The Big 12 Conference presidents have made an about face and are going to aggressively pursue expansion, which only furthers my views that the people who run universities may be blessed with high IQs but aren’t always intelligent.

A month ago, Big 12 commissioner Bob Bowlsby said the league presidents were happy with their 10-member league and would essentially put expansion on the back burner. That was the right decision. The Big 12 doesn’t need more members, or at least not more members from the pool of schools that are still available after the last 10 years of conference realignment.

Tuesday, the conference announced it authorized Bowlsby to start exploring candidates for expansion and that the league would add either two or four teams.

The Big 12 was just fine — well, other than the fact that the Big 12 has 10 members and the Big Ten has 14. What’s in a name these days, anyway?

Advertise with us

The Big 12 is coming off a season in which Oklahoma played in the College Football Playoff, proving the conference doesn’t need a championship or more members to get a seat at the table. All the Big 12 needs is one of its teams to win the national championship. That’s no different than any other league.

People used the year before, when Baylor and TCU were left on the doorstep of playing for the national championship, as proof that the Big 12 needed its own championship game.

Never mind that last year the Pac-12 champion was left out of the College Football Playoff despite winning a conference championship game, and, had North Carolina upset Clemson in the ACC title game, the ACC would have been left out.

The Big 12 resisted expansion, then the rules changed so conferences needed only 10 teams (not 12) to play a championship game. At that point, the Big 12 should have, and seemingly did, end expansion talk forever.

Again, the idea that a championship game is needed to enhance a league’s chances of getting into the playoff is flat-out dumb.

Advertise with us

Let’s play this out real quick. Say Oklahoma enters the Big 12 championship at 11-1, clearly in the discussion for the playoff. But in the Big 12 championship, the Sooners face 9-3 TCU, which has no shot of getting into the playoff. A TCU win would knock the Big 12 out of the playoff, so it’s a myth that a championship is a firewall to being shut out of the playoff.

If it’s about money, remember that every additional team needs to be able to add at least enough money to offset the fact that there are more mouths to feed, so to speak. In other words, if every team in the Big 12 is making $25 million per year from the conference, each new team must add at least $25 million in revenues just to make sure every school is breaking even. A conference championship is expected to bring about $27 million to the league, which currently means about $2.7 million per team. But if you add two more teams, that number per school drops because it is being split 12 ways instead of only 10. So, what’s the point?

Let’s look at some of the schools available: Memphis, Houston, Central Florida, South Florida, Boise State, Connecticut and Cincinnati. Do any of those schools open new markets that are essential to the Big 12’s viability?

Central Florida and South Florida are overrated because they are anonymous in their own markets. Boise State is a good football team and not much else. And I forgot, Connecticut delivers the New York market! Um, OK.

Again, the Big 12 is fine and had earned my admiration for being smart enough to resist the expansion train. Alas, the league has apparently fallen into a trap, which means we will be hearing about sleeping giants Central Florida and South Florida, how Cincinnati is West Virginia’s natural rival, or how Connecticut opens up the New York market to the league.

It’s all utter nonsense. I thought the Big 12 was a breath of fresh air, but I obviously thought wrong.