They came, thousands strong, searching for a feeling. They skipped work, cut class, whatever it took, ending up together in the cavernous Consol Energy Center, and there, late Thursday afternoon, their moment arrived:

The University of North Carolina at Asheville, a No. 16 seed in the NCAA men's basketball tournament's East Region, led Syracuse University, a No. 1 seed, by a point with less than 10 minutes remaining. The Bulldogs had led Syracuse by four at halftime and were hanging on through sheer will and resourcefulness. Since 1985, when the tournament expanded to 64 teams, no top seed had ever lost to a 16 seed. A handful of potential Cinderellas had teased arenas just like Consol Energy Center into believing in miracles, only to be turned away long before the clock struck midnight.

UNC-Asheville, of the Big South Conference, has an enrollment of 3,107 undergraduates and an endowment of $21 million. Syracuse, of the Big East Conference, has an enrollment of 14,000 undergraduates and an endowment of $966 million.

Their basketball teams belie those harsh class distinctions. UNC-Asheville plays in 3,400-seat Kimmel Arena. Syracuse plays in the 34,000-seat Carrier Dome and won the 2003 national championship. The Orange's roster is stacked with future National Basketball Association players who are just biding time at college before making enough money to secure their futures.

Advertise with us

Yet, with about six minutes left, the score stood gridlocked at 54-54, and the crowd of 18,927 (a record for a college basketball game in Pittsburgh) was starting to sense that reality was beginning to set in. On the court, UNC Asheville felt it, too.

"We were meant to be here," Bulldogs guard Matt Dickey said.

The NCAA tournament, despite the hundreds of millions of dollars that it makes for the organization that runs it, has managed to maintain most of its romance. The first two days -- featuring 16 games each to get the field down to 32 before the weekend -- have become a national holiday of sorts, a celebration of the unpredictability of sport and life.

Late Thursday morning, Centre Avenue buzzed outside Consol with ticket scalpers and fans proudly wearing their team colors. The street signs said, "It's a great day for hockey," and people snapped pictures of the new statue of Penguins legend Mario Lemieux, but this was a day for basketball.

Near the statue, a man wore a white Gonzaga jersey, and his wife wore a navy T-shirt that said "GO ZAGS." The assumption, of course, was that they were diehard Gonzaga fans who had traveled all the way from Washington state to see their Bulldogs.

Advertise with us

Nope.

John and Nicole Nabozny were from Pittsburgh, and they are University of Pittsburgh fans. But they have a tradition of going to a tournament site where they pick out a random team and cheer them on. They've been to Spokane, Wash.; Charlotte, N.C.; and St. Petersburg, Fla.; and, with the tournament in Pittsburgh, it just made too much sense to stay at home this year.

When the brackets were announced, the Naboznys picked Gonzaga as their team, went online and purchased their Bulldogs gear, which was sent overnight to them.

So why do they do this? Go to all of this trouble? Simple. They're rush hunting, and, instead of going skydiving or the like, they plunge into March.

"Always the first weekend," Mr. Nabozny said. "It's the fun weekend. There's so many different teams. After the first weekend, you start getting to more traditional teams. It's just not as cool to me."

Advertise with us

In Spokane, Wash., in 2007, the Naboznys chose to pull for Winthrop, a small school from South Carolina. Sure enough, Winthrop upset Notre Dame. They could only be so lucky if something like that happened again Thursday.

The first game of the day -- No. 8 seed Kansas State beat No. 9 seed Southern Mississippi, 70-64 -- didn't do much to distinguish itself. But the day was just getting started. As soon as the first game ended, UNC-Asheville jogged onto the floor, and hundreds of fans clad in blue serenaded them.

Ashley Peterson is a senior at UNC-Asheville. She and her friends, who all had Thursday classes, boarded a bus at 3 a.m. in Asheville and rode for nine hours to get here. She had Bulldog prints painted on her cheeks and a confidence about her despite the reality everybody in the arena knew.

"It's never been done before," she said.

A 16 seed beating a one seed is one of the last mountains yet to be climbed in sports, but, someday, it will happen. Why not Thursday? As Ms. Peterson and her friends walked around Pittsburgh, they received plenty of well-wishes from the locals -- many of whom mentioned they weren't so fond of Syracuse, Pitt's conference rival.

Advertise with us

"Everybody loves an underdog," Ms. Peterson said. "It's an American thing."

On the other side of the arena, the Syracuse fans were feeling a bit nervous even before tip. Their starting center, Fab Melo, was not going to play in this tournament because of a suspension due to academic issues. Plus, nobody wants to be the first No. 1 seed to fall to a No. 16.

"There's always that fear," said Brian Kleiboer, a Syracuse fan who made the drive from Toronto with his son, Michael. "We should win this, but you never know."

"Should" rarely matters in this tournament. UNC-Asheville jumped ahead, 21-17, on a four-point play by Jaron Lane and stretched its lead to 29-22. At halftime, the Bulldogs were on top, 34-30, and college basketball fans across the country were fixated on Pittsburgh.

In the stands, 25-year-old Pitt fan Zack Wanninger was allowing himself to think big.

Advertise with us

"To be a part of that would be amazing," he said. "Absolutely. We're halfway through."

Across the street from Consol remains what's left of its predecessor, the Civic Arena. There, in 1997, No. 15 seed Coppin State beat No. 2 seed South Carolina in one of the first great March upsets. Thursday was Consol's first chance to waltz with the madness of March, and, fittingly, something crazy was already happening.

Sitting courtside, CBS play-by-play broadcaster Kevin Harlan wasn't surprised. He has seen enough of these tournaments up close to know the deal. As the game pushed into the last few minutes with UNC-Asheville still hanging around with Syracuse, Mr. Harlan didn't allow himself to start planning for what he would say if the unthinkable happened.

"I never want to get ahead of myself," Mr. Harlan said. "But hopefully something would have come out that made sense."

Just when it seemed the Orange would pull away for good, the Bulldogs came up with a little something extra. The crowd was purely in UNC-Asheville's corner, booing the referees with every questionable call.

Advertise with us

With Syracuse leading, 64-61, in the final minute, the Bulldogs were employing a full-court press in the hopes of creating a turnover. The Orange threw the ball in toward guard Brandon Triche, and the ball looked to have deflected off him and out of bounds (replays would later show the ball clearly caromed off Mr. Triche). But the officials called it off UNC-Asheville. Consol responded with rightful anger, but nothing could change the outcome.

Syracuse would go on to win, 72-65, and, in this case, an argument could have been made that madness had actually been cheated.

As the stands cleared, Ms. Peterson sat with her friends and pondered it all.

"It's an unforgettable experience," she said. "This is one for the history books."

The bus was waiting outside, ready to take the faithful back to Asheville after about six hours in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

"My head hurts," Ms. Peterson said.

One day into its NCAA tournament life, Consol didn't get a major upset or a buzzer-beater. This flirtation, all too brief and fleeting, would have to do until Saturday.