I remember a game in 2011 at PNC Park when the Mets left fielder that day was introduced and booed by many of the Pirates faithful in the stands.
His name was Jason Bay.
It made no sense to me then, and it still makes no sense to me now.
There isn’t anything uncommon about fans booing players from opposing teams, and there especially isn’t anything uncommon about fans booing a former player from their favorite team.
But Bay?
He was the best player on those Pirates teams who were DOA — that’s dead on arrival in case you don’t know what those initials mean — and yet, he never complained, was always a class act and made it pretty clear he loved his time with the Pirates.
Read More
He should have been celebrated and appreciated, not booed because his only sin was he played so well he needed to be traded because the team knew they couldn’t pay him anywhere close to his value.
And that brings me to a Mets-Pirates game that will take place tonight at PNC Park and involved the homecoming of another popular former Pirate: Neil Walker.
I am amazed at the fact that there are actually fans out there who have some sort of ill will towards Walker, as if he turned his back on the Pirates and forced them to trade him.
That doesn’t make sense on any level — Walker should be celebrated tonight, embraced and he should always be remembered as one of the group of players that helped turn this franchise’s fortunes around.
Not only should Walker be celebrated by fans, he should be celebrated by the organization, with some sort of video tribute that the Penguins have done so often when one of their popular players makes his return in a different uniform.
It’s clear that there was always friction between Neal Huntington and Neil Walker’s camp. Some of it was business, and some of it may have even been personal.
But Walker never let it affect the way he did his job. He never let it affect the way he dealt fans and never let it affect the way he went about his community service. He was always a great ambassador for the organization and for the city.
And even when it became clear he wasn’t going to be re-signed, he continued to hold out hope that he and the Pirates could work something out.
I actually had fans call my radio show recently when I approached this subject to say, “He deserves to be booed because the Pirates made him an offer and he rejected it. He could have stayed!”
Technically, that is true; the Pirates made him an offer that could have kept him here two extra years, but it wasn’t a fair deal and it was one they didn’t expect him to accept.
It isn’t greedy for an athlete or anyone else to want to be paid their market value — just like it isn’t greedy for an organization to decide they don’t believe an athlete is worth what he is asking for.
That’s called business, and it is how things work in the real world.
Walker’s strained relationship with Huntington should have nothing to do with how fans feel about a player who came into the organization as a catcher and worked hard to become a very good second baseman for the major league team.
When Walker started, the organization was a mess. By the time he was traded, the organization was being celebrated as one of the best in baseball.
And while there were many factors in that, he had a hand in it and was one of the cornerstone players that the Pirates were built around as they began to improve.
Walker was a class act here and is a class act still (I know he took a few veiled shots at Huntington in some interviews since his trade, but again, that has nothing to do with the fans or even the Pirates organization). He always handled himself properly, and he always had time to be a good-will ambassador.
I’m not telling fans how to act — you pay your money for the tickets, do what you like — but I am suggesting that if you choose to boo Neil Walker tonight, it is really pretty dumb.
Walker loves the Pirates, he loves Pittsburgh and he loves the fans here — and that’s really all that should matter to the people who go to the game, not his relationship with the team’s general manager.
And as for the Pirates organization, I get that it wasn’t all warm and fuzzy at the end, but Walker was a player who gave them everything he had both on and off the field and should be given a proper introduction tonight.
A short video tribute, maybe something just to give the fans one last chance to celebrate his career and say thanks for all the great things he did in a Pirates uniform and in the community, is in order.
That’s the right thing to do, and the Pirates as an organization have been very good at doing the right thing in recent years.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.