Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Majors and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. Onto the questions …
DAVE FOSSICK, @dman586: With the success the Eagles had with short yardage plays, are you surprised more teams didn’t use the formation?
Starkey: You’re talking about the cheat-code quarterback sneak, Dr. FOSSICK, and yes, I was extremely surprised. Sean Payton says he’ll use that play all the time next season if the NFL doesn’t outlaw it — and that’s the question at the moment: Will the NFL outlaw it?
Should the play — on which multiple players push the quarterback from behind — be legal? First, if you watched the Super Bowl, you have to believe it’s unstoppable. Jalen Hurts was 6-for-6 on sneaks in that game, including a touchdown. Now, it helps to have maybe the best interior line in the game and a quarterback who can squat 600 pounds.
But it looked unstoppable — and as it turns out, Dr. FOSSICK, the Eagles’ refusal to go for it in the third quarter might have cost them the Super Bowl.
The only time either team punted in the second half was on the Eagles’ second possession. They were 3rd-and-3 at their own 32 when an incomplete pass led to a punt. Why not run that play twice right there? Why not run that play EVERY TIME you have 3 or fewer yards and two downs to get a first down?
Read More
Anyway, the QB sneak was more popular than ever last season. According to CBSsports.com, “a record 308 quarterback sneaks were called this season, and teams averaged a first-down conversion on 83% of them, the highest mark dating back to Pro Football Focus' inception in 2006. That's a far cry from the 2016 season, when the play was called fewer than 100 times.”
The QB sneak has been a near-automatic play for, well, as long as football has existed, which makes it even more infuriating that 6-foot-5, 250-pound Ben Roethlisberger refused to run it over the past several years of his career (notably 1st-and-goal at the Patriots’ 1-yard line late in first half of 2016 AFC championship).
But I digress. I think the play will be outlawed, under the phony rationale of “protecting quarterbacks.” The league will trot out the play where Chris Jones dived over the line to try to take out Hurts and say, “We can’t have this play run 10 times a game.”
I think the best solution is to limit the “push players” — the guys pushing from behind — to just one. The way the Steelers did it from time to time. But that’s just me.
Carl Reagle, @reagle_c: Future of pro sports without regional TV money?
Starkey: Different question for different sports I would say, Dr. Reagle. The NFL’s gonna do OK, right? But how about the NHL?
A person in the business told me this: “(Regional Sports Networks) have lost tons of subscribers. I don’t know how many but a lot of people are disconnecting their cable and using streaming devices which are much harder to control and are so fragmented that it’s difficult for the individual teams to be able to capture the dollars.”
He suggested actual regional broadcasts could replace local broadcasts. So if, say, the Penguins played the Blue Jackets, it would be one set of announcers. But nobody has real answers at this point. It’s a confusing situation. I have to believe, however, that one way or another (perhaps for a higher price) we’ll be watching our local teams play.
B&B inda Burgh, @Markieburgh: Is there no player on the roster to get [Jeff] Carter watching from press level. Maybe if he missed a few games he’d get some bounce or just flat out gas out?
Starkey: You’d think, Dr. Burgh, but they had to jettison a salary (Kapanen’s) just to be able to get defenseman Jan Rutta in the lineup. What kind of financial magic will it take to actually promote a player from Wilkes-Barre? At this rate, they’ll have to wait until rosters expand.
Meanwhile, Carter actually scored in the last game — a beautiful shot, I might add — so let’s see if he can put two good games together.
Mark, @Markvg31V: With Capel due for an extension, is it fools gold with the transfer portal or is he the coach to take the team to be the next blue blood of the ACC? Especially being coach K is gone do you think Duke takes a massive step back leaving the door open for a Pitt to make the leap?
Starkey: Let’s not jump out of our sneakers here, Dr. Mark. Pitt’s having a nice bounce-back season — and I believe Jeff Capel has a chance to follow it up with another good year. He appears to have lined up a solid recruiting class, figures to have John Hugley back and will have some key returning players.
But that’s a long way from replacing Duke at anything.
Jayson Lillie, @Jay_Lil75: If Stephon Tuitt plays last year and was anywhere near his usual level of performance, do the Steelers make the playoffs? And is there any truth to the rumor that he might be coming back?
Starkey: I have heard nothing like that, Dr. Lillie. As to your first question, I’m guessing yes, that with an elite game wrecker opposite Cam Hayward, the Steelers would have made the playoffs. Joe Greene in his prime probably would have helped, too, for what it’s worth.
Yinzersaurus, @jbfrompgh: Why doesn’t the NHL do more to market itself, like having the Sid v McDavid show down nationally televised? Thank God it didn’t ... But that’s not the point.
Starkey: I have been asked questions like this — and have pondered questions like this — for nearly a quarter century, Dr. Yinzer, and here is my conclusion: It doesn’t matter how much the NHL “markets” itself or its biggest stars. It is a niche sport in this country and always will be.
They could have had a commercial featuring Crosby and McDavid in every break during the Super Bowl, and it would not have attracted one more viewer from South Dakota or Alabama. The sport still doesn’t lend itself to television after all these years, and more than half the country wouldn’t watch a game if it broke out in their basement.
Walt Harbaugh, @WaltHarbaugh: If you could undo one single Penguins’ transaction over the past few years, which one would it be?
Starkey: That’s a good question, Dr. Harbaugh, and I’m going to say Jack Johnson, five years, $16.25 million on July 1, 2018. Still the most inexplicable Penguins move I have ever seen and the worst free agent signing in club history (no offense to Ziggy Palffy) — and his cap hit kept hurting them for three years after he was bought out.
Ryan Clerici, @ryan_clerici: Do you think there is anything Fillipponi can do to make himself even more annoying? I don’t think it’s possible.
Starkey: Hahahah. You might want to check with Kevin Garnett on that, Dr. Clerici.
#FireHextall, @LegallyJewish: In 20 years will we look back at the pitch clock as a great idea or a concept that ruins the game of baseball?
Starkey: I don’t think we’ll think about it much, Dr. #FireHextall. Having said that, it has profoundly changed the sport in this respect: Baseball now has a clock. It is officially a timed sport.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.