The Penn State basketball team’s biggest problem this season wasn’t a lack of talent.
The Nittany Lions boasted the Big Ten’s leading scorer in D.J. Newbill, and nine of their 15 conference losses came by a margin of seven points or fewer. Those are reflections of a team that had the pieces to compete and win almost every time it took the floor.
No, their biggest problem in staggering to an 18-16 finish after a promising 12-1 start was actually a stunning lack of discipline and impulse control that mired them in avoidable losing streaks.
One big problem was shot selection. Penn State launched the third-most 3-pointers in the conference, despite the fact they were only 11th-best at converting as a percentage. A smart team probably would have figured out that taking such low-percentage shots so often is a bad idea. Not this group!
Instead, the Lions played like a collection of hormone-addled middle school ballhogs who think they’re better than they are. It was truly a parade of arrogant crap chucking that cheated them out of a lot of points they might have scored otherwise by making an extra pass in search of higher percentage interior shots.
This becomes clear when you look at their passing numbers. Penn State finished with the worst assists-per-game average in the conference at 9.9, in part because so many possessions ended in dead-on-arrival long ones.
And even when the Lions did try to move the ball, they were sloppy, finishing with the third-most turnovers in the league on their way to an underwater assist-to-turnover ratio of 0.81, also a league low. Many of their turnovers were of the maddening variety, passes tossed dangerously cross-court or carelessly into opponents’ grasp in search of a highlight-reel dimes.
That’s characteristic of a group that plays more like a collection of dudes trying to be heroes than a cohesive unit. And it reflects a cavalier attitude that stands in stark contrast to Iowa, a team that proved to be Penn State’s peer in terms of talent in splitting their season series.
The Hawkeyes were actually worse than the Lions in 3-point shooting percentage, finishing 12th in the conference. But in a display of commendable self-awareness, they also took second-fewest triples.
Rather than heave bricks, they moved the ball around well, finishing tied for fifth in assists per game. And they were more responsible, too, achieving a 1.27 assist-to-turnover mark.
Their result was a 21-11 record and a No. 7 seed in the NCAA tournament while Penn State players will watch from the couch. The Lions had the potential to be right there with them. Some of those close losses could have become close wins with just an extra smart possession or two per game.
But those smarter possessions didn’t happen, and some responsibility for that has to fall on coach Patrick Chambers, now four years into his Happy Valley tenure.
To be sure, he’s done some great things in building the program, from attracting Newbill to signing the most highly touted recruiting class in program history set to arrive next fall. He’s also fostered a defensive intensity that’s gone a long way toward mitigating those offensive warts.
And while it’d be incorrect to say his talent is the biggest problem, it’d also be unfair to pretend he has it in the abundance that Big Ten powerhouses such as Wisconsin and Michigan State do.
But none of that is an excuse to allow an undisciplined, unfocused and frankly selfish brand of offensive basketball permeate the program. As a coach, it’s incumbent upon him to make sure his players understand their strengths and weaknesses, both as individuals and as a team.
It’s not outwardly clear he’s doing that very well right now. So as Chambers moves into year five, the expectation has to be that he get more out of his players, rather than simply recruit players with more.
Newbill, his former teammate and NBA point guard Tim Fazier and this incoming recruiting class show that Penn State broadly and Chambers specifically can get good players into Happy Valley. That hasn’t always been the case in the past, and it’s a tempting crutch to fall back when seasons like this one don’t live up to expectations.
It can’t be a crutch anymore. The talent is there. Newbill and Frazier were truly all-time greats.
Their talent was simply wasted. And if Penn State doesn’t tighten up its free-wheeling approach soon, that will be a rap Chambers can’t recruit himself out of.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com or Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.