The Baseball Hall of Fame remains the biggest joke among America’s sports museums. Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens are out, Bud Selig is in. That’s all you need to know, though I could go on.
Hockey isn’t nearly as bad, but it had another hold-my-beer moment Tuesday — the result of which is this: Alexander Mogilny remains out; Colin Campbell is in. That was the big news in the Class of ’24 reveal.
Think about that.
One of the most breathtakingly spectacular players in league history, not to mention a man who changed the game forever as the first Soviet defector, has now been rejected 15 times by the shrouded-in-secrecy Hockey Hall of Fame selection committee, while a long-time, unremarkable league executive who easily could have been kicked out of office after an email scandal will be enshrined as a “hockey legend.”
Campbell had a decent career as a player and coach before he became one of NHL commissioner Gary Bettman’s trusted servants. He was the league’s czar of discipline for several years, notably excusing then-Penguins winger Matt Cooke for his vicious and career-altering head shot on Bruins center Marc Savard.
It became especially notable when it was revealed via emails — sent long before the Cooke ruling — that Campbell did not care for Savard, a player he once coached, calling him a “little fake artist” and the “biggest faker going” after he drew a high-sticking call on Campbell’s son, Gregory. There were many eye-opening lines in the emails Campbell sent to fellow league execs around 2006-07.
Read More
Yahoo’s Greg Wyshynski wrote the following in 2010, when the emails were uncovered: “The Colin Campbell Emails aren’t as much a revelation as much as a confirmation for his critics. They reveal criticism of officials who dared call disputed penalties on his son, Gregory Campbell, now a forward with the Bruins. They reveal the candid, petty assessments by an NHL executive on the league’s on-ice officials’ performances. And, most scandalously, they reveal a long-standing grudge Campbell holds against Bruins center Marc Savard ... and fans across the NHL are now wondering if that grudge may have come into play when Campbell let Matt Cooke off without a suspension for concussing Savard last season.”
Campbell said he was shocked by the HOF announcement. So were plenty of others, who had no idea what his credentials would be. Bettman delivered a statement in which he helpfully pointed out that as senior executive vice president of hockey operations, Campbell has “watched more than 30,000 NHL games and personally made thousands of critical video review calls.”
In that case, I’d like to nominate former Penguins video review coach Andy Saucier for the Hall of Fame. His calls actually helped a team win the Cup.
One ex-selection committee member told me, “I was surprised by Campbell. In his case, it seems like a reward for faithful service.”
It’s the Old Boys Network, is what it is. David Poile, who is actually on the selection committee, is part of this year’s class (he recused himself from voting) despite never winning a championship as a GM. I’m not saying Poile is undeserving, but if he’s in, then Eddie Johnston absolutely should be in. The Penguins don’t exist without Johnston, who is the definition of a hockey lifer and builder.
But back to Mogilny and the crime of keeping him out. Bettman and every single member of the 18-person selection committee should be ashamed. The committee is chaired by former NHL star Mike Gartner and includes a mix of media members, ex-players and executives: David Branch, Brian Burke, Cassie Campbell-Pascall, Mark Chipman, Marc de Foy, Ron Francis, Cammi Granato, Anders Hedberg, Jari Kurri, Igor Larionov, Pierre McGuire, Bob McKenzie, Scott Morrison, Mike Murphy, Poile, Luc Robitaille and Joe Sakic.
Burke, incidentally, was one of the few who rushed to Campbell’s defense after the email scandal. These people should be made to publicly defend their choices. They actually left a male player vacancy in this year’s class, one that Mogilny should have filled.
A candidate needs 14 votes to get in. Who’s keeping Mogilny out? Who voted against him? Was he even nominated by one of the members? Has another former Soviet star, Larionov, nominated Mogilny and aggressively pushed his candidacy? These are the kinds of questions that will go unanswered. Unlike voters in other sports, hockey voters are protected by a vow of silence and lack of transparency.
One could make an argument that Mogilny should be enshrined simply for being the first Soviet defector, at a time when it was incredibly dangerous to flee. He despised his dictator coach, Viktor Tikhonov, on the Soviet national teams and hated the military lifestyle players were forced to lead. He had the guts to leave. A rush of legendary Soviet players followed.
But Mogilny also was a must-see player, one who put up 473 goals and 1,032 points in just 990 NHL games, won a Cup, became the first Soviet team captain in NHL history and produced an iconic 76-goal season, topped only by Wayne Gretzky, Mario Lemieux and Brett Hull.
Mogilny also had one of the great quotes in NHL history, saying this of the abhorrent Tikhonov: “Only his wife and his dog like him, and I do not understand how they do.”
Back in 2015, Mogilny’s former Soviet linemate, Sergei Fedorov, said this to Ken Campbell of The Hockey News on Mogilny’s HOF candidacy: “He deserves that honor. Alex was faster than all of us and Alex was a machine. He was built like a machine. Plus on top of all the crazy skill he had, he’s better than all of us. He’s amazing.”
What’s truly amazing is that Mogilny is still waiting and Colin Campbell is in.
What a disgrace.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and @joestarkey1 on X. Joe Starkey can be heard on weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.