, especially Dupree, Shazier and Jones, need to play consistently if the Steelers are going to reach their goals of winning a Super Bowl.
It isn’t just the linebackers that the Steelers invested picks in. The secondary needs help, too, and it looks like the help is going to have to come from some young guys who were drafted high.
Ross Cockrell is penciled in as the starter at one corner, but he has some limitations. The Steelers are hoping rookie first-round pick Artie Burns can push Cockrell and eventually beat him for the job. The same thing can be said at strong safety, where rookie second-round pick Sean Davis needs to beat out undrafted free agent Robert Golden. Last year’s second-round pick, Senquez Golson is pushing to be the third corner to cover slot receivers.
The Steelers’ pass defense, and therefore their defense, was their Achilles heel last year and will be again this year unless the players I named play well every week. In some cases, that may be asking a lot of some younger players, but in the NFL most teams don’t have the luxury to wait around. The Steelers need to get a boost from some of these players and get a sound return from their drafts.
If most of these players do play well, it would go a long way towards suggesting the Steelers are drafting up to their reputation. If they don’t, and the season comes undone because the defense can’t hold up its end of the bargain, it raises some serious questions about whether it’s time for some changes in that department.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.