At his home in Squirrel Hill, Howie Elson watched the College World Series as a man conflicted.

He wanted Arkansas to win, yet he didn’t want Oregon State to lose.

And...

He wanted Oregon State to win, yet he didn’t want Arkansas to lose.

Advertise with us

Let’s explain: Elson's son, Phil, is the award-winning voice of the Razorbacks. His son-in-law, Dan Bartholomae, just completed his first year as a deputy athletic director at Oregon State under former Pitt AD Scott Barnes. Bartholomae worked in the Pitt athletic department the previous 15 years.

Phil and Dan are Allderdice grads. Ditto for Bartholomae's wife Lauren, daughter of Howie and sister of Phil.

"Go RazorBeavs ... Go BeaverHogs."

That’s the amalgamated cheer Howie Elson conjured in keeping loyal to both sides. The series pushed him to the edge of his seat (he listened to Phil's calls via webstream while watching on ESPN) before Oregon State won the third and decisive game, 5-0, on June 28 in Omaha.

Bartholomae and son, Dylan, 8, celebrated the victory in Nebraska, while Lauren, a former Allderdice volleyball player and current yoga instructor, stayed home with daughter Lily, 6, in Corvallis.

Advertise with us

Phil Elson, meantime, closed the broadcast with a call he’s been using since bearing witness to one of the sport's great tragedies.

"Don't forget, it's just game," he said.

Win or lose, he's uttered those words since June of 2007, when minor league first base coach Mike Collbaugh of the Tulsa Drillers was fatally struck by a line drive. Elson called that game for the Class AA Arkansas Travelers, for whom he worked for 14 years.

"It's about keeping things in perspective," said Phil Elson, a Point Park grad and former intern with the Pirates in 1996.

While in Omaha, Phil and Dan caught up at a local chop house for a pre-CWS steak dinner. Dylan Bartholomae spent quality time in the radio booth with uncle Phil, whose children Sadie, 9, and Gabriel, 6, did not make the trip, during a weather delay.

Advertise with us

All the while, Howie, a pediatric dentist who moonlights as a local stage actor and pitcher in over-70 baseball tournaments, listened with angst and excitement.

"Though I have a rooting interest, I watch baseball as someone else watches a play or listens to a symphony," said Elson, a former weekend radio host on KDKA who was known for his "In The Cheap Seats," segment on the John Cigna morning show in the 1980s. "I don't cheer so much as enjoy and appreciate. I love going to the ballpark, but also love watching and listening all by myself, so I don't get disturbed by the noise. ... I watched the (CWS) games by myself or with my wife, Robin."

As a 20-year radio veteran, Phil Elson has called thousands of games. But this was the closest he's been to a championship.

The same could be said of Bartholomae, who worked for nine athletic directors (interim ADs included) in his 15 years at Pitt.

"When Dan got the job at Oregon State, we both talked a lot about how great the baseball teams were at our schools and how great it would be if we both got to the College World Series," Phil Elson said. "So, when the brackets came out, we saw there was a chance that we could play in the championship round. We've both been in the business for a long time, so we know how rare it is to be in the running for a national championship. So, there was a little stroke of luck for this to happen, but it feels like a fulfillment for each of us, too."

Advertise with us

A former compliance officer at Pitt, Bartholomae said, with a laugh, that no wagers were made between he and Phil for the series. Instead, just a lot of banter among the family in group text messages.

He added that it was surreal to think that he and Phil, whom he's known since he first started hanging out at the Elson's home at age 15, would find themselves on opposite sides of such a high-stakes event.

"I've followed Phil's career since Day 1," said Bartholomae, who is four years younger than Phil. "He's worked in Ogden, Utah, and in Stockton, California, and we always listened to his broadcasts on the internet. When he worked for the Arkansas Travelers, we'd go visit him. And when he got the job at Arkansas (as the voice of baseball and women's basketball), it was exciting because I have a lot of friends in the athletic department there. Jeff Long (the former Razorbacks AD) was at Pitt when I was there. It's interesting how things work out sometimes. This has been pretty special."

In a few days, Phil and Dan, who starred in baseball and soccer, respectively, at Allderdice, will be part of a family trip to Hawaii. Dan has bragging rights, at least in theory.

"We'll have fun with it," Phil Elson said.

Advertise with us

As he’s wont to do, Howie Elson put a final spin on the family affair. He shared a quote, from former Yankees pitcher Jim Bouton, that is engraved on his Queens College Baseball Hall-of-Fame plaque.

He believes the words apply to most families.

"You spend a good piece of your life gripping a baseball. And in the end, it turns out that it was the other way around all the time."