The best laid plans at the U.S. Open went out the window Thursday just about the time the third or fourth (I lost count) storm cell blew through Oakmont and caused a delay in the action and then ultimately had play suspended.
It is a shame, too, because the golf course was in immaculate condition, and this was going to set up as an exciting tournament just because it looked like it was going to be such a challenging track to play.
But that’s not really what is troublesome. Rain, bad weather, wind — those things happen to outdoor sports, especially here in Western Pennsylvania, and so the players will adjust and figure out how to play a little different game than they would have had the course been dry.
The troublesome thing, though, is that the USGA is clearly so hell-bent on finishing this thing on Sunday that it has lost its minds and has basically made it a very unfair tournament for the guys who were supposed to be in the second wave Thursday.
Andrew Landry was in the morning wave Thursday and got his entire round, except for one putt, done Thursday. He showed up Friday and made that last putt and was the clubhouse leader at 4-under 66.
He also is now done for the day.
Read More
Meanwhile, guys who were in the second wave — Jason Day, for instance — will play rounds today, finish it, and then have to go right back on the course and play another 18 (or as many as he can get in) because he was supposed to be in the first wave Friday.
I understand that the way most tournaments are set up is if you play in the afternoon Thursday, you play in the morning Friday and vice versa, but keeping that format after a monsoon wreaked havoc on the schedule is silly.
And not fair.
At this point, there were only two ways the schedule could have been done to make it fair, and both are very easy and realistic options:
1) Have everyone finish out their first round Friday and the guys who played in the morning Thursday, they go back and play their second round. It would mean a guy like Landry would only be playing 18 holes (plus a putt), and some others may have to play 22 or 23 holes. But nobody is playing 32 or 33 while others just putt once and go home until Saturday.
It makes sense especially since the guys who played in the morning Thursday would get to play in the afternoon Friday — and then the guys who played primarily Friday morning (because they played very little Thursday) wouldn’t have to play until Saturday morning. That would at least make it a little bit more fair in these first two days. Saturday, you will still have to have some guys play 36 and other play 18 because you will start the third round Saturday afternoon unless…
2) The USGA just sucked it up and committed to playing the final round on Monday. Yeah, there’s TV ratings and all that good stuff, but rain changed all that and nothing is going to be perfect. The integrity and fairness of the tournament should be the No. 1 concern, and the best way to make it fair is start the third round on Sunday and then the fourth round on Monday. That way, nobody is playing more or fewer holes than anyone else, and your final two rounds can be played the way they are supposed to be played. TV ratings on Sunday are always the big factor, and also the USGA doesn’t want to push this an extra day. But again, nobody really wanted there to be so much rain that a few guys named Noah started thinking about building a big boat, either.
You can’t control the weather, and thus you can’t really control the conditions of the course and the fact that spectators will be walking in soupy, sloppy mud covered in mulch for the next few days.
That part of the competition is what makes golf great — man versus Mother Nature, and the course at Oakmont Country Club more often than not wins, no matter the conditions.
But what the USGA could control is the fairness of the competition, and instead of doing the right thing by the players, it chose not to.
The USGA needed to a better job here to make sure that the tournament was fair, and it just didn’t get it done.
I’m sure the tournament will still be fun to watch, compelling and have some fun story lines. You can call it exciting, riveting, thrilling and just about any other word.
Just don’t call it fair, because it isn’t.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.