The most compelling storyline at this week’s U.S. Open at Oakmont Country Club doesn’t involve the young guns of golf and their quest to be the best in the world.
Nah, for me it involves two of the best players in the world who are searching for redemption of sorts. This tournament has represented heartbreak for both over the years.
Phil Mickelson is an all-timer. He has won five majors and accomplished pretty much everything — except win the U.S. Open.
He has been close, finishing second six times and letting a win slip away in 2006 at Winged Foot, but for the most part this event has been the heartbreak hotel.
Given his age — he turns 46 Thursday — it’s pretty clear that his window to win one is closing extremely fast. This week at Oakmont is one of his last realistic shots.
Dustin Johnson, who holds the title as best golfer in the world to not win a major, is only 31, so he has some more time to shed that title, but the clock is already ticking.
Read More
Like Mickelson, Johnson has experienced plenty of heartbreaks in the U.S. Open and has had a couple slip through his hands on Sunday.
The one that is most fresh is last year at Chambers Bay, where he sat about 13 feet away from the 18th hole Sunday with a chance for an eagle and the championship.
Johnson, though, missed it and left himself with a 4-footer that would have at least locked him into a first-place tie with Jordan Spieth. He blew that one, too, and finished second.
Mickelson and Johnson are among the most talented players in the field and have had lots of success, but they would be lying if they told you that winning this week wouldn’t be something special.
That’s why neither one of them tried to downplay the significance of this event, though Johnson was a little more dismissive of the idea that he needs to win one of these events soon than Mickelson was.
Both understand a win here would be career-changing, putting them in a different category and rewriting their narratives.
A win in the U.S. Open would complete Mickelson’s career grand slam and put him in the exclusive company of only five other golfers (in the Masters era). Their names are all consider gold royalty: Jack Nicklaus, Tiger Woods, Ben Hogan, Gary Player and Gene Sarazen.
Mickelson, who is competing in his 26th U.S. Open, understands how big one win would be.
“I could BS you and tell you I don’t think about it,” Mickelson said today. “No, I think about it all the time. This is the tournament I want to win the most to complete the four majors.
“There’s no question that starting this year and every year here forward until I ultimately win this tournament, it will be my biggest thought, my biggest focus because I view those players that have won the four majors totally different than I view all the others.”
Johnson is only 31, so he still has plenty of time to win his first major, but his clock is ticking too because the field is getting younger every year.
The best golfers on tour right now are Rory McIIroy (27), Jordan Spieth (22), Jason Day (28) and Rickie Fowler (27). All of them are younger than Johnson, so they aren’t going anywhere any time soon.
Johnson still has a lot of golf to play and will be a contender for a long time. But the longer he goes without winning one, the longer he has to carry the weight of being “Mr. Close But No Cigar.”
Nobody knows that better than Mickelson, and he was asked about the pressure mounting on Johnson as he continues to chase his first major.
“The longer it goes, the more challenging it becomes,” Mickelson said. “But [Johnson] still has a few more years before it’s crunch time. But the longer it goes, the more you start thinking about it.
“The more it’s discussed, the more you start thinking about it. The challenge is really on Friday and Saturday nights, when you have opportunities and you start putting that self-imposed pressure, because then you never play free. You never play with a kind of a loose attitude, where we all play our best.”
If there is anything inspirational that Johnson could draw from Mickelson’s career, it’s that Mickelson didn’t win his first major title until he was 33.
Johnson’s three-putt meltdown on 18 last year has been a topic of discussion this week, but he says he has put that behind him.
“I feel I handled that situation good,” Johnson said. “It wasn’t like I hit bad shots. The greens weren’t as smooth as they could have been. This week, we won’t have to worry about that. If I miss a putt, I can blame myself, not the greens, which I like.
“But really, all I am trying to do is give myself a chance on Sunday.”
Johnson isn’t interested in the legacy discussion. And at his age, he probably doesn’t need to be quite yet. That doesn’t mean he isn’t aware that winning a major — especially at this course — would make his career narrative change completely.
“Yeah, obviously, it would be great,” Johnson said. “I don’t know how much I would think about it, but obviously, it does all kinds of things for you.”
Johnson and Mickelson will be in contention for the title, presumably, but both will have to exorcise demons on the final day if they are to fill the large hole in their resumes.
That’s why while there are many people rooting for a final grouping of Spieth and Day on Sunday, I’m hoping for Johnson and Mickelson because those two aren’t just playing for a title — they are playing for their legacy.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.