Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Flowers and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. Onto the questions ...

Mark, @Markvg31V: Would you draft (Jordan) Addison at 17 even though there are other holes, much like the Bengals did with Chase over Sewell? Then potentially trade DJ for another Day 2 pick? I get the feeling DJ doesn't want to be a No. 2 to Pickens and can be a distraction.

Starkey: Addison does not compare to Ja’Marr Chase as an overall talent, Dr. Mark, but it’s a legit topic in the big-picture sense, in that you’d be choosing a receiver your young quarterback is familiar with and could grow up with, as opposed to attacking another position of need.

Having said that, would I do it? Would I draft Addison?

Advertise with us

I’d think about it. In fact, I’d think about trading Diontae Johnson and drafting Addison. Yes, I would. To be fair, Johnson by all accounts was not a distraction and I don’t think he will be. If anything, he tried too hard to justify his contract. He just wasn’t very dynamic. I believe he set the NFL record for most catches in a season (86) without a touchdown. His regression is the important point here. I wouldn’t put it past him to rebound strong, but that’s hardly a guarantee.

It would appear they badly overpaid for his services. The Steelers have already committed a bunch of money to Johnson ($27 million guaranteed at signing), so his base salaries of $8 million and $7 million the next two years are easily manageable for another team. This would be a bold move, but I would endorse it. Might be best for both sides as George Pickens asserts himself as the No. 1 guy and the Steelers have an extra prime pick thanks to the Chase Claypool trade.

They’d still have several other picks to address other positions.

Guardian Ad Litem Up Up Up, @LegallyJewish: How much of a joke is it that Highsmith didn’t get named to the Pro Bowl roster?

Starkey: The Pro Bowl, which doesn’t even exist as a game anymore, has been a joke for a long time, Dr. Guardian. Nobody takes it seriously. It’s far more important and prestigious to make All-Pro than it is to make the imaginary Pro Bowl.

Advertise with us

All you need to know about the Pro Bowl this year (voted on by fans, players and coaches, each counting a third) is that Highsmith finished with more sacks than two of the AFC’s outside linebackers combined. He had 14.5 sacks. T.J. Watt (missed several games) and Khalil Mack combined for 13.5.

J Hunter, @Fin3334: Why didn’t they just call the Bills/Bengals game a tie and let the math decide playoff scenario?

Starkey: That was an option, Dr. Hunter, but here’s my question: Why did the NFL favor the Bills over the Bengals in possible playoff scenarios?

Let me explain. The league’s competition committee looked at the canceled Bills-Bengals game and basically said, “If the Bills had won, they would be the No. 1 seed instead of Kansas City, so let’s present a proposal whereby a Bills-Chiefs AFC Championship Game would be played at a neutral site.”

OK, I get that. But what about the Bengals? If they had won the canceled Bills game, they would have clinched the No. 2 seed and positioned themselves to host a divisional game against Buffalo. So why wasn’t there a proposal for that game to be played at a neutral site?

Advertise with us

Instead, if chalk holds, the Bengals will travel to Buffalo next weekend for a playoff game.

After it became clear Bills-Bengals would not be made up, the NFL should have just abided by a rule already on their books: go with winning percentages to determine seeds and home field. Instead, they concocted the neutral-site scenario for one team but not another.

I get why the Bengals are not happy.

Bob Pavlik, @bobp1964: Do the Steelers use the first pick of the second round and trade up to 20, 21 or 22?

Starkey: If they love a player there, why not?

Advertise with us

Caleb D, @Calebmd01: Who do you think would have made more noise in the playoffs this year, the Steelers or the Lions? Could the Lions possibly be closer to contending than the Steelers?

Starkey: Those are two different questions, Dr. D. The Lions probably had a chance to make more noise in the playoffs because they would be facing Brock Purdy (all due respect) whereas the Steelers would be facing Josh Allen.

I think both teams have a great chance to make the playoffs next season. I like the progress the Steelers’ young offensive players made, and I love their schedule.

Huzatguy, @huzatguy: Which Pittsburgh sports media person would make the best offensive coordinator of the Steelers?

Starkey: Bob Pompeani, by far.

Advertise with us

Yinzersaurus, @jbfrompgh: Tomlin is receiving a ton of credit for the Steelers midseason turnaround, but am I wrong for still being annoyed at some of those earlier-season losses that were ultimately the reason we missed the playoffs?

Starkey: Well, his team didn’t quit, so I guess that’s good. But how many teams actually quit in the NFL, Dr. Yinzer? The Jaguars didn’t when they were 2-6. The Lions didn’t when they were 2-6. The Packers didn’t. The Saints didn’t. The Cowboys didn’t when they had to go to Cooper Rush. Even the Browns didn’t.

People say this season was more proof that Tomlin never loses a team. I guess. But what about all the recent late-season collapses? Did he lose any of those teams?

I mean, he had a 7-2-1 team in 2018 that finished 2-4 and missed the playoffs while its best player quit the team.

He had an 8-5 team in 2019 that was favored in its final three games and lost all three, including one to the Jets.

Advertise with us

He had an 11-0 team in 2020 that lost five of its final six games, including the most embarrassing playoff loss in franchise history (OK, maybe second to Tebow).

I’m not saying Tomlin lost those teams, necessarily, but if we’re going to heap praise on him for a good finish, do we also criticize him for the multiple collapses?

In a related matter, here are the AFC teams who’ve gone the longest without a playoff win:

Dolphins: 21 years

Raiders: 20 years

Advertise with us

Jets: 12 years

Broncos: 7 years

Steelers: 6 years

On the plus side, the Steelers beat Tyler Huntley, Marcus Mariota, Andy Dalton, Sam Darnold, Matt Ryan, bad Derek Carr and rusty Deshaun Watson over their final nine games this season. That is commendable. It’s also the least they could have done after the start you mentioned. And yes, the 2-6 start counts. Losing to Zach Wilson and Jacoby Brissett counts every bit as much as games in December.

DAVE FOSSICK, @dman586: Will Kendrick Green be on the Steelers next year?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Was he on the Steelers this year?

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.