There’s almost too much to talk about in the wake of one of the top-five college football games ever played at Acrisure Stadium (although technically it was the first college football game ever played at Acrisure Stadium).
• Pitt’s pulsating 38-31 victory in the 105th edition of the Backyard Brawl joins Pitt 42-Penn State 39 and Cincinnati 45-Pitt 44 as what I would call the three best college games at Acrisure.
There were other highly meaningful ones — beating No. 3 Virginia Tech in 2002, beating Clemson last season and edging West Virginia, 16-13, in 2004 to pave the way to the Fiesta Bowl spring to mind. So does No. 8 Pitt defeating Notre Dame, 27-22, in 2009.
There were other wild games, too, like the time Pitt gave up 61 points and still won (with 76 of their own) against Syracuse in 2016, but this one had everything, including a late comeback, a 28-point fourth quarter, a national television audience, the largest crowd in Pittsburgh sports history (70,622) and a local kid (Aliquippa’s M.J. Devonshire) winning it on an incredible 56-yard interception return.
The last time Heinz Field — sorry, Acrisure Stadium — exploded like that on a pick six was when Troy Polamalu clinched the 2008 AFC championship.
• This was going to be a huge night for the Pitt football program no matter what.
Read More
A loss would have pushed the Panthers out of the national spotlight for several weeks, at the very least, and turned the talk to how maybe last year was nothing more than a Kenny Pickett creation. An aberration.
Instead, Pitt cashed in big time, building on the momentum of last year’s ACC championship. I was thinking the crowd might be split. Most reports had it more like 80/20 Pitt. Which is to say, the kind of crowd you want to please if you’re a program that has long struggled to put fannies in seats.
I’m guessing a healthy percentage of those folks will want to return Sept. 10 for the Tennessee game. It’s called customer satisfaction. It’s how you grow a business.
• Pitt transfer Kedon Slovis had a smashing debut, going 16 of 24 for 308 yards. He wasn’t perfect — except on the game-tying 92-yard drive, when he went 5-for-5 — but he showed the kind of playmaking ability that could take Pitt a long way.
According to ESPN, Slovis's 308 passing yards were the most by a Pitt quarterback in a season opener since Matt Lytle had 349 in 1998 against Villanova.
Slovis wrote a check earlier in the week when he shouted, “(Expletive) West Virginia!” at a pep rally. He cashed it.
• What on earth was Neal Brown thinking? Here’s a guy whose job figures to be on the line this season, playing in a rivalry game with a chance to win back the fan base.
He might have done it, too, if he’d showed some guts on 4th-and-inches at the Pitt 47 with 6:17 left in regulation and his team winning by a touchdown.
Instead, Brown punted and watched the Panthers go 92 yards to tie it. He got what he deserved. It reminded me of Pat Narduzzi kicking that late field goal from the Penn State 1-yard line a few years back.
Brown deprived his players of a chance to put the hammer down (quoting Todd Graham here). He has a 240-pound battering ram in CJ Donaldson, who had 125 yards on seven carries.
ESPN’s Louis Riddick rightfully ripped the decision, pointing out, “Your offensive line is starting to surge.”
“If you go for it and don’t get it, they’ve got a short field,” Brown said postgame.
Yes, that is correct. But if you have confidence in your defense, which Brown said he did, you stop them. The worst that happens is Pitt goes 53 yards and ties it, and you still have time to win it. Or you lean forward for a first down, possibly score more points, win the game and keep the hounds off your back for a week.
“The decision was sound,” Brown said. “If I had to do it again, I’d do it again.”
That’ll win ‘em over!
• Rodney Hammond Jr. looks to me like Pitt's next star running back.
• This will prove to be a high-quality win because West Virginia is going to cause people problems with an upgraded quarterback situation (JT Daniels), plus Donaldson and 6-foot-3, 225-pound receiver Bryce Ford-Wheaton. Those two look like NFL players, despite Ford-Wheaton's big mistake.
• What an embarrassment that Steve Pederson and those who influenced him killed the Backyard Brawl 11 years ago. Think about that.
Think about the lead-up to the incredible scene that unfolded Thursday night. Think about the enjoyment and memories for both fan bases. Think about the fact it was the most heavily attended event in Pittsburgh sports history. And then think about the game itself, an instant classic if ever there was one (and capped by a throng of Pitt players escorting West Virginia players to their tunnel after the game and waving goodbye).
You were deprived of this for 11 years for reasons unknown. I’ve heard part of it was that some influential Pitt fans didn’t like traveling to Mountaineer Field because they didn’t like the atmosphere there. I still can’t figure it out. Just a shame.
These schools should agree to a season-opening game through the year 3000. Who needs Penn State?
• Having said that, you gotta love Narduzzi’s postgame quote: “We’ll play Penn State any time they want to.”
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.