The Pirates suddenly have too many pitchers.
Ordinarily too much pitching is a good thing, but that’s only assuming they are all good pitchers and/or pitching well. That isn’t the case with Pirates. They have too many pitchers who haven’t performed well and/or just aren’t good enough.
I know Neal Huntington loves to stockpile pitchers and build depth, but it’s time for a couple of these pitchers to get on with their life’s work. That’s especially true with the non-waiver trading deadline quickly approaching. The Pirates may be able to dump an arm or two and at least get something — anything — in return for them.
If you go with the model of 12 pitchers on the roster, it’s pretty clear who 10 of those 12 need to be just based on performance or pedigree.
Four of the five starters should be Gerrit Cole, Francisco Liriano, Jameson Taillon and Chad Kuhl. A couple of weeks ago, I wrote that Jeff Locke should absolutely be the fifth starter, but his past four starts have ranged somewhere between bad and dreadful. That has made it a tougher case, unless you consider the alternatives at this point.
Jon Niese has been so bad he was ripped by the general manager, who then, of course, apologized. Although statistically he has been about the same or even a little better than Locke, his overall body of work has not been as good. Juan Nicasio had his shot, didn’t get it done and actually has the look of someone who can help in the bullpen. Ryan Vogelsong lost the job coming out of spring training and hasn’t done a whole lot to prove he deserves another shot at being in the rotation. He has been injured, but he’s back doing rehab assignments and should be ready soon.
Steven Brault, Wilfredo Boscan and Tyler Glasnow are young and have shown some flashes, so if you want to go with young talent over veteran journeymen, these would be the candidates.
Regardless, there are too many pitchers. Not all of them can fit in the bullpen, so Niese and Vogelsong or Locke have to go.
The good thing about Brault, Boscan and Glasnow is that they have options left to go back down to the minors (unlike Locke, for instance), and the schedule allows for a few days off. Thus, the Pirates can survive with only four starters for a few weeks, if needed.
In theory, the Pirates could go with four starters and fill in the blanks with Glasnow and Brault until one of them distinguishes himself or the rosters expand in September. I hated that theory a few weeks ago, but with Locke falling apart, Niese being Niese and Vogelsong being a journeyman at the end of his career, I think it might be the way to go.
The other option is for the Pirates to trade for a veteran starter at the deadline. However, unless it’s a good starting pitcher — which the Pirates are not likely to make a run at — I have no interest in this option. If they are going to bring in a mediocre, flawed reclamation project or veteran guy whose best attribute seems to be he has hung around the majors for a long time, they are better off sticking with Locke, Niese or Vogelsong. But we’ve already established at least two of those three, and probably all three, need to go.
Locke is not a bullpen option, so if we are truly at the point where it’s time for him to go, then he needs to be traded or designated for assignment.
The bullpen is pretty clear. Mark Melancon, Tony Watson, Jared Hughes, Neftali Feliz and Juan Nicasio are no-brainers, and Arquimedes Caminero and A.J Schugel have pitched well in recent weeks. So, there isn’t a place for Niese, Vogelsong and Locke if they aren’t in the starting rotation.
Unlike a lot of people, I could live with one of those three in the rotation. But again, the Pirates’ schedule gives them the luxury of using a combination of the three young guys not named Taillon and Kuhl to spot start and fill in around the main four starters.
Regardless, it’s clear the Pirates need to make some difficult decisions in the next week about who to trade, and some even tougher decisions if they can’t find anyone to take Locke, Niese and Vogelsong off their hands.
Too much pitching is usually a viewed as a good problem to have, but in the Pirates’ case it isn’t. They simply have too many pitchers, and not enough of them have been good enough to keep around beyond next week.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.