Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Majors and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
gtj981, @watchingsports3: Should Malkin move to wing if he comes back?
Starkey: No, Dr. gtj981, but I’m going to focus on the second part of your question and ask this: What’s the best case for bringing Malkin back?
There’s an easy answer, by the way: Box-office-attraction, point-per-game players don’t just appear, especially at bargain rates.
That last piece is the key, of course: How much will he cost?
Malkin has been making more than Sidney Crosby for a long time and has said he will take a pay cut. If the Penguins can sign him to a three-year deal — matching the length of Crosby’s deal — worth, say, $20 million, I’d do it. I don’t know if Malkin would, but I would. And the Penguins should.
Read More
The case, again, is simple: Malkin’s still really good. At age 35 and coming off major knee surgery, he returned midway through the season and produced points (1.02 per game) at a rate equal to the likes of Sebastian Aho and better than the likes of John Tavares and Mika Zibanejad. It stands to reason Malkin will be in a better place, physically, to start next season.
Malking also produced six points in seven playoff games, including some huge goals. If he played with better linemates, he might have averaged two points a game. Instead, in Game 7, he was saddled for part of the time with The Invisible Man (Kasperi Kapanen) and the shell of Rickard Rakell (another victim of the head-hunting Rangers).
That’s not a “Yeah, but” fact. That’s a full stop, end-of-conversation fact. Malkin played without adequate linemates.
Do you think Sidney Crosby or anybody else would have thrived next to a man who exists in theory only, an injured Rakell or Danton Heinen?
Crosby rightfully has the best linemates, including a lethal goal scorer in Jake Guentzel. Malkin has … well, we just went through all that.
If the Penguins can keep an elite point producer and fan favorite as their second center for a bargain rate, they’d be fools to push him out the door.
But what price will Malkin settle for?
Ryan Dischner, @Dischmeister33L: Do you see a cup in this city anytime soon?
Starkey: I’m tempted to say, “Not unless the Fed Ex Cup champion is awarded in Pittsburgh,” Dr. Dischner, but I honestly believe the Penguins still have an outside chance as long as Crosby continues to play at a high level.
They’d still be playing, remember, if Crosby hadn’t been taken out of the Rangers series by an elbow to the head.
I think these past two Penguins teams had a chance to make runs but were undone largely by bad luck and subpar goaltending.
Tristan Jarry was terrible last year. He and Casey DeSmith were injured this year, which meant Louis Domingue — a fringe NHL goalie — had to play parts of six games. Jarry returned and played through pain in Game 7 but also delivered the lowest save percentage of any Penguins goalie in any game in the series and was far and away the second-best goalie on the ice. You can’t create 22 high-danger chances to your opponent’s six and lose a game, as the Penguins did in Game 7.
Jarry battled and made some big saves, but in the end he wasn’t good enough. He basically delivered what Domingue had been delivering for most of the series. If the Penguins are going to have any chance to make a serious run anytime soon, they will need Jarry to be a playoff star.
Jeff Stoyanoff, @jeffgstoyanoff: What reason do we have to be hopeful for the Penguins' future under FSG?
Starkey: It’s likely FSG will spend to the cap. It has a history of winning and appears to be interested in winning. It is run by smart people.
That doesn’t guarantee anything, but it’s a pretty good place to start.
Cold Man Sports, @ColdManSports: Dr. Starkey. Who is going to win the NBA finals? And which NBA player plays the way you did in your prime? My guess Luka (Doncic).
Starkey: The Golden State Warriors, my friend, although that might be my heart talking. I love watching that team. I think they’re good for the sport. They play a beautiful, riveting brand of basketball. My head, however, tells me Boston is the best team and will find a way to defend the Warriors better than anybody else could.
Meantime, the Warriors have to get past Luka, who might be the best player on the planet. My game was more like John Havlicek’s, if you remember him — a little bit of everything, albeit at a very low rate of speed.
BAM BAM MORRIS, @blob_23: Will the Steelers give (Stephon) Tuitt a deadline to be ready for the season? If he’s not out there, that’s a big hole to fill this late in the game.
Starkey: Agreed on that last point, Bam Bam, but when I asked Kevin Colbert in a recent radio interview if the Steelers had a deadline in mind, he said, “Not really … You get into OTAs (which begin next week) and the vets start coming in more regularly. So, we’ll see where it goes.”
Not exactly definitive. Nothing really has been on Tuitt’s availability.
Eugene Mannarino, @steelmann58: Any potential moves left Vet RB or WR or Dl or LB.
Starkey: Always potential moves, Dr. Mannarino. Always. And sometimes the best move is to wait until training camp when teams start to cut veteran players.
Joel Alexander, @Joel_Closer: Growing up on hockey in 80’s & 90’s, there were always a couple guys dedicated to protecting Mario / Gretzky etc. Given the abuse Sid takes in the playoffs, thoughts on dedicating a roster spot to Tie Domi 2.0? An enforcer, not a goon!
Starkey: Nobody on earth is going to keep Crosby out of harm’s way, Dr. Closer. Not in this sport, which glorifies -- or at least enables -- the butchering of its stars.
Let’s consider the example of Tom Wilson. Do you think any single hockey player is going to keep Wilson from being Wilson? Jacob Trouba, too. The presence of Mike Tyson in his prime was not going to stop Jacob Trouba from doing what he did.
It has always been this way, even from the era you speak of. Mario Lemieux wasn’t “protected” from anything. He endured years of ridiculous abuse. Did somebody keep Adam Graves from breaking Mario’s wrist with a baseball-style swing of his stick?
The Rangers were delivering high hits from the start of Game 1. A couple resulted in Penguins head injuries. Trouba’s elbow won the series. As long as hockey looks out for the Troubas of the world more than the Crosbys, you’ll have these types of situations.
The NBA, meanwhile, protects its players, which obviously includes its stars. When there is a dangerous elbow to head in that sport — as there was with the aforementioned Luka Doncic last week — the game literally stops and the play is reviewed. If the head shot is deemed bad enough, a player can be ejected.
In the NHL, everybody debates whether the elbow to the head of the biggest star in the world was actually an elbow to the head. Did it really happen? Was it intentional? You know the drill. It’s been this way for decades.
Why not just seek to eliminate hits to the head? The league has a rule where you are responsible for your stick, regardless of intent. Why can’t the same be true of your elbow?
DMcClurg, @mcclurg22: I believe Kris Letang will be gone next year and I feel our defense is very soft. Tell me which two current defenseman you would keep for next year. The rest would be new to the team. Contracts don’t matter.
Starkey: Letang and Dumoulin, but if you’re not including Letang, I would say Dumoulin and Matheson.
chadgiron, @chadgiron: Have the Pens in the Crosby/Malkin era low key underachieved? 4 consecutive 1st round outs. Some other bad showings. Reasonable to expect 1-2 more conference finals trips out of this ‘era’?
Starkey: Underachieved? Have you gone nuts, Dr. chadgiron? They have been to four Stanley Cup Finals and have won three of them, including two in a row. They made the playoffs every year with Crosby and Malkin together. They have been to the conference finals five times in 16 years — a third of the time, basically — despite the presence of some very powerful organizations, including the Capitals, Bruins and Lightning.
The Penguins clearly are the top organization of the salary cap era, to this point. Also, I believe they would have won it all in 2011 if not for injuries that knocked Crosby and Malkin out of the playoffs at the very height of their powers.
Yes, four first-round losses in a row is not good — but have you checked in on the Capitals or Leafs lately?
MOJO, @mjro1105: How do the same fans that demonize Trouba, vote this guy (Jack Lambert) their #1 ALL-TIME athlete?
Starkey: Remind me, Dr. MOJO, which stars Jack Lambert eliminated from playoff games with elbows to the face?
BKV, @Bee_K_Vee: What % do you give each of these players returning to the Pens?
Malkin
Letang
Rust
Rackell
DeSmith
and for fun… Fleury
Starkey: Thank for the question, Dr. Bee. Envelopes, please …
Malkin: 51%
Rust: 49%
Letang: 40%
DeSmith: 15% (he’s an interesting case, but it’s tough to bring him back again as a UFA when he is again coming off a major injury to same area of his body).
Rakell: 11%
Fleury: 5% — much as I would love it.
Maybe I should put Fleury higher than that, if DeSmith doesn’t return. Maybe way higher.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.