Marc-Andre Fleury was not very good Sunday night in the Penguins’ 4-3 overtime loss to Tampa Bay in Game 5 of the Eastern Conference final.

He looked rusty and like he got worse as the game wore on, not better.

It got to the point in the third period that just about every shot that was sent his way seemed to be an adventure, and it wasn’t a shock that the first shot he faced in overtime went in the goal.

But he wasn’t the reason the Penguins lost. I thought the correct move would have been to stick with Matt Murray, but there is no way to say definitively that if Murray had played, the Penguins would have won.

Advertise with us

Frankly, if we are looking for reasons for the loss, the list starts with the overlooked fact that the other team is pretty good too.

Beyond that, Kris Letang stunk out loud, Evgeni Malkin was mostly a non-factor, Sidney Crosby didn’t contribute much, the Beau Bennett move didn’t do much and there were too many defensive breakdowns in front of Fleury to count.

So, if we’re looking for someone to blame, the list is long.

But that’s not the real issue nor is it the point. The real issue is the Penguins are facing elimination in Game 6 and now have two goaltenders who have given up four goals apiece in their previous start.

The question before Mike Sullivan is simple: which goaltender do you start for Game 6?

Advertise with us

My answer for every other game leading up to Game 5 Sunday night was Matt Murray. He was playing well, he was winning and he wasn’t rusty.

However, if I was the coach, I would start Marc-Andre Fleury in Game 6 for all the reasons Sullivan and company gave for playing him in Game 5.

It’s the only logical answer, the only answer that would make sense.

Think about it. Fleury was the starter, is the most experienced goaltender on the team, has won a Stanley Cup and has won a ton of playoff hockey games.

The only reason he stopped playing was injury, and by the time he was healthy, Murray was on a roll and leading the team to playoff wins against the Rangers and Capitals.

Advertise with us

There was no reason to go back to Fleury for most of the playoffs, no reason for a change because the team was winning and Murray was playing with a lot of confidence.

Now that the move was made — regardless of how you feel about it — Sullivan needs to stay the course and bet on his experienced goaltender to lead the Penguins to a championship.

Everybody knew he would be rusty, regardless of when he came back, and he was indeed rusty Sunday night. But now that first game back is behind him, and one would figure he will get much better in his second start.

Obviously, there are no guarantees, and maybe Fleury will struggle again in Game 6. But in choosing to play him in Game 5, Sullivan has really left himself no choice.

Fleury was chosen for Game 5 because the Penguins decision-makers believe he is the better goaltender of the two and his experience is too significant to overlook. And if that was the answer going into Game 5, it has to be the answer going into Game 6 now that he has one game under his belt and is presumably back into the routine of playing.

Advertise with us

Putting him back on the bench now would make absolutely no sense — unless the Penguins brass believes Murray is the better goaltender, in which case, playing Fleury in Game 5 made no sense.

Of course, let’s be honest. If the defense in front of the goaltender doesn’t get better than it was in Game 5, Sullivan could start Jeff Zatkoff and it wouldn’t matter because the Penguins aren’t going to win.

This series is far from over, and the Penguins can certainly still win it, but they need to play better than they have for five of the past six periods. Even then, they might still need their goaltender to stand on his head and steal a game.

At this point, the goaltender who seems most capable of doing that is the one who has already proven he can, and that’s why it has to be Marc-Andre Fleury.

Follow Paul Zeise on Twitter @PaulZeise.