The United Bid Committee announced Wednesday that 2026 World Cup matches will not come to Pittsburgh. It may still end up in peer cities such as Cincinnati, Kansas City, Las Vegas, Nashville, Minneapolis, Salt Lake City and Tampa. But we’re out of the running.

The reasons why amount to a chicken-or-egg question of what needs to come first for soccer to grow in Western Pa.: fan interest or investment from the sport?

Pittsburgh’s negatives as a soccer city are obvious. It already has three long-established professional sports teams gobbling up the entertainment dollars in a media market ranked No. 23 nationally. That’s to say nothing of three major college programs ringing the area. It lacks a substantial population of Latinos, who MLS view as elemental to the sport's success in the U.S. And it doesn’t particularly care for the minor-league Riverhounds, who are drawing fewer than 3,000 fans per game to Highmark Stadium this season.

It’s easy to end the conversation there. But one could have made many of the same arguments against bringing an NHL franchise here 50 years and five Stanley Cups ago. Pittsburgh also has good stories to tell any sport willing to make a serious effort here.

Advertise with us

For one, the city has supported soccer when the sport has delivered events commensurate with the locals’ big-league tastes.

Yes, Riverhounds attendance is bad, worse than in true minor-league markets such as Tulsa, Okla., Reno, Nev., Rochester, N.Y., Bethlehem, Pa., and Harrisburg. But Pittsburgh has virtually no history as a minor-league town, no stomach for proving its mettle the way, say, other United Soccer League cities such as Orlando, Fla., have in the recent past.

When soccer does stage premiere events here, though, people show up. A crowd of 34,347 turned out to see Manchester City top AC Milan in a matchup of European clubs here in 2014. Even more folks — 44,028 to be exact — were in attendance the following year when the U.S. women’s national team stopped in for an exhibition against Costa Rica after winning the World Cup.

To put those crowds in context, Minneapolis — newly a Major League Soccer city — drew fewer fans for its leg of that 2014 tour by European clubs through the U.S. Just 36,170 showed up to Soldier Field to see a similar game in massive Chicago. And just 32,869 fans were at Camping World Stadium in Orlando — supposedly the hottest soccer market going — later in the U.S. women’s team’s victory tour.

Pittsburgh also has a richer sports culture than most cities its size. Add up the professional sports titles won in all of those cities named above — still possibilities to welcome the World Cup — and they only tie Pittsburgh by itself, 16-16.

Advertise with us

That success has created an environment in which sports are moreso a lifestyle than entertainment option. Stage any big event here, and the city has shown people will turn out, whether it’s the NCAA men’s basketball tournament, an NHL outdoor game or, heck, the Bassmaster Classic.

Maybe soccer isn’t ready to bet on that reputation with a crown jewel like a World Cup bid. That’s understandable given Pittsburgh’s negatives, and frankly, it’ll be a surprise if more than one or two of those other mid-size cities end up getting games for similar reasons.

Still, it’s worth acknowledging on this occasion that some of Pittsburgh’s shortcomings as a soccer city fall on the sport itself.

Interest is a two-way street, and as long as the soccer menu here is a minor-league team and a worthy exhibition once every blue moon, Pittsburghers are understandably going to treat that like the sideshow it is. Beef up the offerings with a World Cup qualifier or an MLS team, and soccer folks might be surprised with the rewards they can reap here.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.