Goals per game in the NHL are down about 21 percent this season from when Mario Lemieux led the Penguins to the second of their back-to-back Stanley Cup titles in 1992 — truly a different era. But they’re down 11 percent since latter-day Pittsburgh star Sidney Crosby broke into the league in 2005-2006. And they’re down about 6 percent from when he and sidekick Evgeni Malkin keyed the franchise’s 2009 championship run.

The past four seasons have all seen the lowest goals per game averages since the league returned from the lockout that wiped out the 2004-2005 season.

During this period, Crosby’s points per game average has gone down in each of the past three years, even as he won the NHL scoring title last season and sits a lofty fifth in the scoring race this season. Malkin, meanwhile, has posted two of the lowest points per game averages of his career in the past three campaigns.

So it’s hard to score points in the NHL these days, and it’s getting harder, even if you’re hailed as two of the very best players in the game. And yet it’s rare that point is raised in reference to why the Penguins’ cornerstones aren't performing quite as well as they used to.

Advertise with us

Many will point to the injuries both players have battled in the latter parts of their careers, hinting that scoring explosions loom in a healthy future. Others will complain endlessly about their wingers, insisting that the Penguins are always a trade or two away from getting Crosby, 27, and Malkin, 28, the help they need to turn their declines around.

Both of those theories are definitely relevant. But with the end of both players’ primes rapidly approaching — only six players in history have led the league in scoring after age 30 — it’s probably time to stop expecting them to defy a leaguewide scoring decline and play dramatically better than they have in the recent past.

That’s not to say they can’t be very good players, if not the best players in the league, over the next three to four years. Crosby outscored the field by 17 points in 2013-2014, a year in which his points per game average dropped off a good deal from 1.56 the year before to 1.30.

And that shouldn’t give them immunity from criticism of their playoff performances, especially after Crosby’s one-goal disaster against the Columbus Blue Jackets and New York Rangers last spring.

It’s simply an acknowledgement that in this goal-scoring environment, the dominance we’ve seen from Lemieux in the past and even Malkin/​Crosby recently is going to be increasingly difficult to reach unless significant rule changes begin freeing things up in the NHL, even if both get better wingers and stay off injured reserve.

Advertise with us

Through Sunday, powerplay opportunities are at their lowest levels since 1977-78 this year at 3.16 per game, per team.

And Dejan Kovacevic of DKonPittsburghSports.com, formerly of the Post-Gazette, recently fingered the proliferation of blocked shots for the scoring declines, noting half of NHL teams blocked at least 1,200 attempts last season compared to just six teams in that freer 2005-2006 campaign. He argued the practice should be outlawed going forward, but there’s no indication commissioner Gary Bettman and Co. are leaning toward that.

In fact, as Kovacevic noted, Bettman has been fairly boastful about the historically low goal scoring we’ve seen recently, telling a crowd in Anaheim that recently retired Teemu Selanne’s record 76 goals in a rookie season “will never be broken.”

Those are just a couple examples of ways Crosby and Malkin are trying to swim upstream in boosting their point totals. And they’re not alone.

Capitals star Alex Ovechkin’s points per game average has dropped to an even 1.00 this year, a second-straight season of decline. Blackhawks stalwart Jonathan Toews is scoring at the slowest clip of his career. And his teammate Patrick Kane is leading the NHL scoring race right now despite scoring about 0.20 points per game fewer than Crosby did in winning the Art Ross trophy last year.

Advertise with us

Consider any of those dropoffs on their own, and sure, maybe they can be explained through individual circumstances, i.e. injuries and teammates. But when you can use five of the biggest names in the game to illustrate a wider decrease in scoring, it’s not a coincidence.

This is the NHL Malkin and Crosby have been given. It's not the point-happy league of the ’90s, and it's not even the friendlier goal-scoring habitat they broke into about a decade ago. It's a rugged place, whether you're a star or a fourth-liner.

Perhaps they can boost production with better teammates, cleaner bills of health and sheer force of will. But expecting that would appear to set fans up for disappointment.

For both players, their respective legacies should be much more tied to winning Stanley Cup titles at this point. It's probably time to get used to everything else.

Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com.