The Pirates’ (pending) re-signing of pitcher Francisco Liriano this week to a three-year, $39 million deal so solidified their starting rotation that it looks like Neal Huntington is finished with his major purchases for the offseason.

The Post-Gazette’s Bill Brink quoted the general manager Tuesday as saying with regard to the rotation: “At this point in time, assuming everything follows through (with Liriano), I would think we'll turn our attention to other resources, to other ways to improve the club.”

He did Wednesday by acquiring a much-needed bullpen lefty from the Philadelphia Phillies in reliever Antonio Bastardo.

And seeing as the everyday lineup remains largely intact from the end of last season – the exceptions being Francisco Cervelli replacing Russell Martin at catcher and Pedro Alvarez likely moving across the diamond from third to first base to replace Ike Davis and Gaby Sanchez — the front office appears to be betting the most efficient upgrades it can get will come simply from the players the Pirates already have being more productive in 2015.

Advertise with us

If you’re a fan of the Wins Above Replacement (WAR) statistic – a popular sabermetric figure that functions as an overall measure of a player’s offensive and defensive performance in comparison to readily available replacement players – then there’s reason to believe the front office is wise to see this upside.

According to Baseball Reference, of Pirates who were in starting roles the past two years and figure to be in similar roles next year, only shortstop Jordy Mercer improved his WAR (by 0.8) in 2014. Alvarez, Liriano, center fielder Andrew McCutchen, left fielder Starling Marte, second baseman Neil Walker, and starting pitchers Jeff Locke, Charlie Morton and Gerrit Cole posted a combined dip of 7.7 WAR.

On top of that, the first base platoon of the now-departed Sanchez and Davis combined to be sub-replacement by .8 WAR, while Gregory Polanco, the right fielder who emerged from the minors in June, was merely at replacement level.

Utilityman Josh Harrison’s 5.0 WAR were an important factor in offsetting some of those losses from 2013 and helping the Pirates slide into the National League wild-card game for a second consecutive year. The contributions of starters Edinson Volquez and Vance Worley were valuable, too, at 2.5 and 1.6 WAR, respectively.

But the fact remains that last season’s Pirates had a lot of key guys regressing at the same time, for a variety of reasons. Statistically speaking, some may have hit career peaks in 2013 and merely fell off closer to their averages. Then, of course, there are injuries that almost every player named above battled at some point in 2014.

Advertise with us

This means that a healthier 2015, or one in which players simply split the difference between their 2013 and 2014 performance levels, should go a long way toward helping the team replace Martin’s departed 5.5 WAR in the aggregate (think Billy Beane in the movie “Moneyball”) and eat into that 2-game edge the St. Louis Cardinals had in the National League Central race.

That’s to say nothing of Polanco’s potential to be, as Huntington told the P-G’s Stephen Nesbitt on Tuesday, “a really good major league player,” or once-and-future Pirates starter A.J. Burnett’s ability to bounce back from a tough 2014 with the Phillies to bolster Pittsburgh’s rotation as he did the year before.

Of course, it’s dangerous to use one statistic, even one as handy as WAR, as the sole indicator for the trajectory of a team. Whether you like to dig deeper into narrower statistics or use an old-school eye test, it’s easy to spot the Pirates’ more micro uncertainties, from Burnett’s health at 38 to Alvarez’s move to first and Cervelli’s lack of experience as an every-day catcher. Beyond that, no one knows what injuries might befall the Bucs over the course of a grueling six-month campaign.

What WAR can show in the macro, however, is that many Pirates in major roles can be better because they have been better.

Huntington’s comments suggest he’s willing to take his chances with that upside and save his resources for a day when the potential for internal progression isn’t quite as apparent.

Advertise with us

He might yet have some big moves left in him. But if they happen, expect they’ll come from a position of confidence rather than desperation.

Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com