The Penguins are not in a must-win situation tonight against Tampa in Game 2 of the Eastern Conference final, contrary to some people’s belief.

Sure, it would behoove the Penguins to win and avoid falling into a 2-0 hole, especially with the next two games scheduled to take place in Tampa.

But if they lose tonight, it doesn’t mean the series is over as the only must-win games in the playoffs are elimination games.

Which brings me to this: Mike Sullivan still has a little bit of time to try and figure out what his best lineup is. And there is no question that Olli Maatta, if healthy, is one of his six (actually two) best defensemen.

Advertise with us

That’s why, even though Maatta hasn’t played well of late, he should still be in the lineup tonight unless, like I said, he isn’t healthy.

It seems as if Sullivan is going in a different direction. Reports from the morning skate indicate Maatta will be a healthy scratch and Justin Schultz instead will get the nod.

I understand it, but I think that is a mistake.

Maatta doesn’t seem to be playing at a high level, he seems to be a hair slower than he should be and he doesn’t seem to be reacting to plays like we know he can. But, he is still a guy who is considered one of the best and most talented young defensemen in the world. If you’re going to bet on someone, always bet on talent.

Maatta drew Sullivan’s ire in Game 1, when he was beaten by Alex Killorn on the Lightning’s first goal of a 3-1 win. That, apparently, was the final straw that led him to the bench.

Advertise with us

Sullivan is making what most consider the safe play by putting Schultz in the lineup.

That’s unfortunate.

Schultz is only 25, and so he is too young to be considered a journeyman, but let’s be honest, he already has the resume of a guy who looks like he will be a journeyman by the time it is all said and done. His ceiling seems to be somewhere between the fifth and seventh defensemen for most of his career. He will be a guy who moves around often because he is known as a “professional player who can get the job done” but not much more.

Despite all the talk about how responsible and disciplined he is as a defenseman, his career plus-minus is minus-71.

You know something that Kris Letang, Brian Dumoulin, Ben Lovejoy, Trevor Daley and even Olli Maatta all have in common?

Advertise with us

All of them have a positive plus-minus for their careers, which means that statistic isn’t totally meaningless. Also, they’re all pretty good at helping their team stop the other team from scoring.

Schultz will stay at home and not take chances, and, theoretically, that means that he may not add much, but he isn’t likely to be out of position or get beat for goals.

Maatta needs to play much better, we all know that, but here’s the thing: unlike Schultz, Maatta can play much better than he is.

Given his upside and what he brings when he is playing at the top of his game, if it’s me coaching, I’m rolling the dice and giving him another shot to get it right.

But that’s just me.

Advertise with us

If you put two players in front of me and both have proven they can get the job done and one has far more upside than the other, I’m almost always gambling on potential.

Now, if Maatta still is not 100 percent healthy, if there are some things lingering we don’t know about — and watching him play recently, that really does seem to be the case — that’s a different story.

But the way that NHL teams report injuries, we will never know the truth on that, so we must assume he is healthy.

And if he’s healthy, he needs to play at least one more game before Sullivan goes to Schultz.

Follow Paul Zeise on Twitter @PaulZeise.