Jim Rutherford said today that in a perfect world the Penguins would be able to keep both Marc-Andre Fleury and Matt Murray for next season, and yes, that’s indeed true.

It would be great if the Penguins could keep them both and split their starts and also sing a few rounds of “Kumbaya” between games.

That’s what a perfect world would look like, but what about the world of sports is ever perfect? More importantly, except for some pie in the sky sentiment about Fleury’s value to the locker room, what about keeping both goaltenders would really make much sense?

That’s why the Penguins should sit down with Fleury as soon as possible and figure out what teams he would be OK playing for and then work to trade him there.

Advertise with us

It just won’t work keeping both goaltenders around, and this idea of splitting starts is silly. This is, and should be, Murray’s team now.

There are times when two starting goaltenders can co-exist, but not when one has been the starter for a long time and the other is a young prodigy. The reality is that in a salary-cap sport, it is a luxury most teams cannot afford.

True, the Penguins are in a pretty good place salary-wise, as Fleury is due to make about $5.75 million and Murray is due to make about $950,000. If you combine those salaries, it adds up to about $6.7 million — still less than the salary of any of the top four goaltenders.

Financially, it could work, but it still doesn’t make sense.

The backup goaltender would be fifth-highest paid on the team and would be among the top 14 goaltenders in the league.

Advertise with us

There is risk involved in letting Fleury go, as Murray could get hurt or show he was a one-hit wonder. I’m trusting Rutherford and Mike Sullivan that Murray is as good as he played in the playoffs and is capable of becoming a franchise goaltender.

If that’s the case — and it certainly seems to be — there is no reason to keep Fleury around because you can always find a much cheaper veteran backup for when Murray needs a break.

Murray could get hurt, but so could Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang and just about every other player. You can’t make roster decisions like this one on the off chance a player may suffer a season-ending injury.

Fleury has a limited no-trade clause, but I don’t see any scenario where he signs to play 20-25 games as the backup. I’ve been told by several people I trust that he wants to be a starter and is willing to go elsewhere to achieve that.

That means his no-trade clause shouldn’t be much of an obstacle to find a suitor. With the cap money it would free up, the Penguins could shore up some other areas, maybe another defenseman or a wing for Malkin’s line.

Advertise with us

Rutherford didn’t commit to trading Fleury, but if you read between the lines, even he knows it isn’t very realistic to think that the situation can work well.

“I have not met with Marc yet to see what he’s feeling. I have not seen the expansion guidelines yet, so I don’t want to get too far ahead of myself,” Rutherford said. “I’m going to say the obvious. It’s a great situation that we have good goalies, but it could be a tough situation going forward.”

Fleury is an extremely popular player in this town (though some Penguins fans have soured on him) and even more so in that locker room, so watching him suit up for another team would be tough — but life goes on.

He proved he’s a team player and a great teammate by the way he handled himself in the playoffs. After all, he lost his job because he got hurt, which doesn’t happen all that often in sports.

He never pouted, he never made it about him, he never made demands. All he did was say all the right things, root for his teammates and help Murray anyway he could. But that was for a very short window, and the team was winning, so it would have been foolish for him to act any other way.

Advertise with us

I don’t think it would be nearly as easy for him to be a good soldier in the regular season, especially if Murray hit a slump and the team lost a few games in a row.

Competitors want to be the guy, and when you have been the guy for so long, it’s hard to sit on the sidelines night in and night out.

I love Fleury the player as much as anyone. I’m one of his biggest fans in town and think he has been an outstanding player for the Penguins for a lot of years.

I understand the sentiment that the Penguins should keep him and try to make it work — but that isn’t realistic, so it’s time for him to go.