It is now nine straight years without a playoff win.
Strike that.
It’s nine straight years without coming close to a playoff win after a 30-6 disaster against the Houston Texans on Monday night at Acrisure Stadium. And it could have been way worse.
It’s also seven straight playoff losses for Mike Tomlin, tying him with Marvin Lewis for the longest playoff losing streak in NFL history, just ahead of (or behind) Marty Schottenheimer and Jim Mora. Tomlin’s average margin of defeat across those seven losses: two touchdowns (and then some).
Think about that. Then tell me you’d give Tomlin another year.
I wouldn’t.
Read More
I had never before written that it was time to move on from Tomlin until last year’s playoff debacle in Baltimore, when the defense seemed to quit on him in a two-touchdown loss. You might remember what analyst Kirk Herbstreit said for millions to hear while the Ravens were shredding the Steelers for first-half touchdown drives of 95, 90 and 85 yards:
“I don’t see any fight, any pushback. Where the hell is the fight? This is the Pittsburgh Steelers. There’s nothing. They’re just going through the motions.”
The Chicago Bears subsequently called about trading for Tomlin. Steelers president Art Rooney II didn’t take the call.
There were times this season when it looked as if Tomlin had righted the ship. I thought the Steelers were onto something going into this game, especially after the dramatic (and lucky) win over the Ravens a week earlier. I was wrong. They were wrong. Lots of people were wrong.
We should have learned our lesson: Tomlin simply doesn’t win the biggest games anymore. And what ESPN’s Troy Aikman said as the final seconds ticked away rang true: “It really wipes out any good feelings you had about the year and winning the division last week.”
It really does. And it really is time. National media often frames the Tomlin situation this way: He’ll decide his own fate in Pittsburgh.
Why can’t he be fired?
John Harbaugh, who has a virtually identical resume, was just fired last week.
Pete Carroll was pushed out of Seattle.
Mike McCarthy was fired in Green Bay.
Bill Belichick was pushed out of New England after six Super Bowl wins, for goodness sake.
Why can’t the Steelers fire Tomlin? He’ll be OK. They’ll be OK. Everybody will survive and perhaps even thrive.
National media also loves to repeat the fact that Tomlin has never had a losing season. What they don’t mention as often is that he ironically has a losing playoff record — a horrible one, actually, at 8-12.
This season, in retrospect, was especially galling. After some of his players bragged before the season that the Steelers’ defense would be historically great, the flagship station gave Tomlin a chance to douse that kind of ridiculous talk.
He lit a match to it, instead, saying his defense had “a chance to do big, big things. When I say big things, I’m talking about historic things.”
Yes, well, that defense surrendered 408 yards to a mediocre Texans offense Monday, including 164 yards rushing. Running back Woody Marks had a career-best 112 yards on 19 carries. Houston didn’t have its best player, receiver Nico Collins, for much of the game.
Meantime, the Texans defense is everything Tomlin hoped the Steelers ‘D’ would be. It is downright destructive, maybe historically so. The Texans won in spite of quarterback C.J. Stroud, reminding me of the 2000 Ravens with Trent Dilfer.
I’ve said this before, but it needs an update: If a person’s first memories occur around age 5, then you have kids nearing college who have no memory of the Steelers winning a playoff game.
In their seven straight losses, they have been outscored 73-3 in first quarters.
These are the Steelers’ past five seasons, including the terrible playoff losses:
10-8
10-8
10-8
9-8
9-7-1
Late in the game, cameras panned to Rooney and GM Omar Khan in the press box, and I couldn’t help but wonder if Rooney fears the NFL draft — which will be the biggest event Pittsburgh has ever hosted — might turn into one big “Fire Tomlin!” festival.
He could avoid that by doing the right thing. It’s time.
Meanwhile …
• It’s also time for Aaron Rodgers to move on. He was better than expected this season and deserves credit for that. He served this city and this team well. But it’s better to leave a year too early than a year too late.
A frustrated Rodgers delivered more F-bombs than big throws during Monday’s game. He wound up with the lowest scoring output of any playoff game of his career, and what might have been his final pass was a pick-six.
The Steelers should not even make an offer. They have to find their next quarterback. If they don’t have that guy next season, they should use Mason Rudolph as the bridge quarterback and give Will Howard a shot.
• Rodgers got on his soapbox regarding the idea of firing Tomlin, saying the league had changed since he entered in 2004.
“When I first got in the league, there wouldn’t be a conversation about whether those guys [Tomlin and Green Bay coach Matt LaFleur] are on the hot seat,” Rodgers said.
Yes there would, actually, and I’ll prove it in a moment.
But he went on: “The way the league is covered now and there’s snap decisions and validity given to Twitter experts and experts on TV now … to me that’s an absolute joke. When you have the right guy, and the culture is right, you don’t think about making a change. But there’s a lot of pressure that comes from the outside, and obviously that sways decisions from time to time. But, not how I would do things and not how the league used to be.”
That’s just wrong. When Rodgers came into the league in 2005, you had plenty of coaches who had been successful or were about to be and would get fired soon enough.
Those included Andy Reid in Philadelphia (multiple conference championship games, plus a Super Bowl appearance), Brian Billick in Baltimore (Super Bowl win), John Fox in Carolina (Super Bowl appearance, multiple division titles), Marvin Lewis in Cincinnati (several playoff appearances with previously moribund franchise), Marty Schottenheimer in San Diego (47-33 record, coming off 14-2 season when he was fired) and Tom Coughlin with the Giants (two Super Bowl wins before he was eventually pushed out).
Rodgers also might have forgotten that his Super Bowl-winning coach in Green Bay — Mike McCarthy — was fired eight years ago and that Tony Dungy was fired after a highly successful stint in Tampa Bay decades ago.
That’s life in the NFL — and it always has been. Social media has intensified, obviously, but successful coaches were getting fired when Rodgers entered the league, and they’re getting fired now — often justifiably when they rarely or never win playoff games.
• DK Metcalf certainly didn’t bathe himself in glory Monday. He had a huge drop (maybe two) and at least one missed block, contributing greatly to the loss. The Steelers might want to re-examine their financial commitments to him.
• How Pat Freiermuth gets targeted only three times is beyond me. His disappearance from the Steelers offense for much of this season was an inexplicable embarrassment.
• I guess offensive coordinator Arthur Smith will now interview for some head coaching opportunities? How does this keep happening?
• Arthur wasn’t the worst Smith for the Steelers on Monday, however. That was tight end Jonnu Smith, who never found a place in this offense. He had two catches for minus-1 yard. He was this year’s Cordarrelle Patterson — an Arthur Smith acquisition gone wrong.
• It looks like T.J. Watt might really become his generation’s Dick Butkus — a great player who never wins a playoff game. He is 0-5 with one sack.
• What has been true remains so, and it’s a terrible place to be: The Steelers still need a franchise quarterback.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.