If you’re a self-proclaimed “great” college football program and you rarely win the biggest games, you better win every single one of the smallest games. For several years, James Franklin did.

Then came UCLA.

Normally, an upset loss — even one where you’re a 24.5-point favorite — wouldn’t carry this much meaning. In Franklin’s case, it does, seeing as it might have been the worst loss in Penn State history and likely ruined any chance of the preseason No. 2 Nittany Lions making the College Football Playoff.

Let’s just say this plainly: It was a fireable offense. A top-10 team had not lost to an 0-4 team in 40 years. Franklin’s lucky he wasn’t canned at halftime (Penn State trailed 27-7) or at the airport afterward, a la Lane Kiffin at USC.

Advertise with us

If Penn State doesn’t run the table and finish 10-2, the school’s decision-makers owe it to the fan base to fire Franklin despite an enormous buyout that USA Today reported will be $48,666,667 as of Dec. 1.

There might be more to that buyout figure than meets the eye, by the way. It might be more manageable than you’d think. More on that in a moment.

I have defended Franklin. He wins a ton of games. He won two playoff games last season. But Penn State doesn’t exist just to win double-digit games anymore. It exists to win championships. The bar was raised this past offseason when the university stepped up and made Ohio State assistant Jim Knowles the highest-paid defensive coordinator in college football history at more than $3 million annually. Penn State’s coordinators make close to $5 million combined.

Franklin, in his 12th season, only stoked expectations when he said, “This is the best combined personnel that I think we’ve had at Penn State. And when I talk about personnel, I’m talking about players and staff.”

That was before yet another loss to a top-10 team (Oregon), followed a week later by the UCLA meltdown. Franklin is 1-15 against AP top-five teams, 4-21 against top-10 teams and 16-29 against top-25 teams. He is 1-10 against Ohio State, 3-7 against Michigan and 1-8 against top-10 teams at home.

Advertise with us

And then came UCLA.

I, for one, am no longer interested in performing the mental gymnastics required to work around all that and make a logical case to keep Franklin. There is none — unless he wins out. If he does that, Penn State would have a solid case for the CFP. It would own maybe the best win of the season by winning at Ohio State.

Did I mention that Franklin is 1-10 against Ohio State?

He’d also have to avoid another upset loss, of course, and until UCLA, Franklin had been quite good at that. They don’t call him Small Game James for nothing. He hadn’t lost to an unranked team since Illinois in 2021 — and that took nine overtimes.

As for the prospective buyout, much remains unknown. USA Today conducted a study of college coaching contracts and reported this important caveat on buyout clauses in general: “Many of buyout clauses reviewed by USA TODAY are expressly subject to coach's duty to make good-faith efforts to find another job, with income from that employment offsetting the amount owed.”

Advertise with us

That seems important. Franklin would surely be sought after and could find another high-paying job.

Also, this: “If mitigation and offset are not addressed in contract, the coach may still have an obligation to make efforts in that regard.”

And this: “The amount listed may be owed to coach over an extended period of time, rather than as a lump sum at termination.”

It isn’t known how much of that applies to Franklin’s deal. The York Daily Dispatch reported that Penn State has refused to release Franklin’s contract.

However, it seems entirely possible that Penn State could work around the notion of having to hand Franklin a $48 million check the minute it fires him. The ideal scenario would see them reach a compromise and Franklin find another lucrative position.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, the UCLA stench will linger. The Bruins had recently fired their main coaches, leaving tight ends coach Jerry Neuheisel to make his play-calling debut against Knowles. And there was nothing fluky about the outcome. UCLA physically dominated for much of the game.

The end of the first half will long be remembered as emblematic of Franklin’s game-day issues.

Penn State trailed 24-7 at the two-minute warning with the ball at the UCLA 44 and all three timeouts remaining. The Nittany Lions subsequently ran it twice — will they ever fully trust quarterback Drew Allar? — gaining just 6 yards as time ticked away.

Allar then was tackled short of the first down with 57 seconds left. Franklin incredibly watched 20 more seconds elapse. The CBS crew couldn’t believe their eyes.

(Analyst) Gary Danielson: “Why no timeout here? What are they doing?”

Advertise with us

(Play-by-play man) Brad Nessler: “They STILL didn’t take a timeout. … And now they’re confused on the alignment, and UCLA is going to take a timeout — I guess to help them out.”

Danielson: “Well, they burned enough time on their own, it really doesn’t make a difference.”

Nessler: “OK, that’s the weirdest sequence I’ve seen in the last 10 years.”

After a commercial break, Nessler said, “Quite frankly, I can’t explain the last minute-and-a-half. Do you want to try?”

Danielson: “Well, lemme try this: Who do you think James Franklin has less confidence in, his offense or his defense?”

Advertise with us

Allar was then sacked on fourth down and UCLA kicked a field goal before the half. Millions watched in horror as Franklin tried to explain at halftime that he’d wanted to run the clock toward zero and score a touchdown. Maybe he should have focused on the touchdown part of that equation.

Amid a days-long autopsy of the most stunning game of the season, maybe many seasons, excellent ESPN analyst Pete Thamel defended Franklin on Monday’s “College GameDay Podcast.” He pointed to the hefty buyout and the overall record and said, “Like, do you fire James Franklin?”

Yes, Pete. You do. If your goal is to be elite — and if he doesn’t win out — you fire James Franklin.

No matter the cost.