When bartender Shirl Mahoney retired, she told people the last thing she wanted to do was sit around the house growing old. She was true to her word. When she saw an ad for a 5K race in her town of South Park, she signed up — even though the only running she’d ever done was behind the bar.
She ran-walked her way to first place in her division and was instantly hooked. She’s done nearly 200 more races since.

Enter our Pittsburgh Marathon special section
Shadyside resident Jerry Agin already had amassed a medal collection by the time Mrs. Mahoney pinned on her race first bib. A trail runner who’s happiest dashing around with the Hash House Harriers, he has twice finished a 100-mile endurance event. He’s also run more than a dozen marathons, including eight of the past nine Pittsburgh Marathons.
Both seniors will be at the start when the starting pistol goes off on May 6 for the 10th anniversary Pittsburgh race. Mrs. Mahoney, who’s 75 and signed up for the half-marathon, will be the oldest female competitor. Mr. Agin, 76, will be the oldest local male marathoner. Their plans of attack couldn’t be more different.
The Pittsburgh Marathon Cavalry: 10 Years. 10 Stories.
Everybody wants that medal
Read More
Mrs. Mahoney grew up in the city’s Allentown neighborhood. She started bartending a couple of years after graduating from St. Canice High School in Knoxville in 1961 and loved it. For 30 years she crafted cocktails at bars around town, including at Scoglio, a white-tablecloth Italian restaurant in Fifth Avenue Place, Downtown. She retired in 2003.
Being on her feet all day, she says, gave her an excuse not to exercise: She got her workout at work. “You had to hustle or they’d let you go.”
She did every local 5K she could find after her first race. She moved on to out-of-town races, including half-marathons in Las Vegas, Cleveland and Niagara Falls. She also traveled to Washington, D.C., to compete in the Army 10 miler.
Running races, she says, invigorates her. There’s the thrill of the crowd. It’s fun to travel to different communities. And she is addicted to the tangible reminders of her effort. Everybody, she says, wants that medal or trophy after crossing the finish. Hers are displayed in a glass curio in her basement. Her friend Linda Adams, who’s 80 and still runs 5Ks, catalogs all of her race bibs into two huge binders.
She’s also made so many new friends through racing. Sometimes, they cross the finish line together holding hands, she says.
Mrs. Mahoney still is competitive. She gets mad if she doesn’t place in her age group. She bristles over running 20 races last year and coming home with only 19 medals.
Unlike most half-marathoners, Mrs. Mahoney doesn’t train — she just shows up and runs. She walks, up to seven miles most days at South Park. When people ask why she doesn’t practice, she replies that it’s boring. But on race day, “I get there and get psyched up.”
Running After Retirement: 10 Years. 10 Stories.
She gets so excited, says her husband, Pat, she could lose a foot in the middle of a race and not even know it.
“There’s all those people cheering you,” says Mrs. Mahoney. “Sometimes I look in the mirror and look old, but I don’t feel old.”
It’s about having fun, not breaking records
Mr. Agin grew up in New Jersey and moved to Pittsburgh in 1979 to help establish The Robotics Institute at Carnegie Mellon University. He started running in his late 30s, he says, because he wanted to be healthier. He kept with it because “it’s fun,” and he was blessed with the right genes to be very good at it.
He started running competitively with short-distance races. He did his first marathon in Pittsburgh in 1985 and got into trail running in a big way a few years later. He finished his first ultra marathon — California’s 100-mile Western States Endurance Run — in 1990 and liked it so much he did another two years later in Virginia. He now has dozens of ultra and regular marathons under his belt.
He likes running the Pittsburgh Marathon, he says, because it’s familiar and has terrific crowd support. Spectators love him, too, because he has so much fun — he toots tunes on a bugle as he races. The tradition started when he joined the Pittsburgh Hash House Harriers. Hashers like to make noise, he says, and he just happened to play trumpet as a kid. “I give my energy to the crowd, and they give it back to me,” he says.
Unlike Mrs. Mahoney, he does train. He wants to do well even though he doesn’t keep track of his weekly miles and rests between workouts. He takes time off when injured. And he runs socially whenever possible.
While doing well in a race is a validation, it’s never the prime reason he runs. A marathon is a significant challenge, he says, “and a denial of aging.”
Mr. Agin is going into this year’s marathon with a confidence builder: He finished the Mohican 50K in Loudonville, Ohio, on April 14 in 8:19.
He attributes his longevity in the sport to having the right genes. Illness and major injuries have bypassed him. Because he’s small, there’s less stress on the bones and muscles and sinews.
Some people might do the same things he does and get different results, he says. “So I consider myself very fortunate.”
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.