There are lots of theories about how to “fix” the Pirates, but a lot of them seem to miss the easiest and best route for them to get back over .500 and make a push towards a fourth consecutive Wild Card game.

True, there are moves that could be made and lineups to be tinkered with, but the Pirates will go nowhere if four of their best players aren’t their best players in the second half of the season.

Start with Gerrit Cole, who has been on the disabled list since June 11. He is expected to return sometime shortly after the All-Star break.

Cole was in the midst of putting together a good season when he got hurt, but as the staff ace, he needs to be even better for the Pirates in the second half.

Advertise with us

His past three starts were not good by his standards, and perhaps that had a lot to do with his injured triceps. Hopefully, once he is healthy, he returns and becomes the anchor, the stopper, the stud — whatever you want to call him — that stabilizes the rotation.

Next up is Francisco Liriano, who has not been good by anyone’s standards.

Maybe Liriano is hurt, maybe he is old, or maybe he is just in the midst of a rough stretch and needs to find his way out of it.

I’m not a doctor, trainer or a manager but if I were king of the world he would be put on the disabled list with some sort of “discomfort” until after the All-Star break as well.

That would mean he would miss his next two starts, but it would give him a chance to get himself together.

Advertise with us

Getting rid of him makes no sense. He has proven to be one of the team’s best pitchers and most reliable players over the past three years.

He has also shown a remarkable ability to figure things out and rebound after a tough stretch. He is way too good of a player to give up on. I’m not sure the path to a wild-card berth is there for the Pirates if he isn’t a part of it.

Francisco Cervelli coming back healthy — which he is expected to do after the break — is a huge part of this equation as well.

Losing Cervelli hurt the Pirates defense, pitching staff and offense. He was hitting only .257, but that is a monster number compared to his three replacements: Chris Stewart (.205), Jacob Stallings (.125) and Eric Kratz (.059). Getting Cervelli back will lift this team in just about every category.

And then there is, of course, Andrew McCutchen, who is hitting .239 and looking lost at the plate far more often than I can ever remember.

Advertise with us

It’s clear McCutchen is struggling in every way possible, but like Liriano — and like Clint Hurdle likes to say — you have to trust the talent and trust that a player with McCutchen’s talent will eventually figure it out.

A bonus key to the second half of the season is Jameson Taillon, who showed against Seattle and earlier in June against the Mets what kind of pitcher he can be. If Taillon can be as good as he has already proven he can be, the Pirates can make some noise in the second half.

I know it isn’t as sexy as making all kinds of moves, but the answers are, for the most part, already on the roster.

It’s hard to win when your best players are either injured or aren’t playing like your best players. While we like to lose our minds about guys like Kyle Lobstein, Cory Luebke and Kratz not getting it done, those guys aren’t really all that relevant.

If Cole, Liriano and Taillon become the three best pitchers on the staff, as they should be, do you think that changes the outlook of this starting staff?

Advertise with us

If that happens and Jeff Locke keeps being Jeff Locke — giving a great effort four out of every seven starts — it almost doesn’t even matter who’s the last starter.

The starting staff improving would improve the bullpen. That means more of Neftali Feliz/Tony Watson and Mark Melancon to clean up the end of the games and less of the current middle reliever abyss.

Honestly, it sounds like pie in the sky nonsense, but we always look for complex answers and solutions when the answers are usually right in front of us.

The Pirates can do all the tinkering they want, and it won’t make a difference if their best players aren’t their best players — specifically Cole, Liriano, Cervelli, McCutchen and Taillon — in the second half of the season.

Follow Paul Zeise on Twitter @PaulZeise.