March might be mostly about the Madness, but it’s also fantasy baseball draft season, which means a lot of Pittsburghers are mulling the question of how to regard their favorite Pirates.
The hometown players are typically the ones fans know best and are predisposed to see promise for. You can use this to your advantage by seeing value where others don’t. But you also have to be careful not to let your emotional attachments cloud your judgment and lead you to overvaluing certain guys doomed to be busts.
It’s a tricky dance, one the following cheat sheet should help you navigate with a little help from the FantasyPros.com composite ratings, which mash together dozens of experts’ player rankings for a useful average of how a player is generally regarded.
Are your favorites ranked too high or too low? That’s ultimately up to you to decide, but here’s one man’s guide to getting the most possible bang in selecting (or avoiding) your fantasy Bucs.
C Francisco Cervelli and C Chris Stewart
We’re still not sure exactly how they’ll split the catching duties this season, and until we are, they’re definitely not worth drafting. Cervelli’s bat has a little pop in it and might be worth stashing in deeper formats if he emerges as more of an everyday option. But under most circumstances, you’ll want both guys to prove their worth before picking them up off the waiver wire. Composite positional rankings: Cervelli, 37; Stewart, 57
1B Pedro Alvarez
Unlike the Pirates, you don’t have to count on him this season, as there will be plenty of more consistent options on draft boards. We saw his upside when he led the National League in homers two years ago, and his eligibility at third base — where his bat plays a little better —adds to his value. So he should be drafted. But don’t touch him before the bench portion of the program and have safer options lined up at both first and third base, because 2014 laid bare how maddeningly inconsistent he can be. Composite positional ranking: First base, 33. Third base, 21.
2B Neil Walker
Coming off a 2014 season in which he showed a lot of power, he’ll be more attractive than normal in the fantasy drafts. This may cause others, especially Pittsburghers, to reach for him early. But his injury history is a concern and he will be hard pressed to repeat a career year, so Walker is probably best valued as a mid-round pick, where you can project him for solid production relative to his position and still invest earlier picks in bigger difference makers. Composite positional raking: 10.
3B/utility Josh Harrison
His positional versatility — he’ll have 2B, 3B, RF and LF eligibility — can give you a lot of options if he comes anywhere close to putting up the numbers he did last season. Some might fall in love with this and take him as high as the fifth or sixth round in standard leagues. Don’t be that person, but definitely keep an eye on him as you move into the middle rounds. If you can get him there, you’ll be freer to take some gambles later in the draft, knowing Harrison should be able to plug holes if a riskier pick flops. Composite positional ranking: Third base, 15. Second base, 15. Outfield, 36.
SS Jung Ho Kang/Jordy Mercer
Because it’s uncertain at this point who will get most of the plate appearances at shortstop, you’re probably going to want to avoid drafting either guy ahead of the late rounds, if at all. Mercer’s bat was playable after his disastrous start to last season. And, enigma that he is, Kang’s power could quickly make him playable if he slides into an everyday role. But at this point, you just don’t know. Taking either with any more than a flier would be a bad idea at this point. Composite positional rankings: Kang, 23; Mercer, 25.
OF Starling Marte
His streakiness at times last season has the potential to mask his value a little, so if you’re up for a gamble, maybe wait to see if he drops past the first few rounds, after which he’d be a steal. He wouldn’t be a bad pick earlier than that, though, so don’t wait around if you really want him. His eligibility at center and left field in those formats is a plus. Composite positional ranking: Outfield, 16 (No. 6 among OFs with LF and CF eligibility.)
OF Andrew McCutchen
If you have the first or second overall pick, I’d recommend grabbing either Mike Trout or Clayton Kershaw. Beyond that, you need to select McCutchen if he’s available. His track record speaks for itself. Composite positional ranking: Outfield, 2.
OF Gregory Polanco
Most everyone expects him to be better in his second season, but it’s far from clear how much better. That uncertainty will hurt his value, but sets him up to be an excellent sleeper. If you’re feeling comfortable with the first two outfielders you pick, I wouldn’t hesitate to take a gamble with Polanco if the pickings are getting slim toward the late middle rounds. At the very least, pick him early in the bench stages. Composite positional ranking: 40.
SP Gerrit Cole
He’s my pick for the Pirate Pittsburghers are most likely to reach for at their peril this year. With an injury-riddled 2014 behind him, it seems there’s a prevailing feeling that this is the season the former No. 1 pick realizes his potential as a dominant No. 1 starter. That doesn’t mean it’d be smart to draft him with that expectation. If he’s around by the sixth or seventh round, then you want to start thinking about selecting him as the solid No. 2 starter with upside that he’s proven to be. But drafting him with the Kershaws and Madison Bumgarners of the world risks getting sucked into the hometown guy’s hype vortex. Composite positional ranking, 21.
SP Francisco Liriano
Despite his dominant second half last season and his Cy Young flirtations in 2013, the fantasy gods aren’t high on Filthy Frank this spring. So where the homer in you might be clouding your vision on a guy like Cole, it wouldn’t be a terrible idea to trust what you’ve observed in Liriano the past two years and maybe jump on him a little earlier than the later rounds in which he’s projected to go. Composite positional ranking, 47.
SPs A.J. Burnett, Jeff Locke, Vance Worley and Charlie Morton
I’d stay away from all four of these guys for now. Burnett needs to prove he can shake off a terrible 2014, and where the other three fit into the rotation is too nebulous at the moment. They’ll all start as intriguing wire fodder, though. Composite positional rankings: Burnett, 75; Locke, 130, Worley, 140; Morton, 149.
RP Mark Melancon
I’m very much in the school of punting on saves if that’s a category in my league. I’d rather stash starters that have some trade value and then find some high-strikeout relievers on the wire after the draft. But if you want a closer, don’t wait too long to grab Melancon. He’s near the top of the heap at his position, so if names like Craig Kimbrel and Aroldis Chapman begin to go, jump on him. Composite positional ranking, 5.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com or Twitter, @fugimaster24






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.