It’s the blooper reel that never ends, my friends, and the Pirates got started bright and early this year, confirming Wednesday that their prized offseason acquisition has only one functional arm.
The good news is he's batting .500. One arm does work. The bad news is that the other one is out of commission on account of a chronic wrist problem that had to be surgically repaired. This did not become public knowledge until the Post-Gazette reported it Tuesday night. First baseman Spencer Horwitz will miss six to eight weeks, minimum.
On top of that, in a generally optimistic piece regarding another player with chronic injury issues, third baseman Ke’Bryan Hayes, this little nugget from the Post-Gazette’s Andrew Destin appeared: “As he has said publicly before, Hayes acknowledged that his lower-back issues will likely linger for the rest of his career and life.”
That’s comforting.
So on a day that is supposed to be filled with unrealistic optimism — pitchers and catchers report, everybody’s 0-0, Spencer Horwitz might actually be good, etc. — general manager Ben Cherington was forced to address the unpleasant and perhaps self-incriminating topic of the Horwitz surgery. He said the team knew of Horwitz’s chronic issues when it traded for him in December, which might prompt one to ask, “Why did you trade for him, then?” But everybody knows the answer.
All together now ... because we’re the Pirates.
Read More
Last July, the Pirates traded for their alleged cleanup hitter of the future only to release him a few months later after realizing that he doesn’t know how to play baseball.
This is a disaster. Maybe Horwitz’s wrist problem got worse after the Pirates dealt for him, as Cherington posited. Or maybe, as John Perrotto of Pittsburgh Baseball Now reported, Horwitz actually had a thumb injury unrelated to the wrist issues. Perrotto said Horwitz told him as much.
Whatever the case, the age-old question arises: Who’s on first? And with the Pirates, that leads to an age-old answer: Who knows? One candidate (Jared Triolo) can’t hit. Another (Henry Davis) can’t hit or field. Another (Bryan Reynolds) plays right field. A fourth (Darick Hall) and a fifth (DJ Stewart) are so anonymous they might as well be in witness protection.
Look around the diamond, and this is what you might see on a given day: a one-armed first baseman, a permanently injured third baseman, a shortstop who isn't a shortstop, a center fielder who is a shortstop, a right fielder who’s a left fielder, and a left fielder who’s practically as old as Clint Hurdle and whose biggest hit in recent memory was slapping a rival player in the face over a fantasy football dispute.
The over/under on combined home runs by the starting infield could fairly be set at 30.5.
Shortstop Isiah Kiner-Falefa — the guy who famously predicted the Pirates would win 100 games this season — is probably best-suited to be a utility man, but the Pirates have more utility men than Duquesne Light. Somebody has to be the everyday shortstop. You would think they'd have a homegrown one by now, considering they have drafted roughly 500 shortstops over the past decade.
But back to the fantasy football dispute, if only to squeeze in a legendary quote from a player the Pirates should have signed this offseason — slugging lefty Joc Pederson, who went for a reasonable price to the Texas Rangers. (The Pirates, meanwhile, will again settle for an aging Andrew McCutchen as their primary DH, perhaps using his popularity as a distraction from the fact that they did absolutely nothing of significance to build around ace starter Paul Skenes, aside from bringing in an injured first baseman.)
Two years ago, Pederson was playing for the San Francisco Giants, and new Pirates left fielder Tommy Pham was with the Cincinnati Reds. The two had been in a fantasy football league the previous season with players from various teams. They didn’t know each other well but had a dispute when Pham accused Pederson of stashing players on IR, or some such thing.
Pederson also admitted that he sent a playful text within the fantasy league text group mocking the San Diego Padres, who had a few players — including Pham at the time — in the league. Seven months later, Pham walked up to Pederson before a game, in the outfield, and slapped him, leading to this memorable Pederson quote: “It is true, I did send a GIF making fun of the Padres. And if I hurt anyone’s feelings, I apologize for that.”
There seems to be this idea that the fiery Pham is just what the Pirates need in their clubhouse. OK, then make him the manager. I’d rather have somebody who can still play high-level baseball, and I’m not sure Pham's that guy (although if it works out, the Pirates' theme song has to be, “We are Pham-a-lee”).
The soon-to-be 37-year-old Pham played for three teams last season and batted .248 with nine home runs in 440 at-bats. But at least he’s functional, which is more than you can say for the new first baseman.
I wonder what Day 2 will bring.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.