All creative solutions must be considered, including the idea of signing Russell Wilson.
You do understand the gravity of the situation, yes? You realize that the Steelers’ quarterback situation qualifies as an emergency? This team still doesn’t don’t know if it has a guy in a conference filled with GUYS at the most important position in sports.
The Steelers are headed into Year 3 of auditions for the lead role. Year 3, and they still don’t know if Kenny Pickett can sing. They don’t know if pending free agent Mason Rudolph is going to return, either, and if even if he does, they’ll be headed to camp with Kenny Pickett and Mason Rudolph.
Baltimore’s going to camp with Lamar Jackson.
Buffalo’s going to camp with Josh Allen.
Kansas City’s going to camp with Patrick Mahomes.
Read More
Cincinnati’s going to camp with Joe Burrow.
Houston’s going to camp with C.J. Stroud.
The Chargers are going to camp with Justin Herbert.
Miami’s going to camp with Tua Tagovailoa.
Jacksonville’s going to camp with Trevor Lawrence.
New England might be going to camp with Drake Maye.
The idea of a Pickett-Rudolph competition, while compelling in some ways, would be reason for fear, not optimism, and would call to mind one of football’s finest cliches, courtesy of the late, great John Madden: “If you have two quarterbacks, you actually have none.”
Mike Tomlin was asked several questions about his quarterback situation at his season-ending news conference, and if ever there was a time to walk off the podium, that was it — because there are no good answers.
The one response that stood out: "There will be competition there. There’s always competition in this thing. We don't anoint anyone.”
Actually, there’s never competition in this thing if you have a guy, and you went to camp with a guy — an anointed one — for your first 15 years here. His name was Ben Roethlisberger. Competition is the last thing you want at the quarterback spot.
But this is where the Steelers are, backed into a corner with Pickett headed into Year 3, needing to find out if he can assert himself and hoping that Mason Rudolph will provide the “competition” but uncertain if he will return.
It’s a strange situation because the Steelers want to find out once and for all about Pickett. That’s the plan. As such, it would preclude the idea of adding a sure-fire starter such as Kirk Cousins. That wouldn’t make sense.
But what about Wilson, who is expected to be released by the Broncos? His situation is much murkier. What if there is little market for him? Would he consider a backup spot with a quick promotion possible? Tomlin has already shown he is willing to bench and bury Pickett.
NFL insider Peter King does a weekly radio spot on 93.7 The Fan and has brought up Wilson’s name several times in recent weeks in connection to the Steelers. He believes Wilson could be a fit, and he points out that Wilson could be had for the NFL’s veteran minimum salary.
“I would not rule out Wilson there,” King said. “I think if Mike Tomlin had his way, he’d want a veteran quarterback in there who will make sure that you enter the season with a fighting chance against three teams in your division, all of whom have a better quarterback situation right now than you do.”
Yes, it’s instructive to remember that the Steelers would have finished last in the AFC North if Joe Burrow had been healthy.
I get that many people would not love this idea. I don’t get rejecting it out of hand as some kind of ludicrous rantings of people looking for clicks. I think it would be way more ludicrous to go to camp with Pickett and Rudolph and expect to win anything significant.
The upside here is that Wilson, 35, is coming off a season in which he finished eighth in the league in passer rating (98.0) while throwing for 26 touchdowns against eight interceptions. He tied for the NFL lead in fourth-quarter comebacks (four) and was tied for second in game-winning drives (four), according to Pro Football Reference, and while the legs aren’t what they used to be, he ran still ran for 381 yards and three touchdowns.
If you watched any Broncos games, like the Monday night comeback win at Buffalo, you saw that Wilson still can move more than adequately. He helped the Broncos to consecutive midseason victories over Green Bay, Kansas City, Buffalo, Minnesota and Cleveland, even as his own team seemingly was sabotaging him.
It was clear that Broncos coach Sean Payton was not a huge Wilson fan. Things got ugly in November, right after Wilson led the Broncos to their first win over the Chiefs since 2015.
As King wrote, “Wilson alleged that Broncos GM George Paton asked or demanded that Wilson adjust the injury guarantee in his contract in midseason; if he didn’t, the quarterback would be benched. That’s outrageous. It’s the ultimate example of a bad-faith threat.”
After a few more games playing amid friendly fire, Wilson was benched. Who knows what his market will be this offseason? He might have better options than coming to Steelers camp to compete with Pickett. If not, the Steelers should make the call.
9-1-1.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.