Pitt and Penn State could be renewing their rivalry in about three weeks at one of two bowls their respective conferences share tie-ins with: the New Era Pinstripe Bowl in New York’s Yankee Stadium or the Quick Lane Bowl at Detroit’s Ford Field.
But whether that actually happens may not be determined by humans who can look at two 6-6 rivals and determine they’d be a marketable match for games that typically are late-December duds ahead of the marquee New Year’s Day bowl slate.
As the Post-Gazette’s Sam Werner detailed Monday, technicalities might win the day as the ACC's tiered bowl-slotting system could prevent the Pinstripe Bowl — which news services including CBS, FOX Sports, the Sporting News and SB Nation think Penn State is a lock for on the Big Ten side — from selecting the Panthers.
Depending upon the result of this weekend’s ACC championship game between Florida State and Georgia Tech, Pitt could be locked into the ACC's second tier and thus outside the pool the first-tier Pinstripe Bowl can choose from.
Conversely, Penn State could be off the board by the time the Quick Lane Bowl, a lower-tier Big Ten bowl, can select the Nittany Lions to face the Panthers.
This is silly. Especially in a year when both teams struggled at times, a Pitt-Penn State bowl game ahead of the scheduled 2016 resumption of their series would generate a lot of excitement. And most importantly for bowl officials, it’d probably generate strong ticket sales and TV ratings for games that otherwise might get lost in the rush of Christmas weekend.
If conference bowl tie-ins can’t produce a matchup this obvious, then doesn’t it defeat the purpose of having them in the first place?
But wait, it gets worse.
Technicalities might rob Penn State fans of a consolation matchup with Notre Dame, too. The Raleigh News & Observer reported Monday a lottery will determine which ACC first tier bowl can snap up the independent-but-league-affiliated Fighting Irish. This could also preclude the Pinstripe Bowl from picking Notre Dame.
This would be another colossal breakdown in common sense.
The New York Times reported in 2011 that Notre Dame and Penn State are the second- and third-most popular teams in New York City, with more than 400,000 combined fans in the area, to say nothing of Notre Dame’s strong northeastern Pennsylvania following and New York’s proximity to other large Penn State alumni bases.
Matching the schools up at Yankee Stadium would be a huge draw and a lot of fun for fans of two tradition-rich schools that didn’t have a whole lot to be excited about this season. (Notre Dame stumbled from the top 5 in the rankings to finish 7-5.)
But that, like Pitt-Penn State, will be left up to fate and not an ounce of critical thinking by human brains.
The result could very well match the Lions up with the likes of Boston College, Duke or N.C. State in New York. Meanwhile, projections by various services have the Panthers going anywhere from Detroit to play Northwestern or Illinois, the New Orleans Bowl to face UL-Lafayette or something called the Raycom Media Camellia Bowl in Montgomery, Ala., where they’d face Toledo.
Um, I think I’ll stay home and eat the Christmas leftovers, thanks.
Here’s hoping bowl and conference officials access the “duh” complexes in their brains and iron out a way to match Pitt and Penn State — or at least Penn State and Notre Dame — to wrap up this otherwise mediocre season for the local teams with a little sizzle.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.