The Penguins still don’t prioritize the draft.
They put a lot of effort into creating the illusion that they do last spring when they fired Ray Shero, a general manager who presided over many busts and ill-fated sales of picks for rental players on his way to early playoff exits the past five years.
Co-owner Ron Burkle told the Tribune-Review at the time: “We’re a team that’s been talking about finding forwards for Sidney (Crosby) all this time. We haven’t been drafting those forwards, and we’ve given up some younger players along the way. That has to change.”
But that habit hasn’t actually changed under new GM Jim Rutherford.
He gave up the Penguins’ first round pick this year in the January acquisition of left winger David Perron from Edmonton. Last week, he coughed up a fourth-round pick this year and a second-round pick next year to add right winger Daniel Winnik from Toronto. And at yesterday’s trading deadline, he shipped a 2016 pick to St. Louis as part of the trade for defenseman Ian Cole.
Perron’s contract is up after next season, while Winnik (unrestricted) and Cole (restricted) will be free agents this summer. Presumably, they could go the way of Jarome Iginla, Douglas Murray, Marcel Goc, and Lee Stempniak — all of whom were acquired for picks — out of the organization afterward.
Meanwhile, the Penguins’ prospect cupboard will be as empty as ever in their absence. Their only choice before the fifth round of the 2015 draft will come in the second round, and there’s almost no NHL-ready forward talent in the system ready to come up and help the big club in a significant way.
That will leave people muttering familiar complaints about depth in future seasons, because trading draft picks in bulk creates fleeting solutions to problems in the present while compounding them over the long term.
The Penguins’ are already feeling that compounding effect as a result of past trades. The third and fourth lines were lackluster in the playoffs last year, and almost all of the players filling those roles this year are expensive hired guns or trade additions. Beau Bennett is the only regular forward who could be loosely defined as young, home-grown talent.
And yet, the organization still is pressing forward with an old strategy of mortgaging the future to win now.
That’s a problem when you consider Crosby and fellow superstar Evgeni Malkin will go into statistical declines as they get older. While they can probably both still be productive NHL players for the next several years, their primes are closing quickly. They’re going to need more and more help with each passing season.
The Penguins, instead, are setting the team up to be completely bankrupt of internal options to address that, even though surrounding the duo with young players has worked well in the past.
The Stanley Cup-winning team of 2008-2009 had its share of organizational outsiders. But Crosby and Malkin got help from fellow Pittsburgh draftees Jordan Staal, Maxime Talbot and Tyler Kennedy. Those three combined to score 47 goals that year, and Talbot ended up being the hero of the Game 7 win against Detroit in the Stanley Cup Final, scoring both goals.
He was an eighth-round choice, the type of selection the organization has been parting with far too casually of late. This year’s team, let alone future groups, could benefit from young, inexpensive options like him, but won’t because of deals that didn’t ultimately result in more championships.
Look, there’s a good argument to be made that the Penguins need to maximize their chances through trades as much as they can with their stars still in their peak years. There’s no telling how either will age, after all, especially with their injury histories. The next couple seasons may be the best shots they have at a title for some time.
And you can make an equally compelling case that Perron, Winnik and Cole will prove to be better fits than past rentals, address some real needs come playoff time and help the Penguins win a Cup to justify those future pains.
The problem is Burkle himself made a very different case less than a year ago, saying the club needs to emphasize drafting a development to avoid Crosby and Malkin having to wind down their careers with soup cans for linemates.
Allowing his GM to act in direct contradiction of that vision is, at best, sending a muddled message and, at worst, deomonstrating a lack of coherent organizational philosophy.
So if these moves don’t pay off with a Cup victory this year, fans should point the finger all the way to the top for the consequences that will have in the future.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.