Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Flowers and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Yinzersaurus, @jbfrompgh: Is there any doubt the Penguins won the trade with Anaheim?

Starkey: I like the move, Yinzer, but there is always some doubt. Will Rickard Rakell recapture the goal-scoring touch he showed earlier in his career? Will he thrive next to Evgeni Malkin, assuming the two are paired?

And what did the Penguins lose with Zach Aston-Reese? Some will laugh at that question, pointing to ZAR’s paltry goal totals, but the Penguins’ improved defense and penalty killing are not laughing matters — and ZAR was an important part of that.

Advertise with us

I mean, the Penguins are fourth in the NHL in goals-against average. How often has that happened in franchise history? Their penalty killing you know about. Many, many factors go into both — notably great goaltending — but let’s not pretend ZAR was a useless piece. He’d become a pretty good defensive player.

Having said that, goals are at a premium come playoff time, and ZAR did not produce nearly enough of them. Hopefully, Rakell will. He scores in a variety of ways when he’s at his best — deflections, wrap-arounds, handsy moves from close-range, one-timers, you name it.

I’m eager to watch his game on a nightly basis. You never really know about a player until you see him every game. Malkin’s greatest collaborator was James Neal, who had a knack for finding open space and using his quick release on Malkin feeds. I’m not sure Rakell is that kind of sniper, but that doesn’t mean he won’t mesh with Malkin.

I’m not at all concerned about the second-round pick, Dominik Simon or prospect goalie Calle Clang. Ron Hextall dealt from his one organizational strength — goaltending — and brought in a player who could potentially provide a scoring boost when it counts.

We’ve seen very good Penguins teams die on the vine because they couldn’t score (think of two goals in an entire Bruins series). It took Phil Kessel, Patric Hornqvist, etc., to change that situation. You gotta find goals when you need them against great goaltending.

Advertise with us

This was worth a shot.

Rich N, @rxn128: Hi Joe. You’re the Steelers GM. If Cleveland would deal Baker for a low draft pick, or if they cut him outright, do you take a gamble on him and have 3 1st rd picks and one with a 1st rd grade complete for the starting job?

Starkey: Yes, I do, Dr. N — just for the sheer absurdity of it and for all the fun we’d have in camp. I also love your phrasing: three first-round picks and “one with a first-round grade.” That claim about Mason Rudolph shall live in infamy.

In truth, I probably wouldn’t recommend this. And the Steelers definitely won’t do it. But one could easily make an argument that Baker Mayfield would be the best quarterback at Steelers camp. He had a pretty good season just two years ago. He’s still young. He’s obviously talented.

Let’s put it this way: If they announced they were bringing in a recently released Mayfield to camp and getting rid of Rudolph, I wouldn’t rip them. I think Trubisky vs. Mayfield would be epic.

Advertise with us

Barry Sherry, @TrekRef: Take this CBA and jump in your time machine back to 1973. With free agency do the Steelers pick up Bradshaw’s fifth year option or let him walk?

Starkey: Interesting question, Dr. Sherry, but it would be an obvious choice: Pick up the option.

If the time to pick up the option were after Year 2, you could look back and wonder if the Steelers or any team would have been patient with Bradshaw. He was 8-13 at that point, with 19 touchdowns and 46 interceptions.

Yes, 19 TDs and 46 interceptions. Social media would have buried him. Fans would have buried him. Media would have buried him. And maybe the latter two entities did (I was only 6 at the time, so not yet capable of ripping quarterbacks).

The time to pick up the option, however, arrives after Year 3, and Bradshaw went 11-3 that year (1972) and led the Steelers to their first playoff win ... well ... ever. You might remember a memorable pass to win that playoff game.

Advertise with us

So if your point is that teams run out of patience with young quarterbacks way too quickly these days, it’s a fair one, but if your point is that the Steelers might have made Bradshaw play Year 4 without picking up his option for Year 5? No way.

Luke Sweeney, @LukeSweeney5000: Joe, is the recent spate of free agent signings ensuring cap hell on the horizon? Or have the Rams influenced the Steelers to alter their philosophy?

Starkey: Actually, Dr. Sweeney (and I’m partial to that name for reasons I will explain in a moment), the Steelers left themselves an out with just about all their free agent contracts.

Here’s an example, as our Gerry Dulac tweeted: “The only part of Mitchell Trubisky’s contract that is guaranteed is his $5 million signing bonus, making the deal very cap friendly for the Steelers, per sources.”

Also, the deals for Levi Wallace, Myles Jack and Ahkello Witherspoon are for only two years, and the one for Mason Cole is hardly prohibitive. And the one for James Daniels seems very reasonable at three years. So if anything, the Steelers were very thrifty and reasonable with these deals. Not a ton of long-term risk involved.

Advertise with us

As for the name Sweeney, there is a legend among my friends that is simply called “The Sweeney Bust.” My parents were away. I had a giant party, against their wishes (I was expressly forbidden from staging such a gathering), and the next morning my parents’ good friend Jim Sweeney made an unannounced visit to the house. Clearly, they had commissioned him to run a check. My buddies and I were cleaning up the mess — and still drinking out of the keg — when I saw Mr. Sweeney walking down the driveway. My heart sank. He had the power to crush me. He could have told my parents what went down.

Instead, he took a look around, made a joke of some sort and never told. It ironically goes down in history as “The Sweeney Bust.” What a man.

Ryan Knee, @Elbowuindagut: Prediction time Dr. Starkey. The east looks completely up in the air w/any of the 8 teams capable of winning. The Pens get Rakell, FLA changed their whole squad, TOR seems to finally care. So who faces off in the ECF and who does the winner meet to play for the cup?

Starkey: I still like Tampa, Dr. Knee. They quietly refurbished their third line. They have the star power. They have the best goalie. They have an elite shut-down defenseman. They’re the team to beat.

Tampa-Colorado in the final.

Advertise with us

Yinzer, Esq., @LegallyJewish: At this point it would be kind of a joke and nothing more than service time manipulation to send Oneil Cruz to the minors, no? Guy hit one that hasn’t landed yet and maybe if even just as a DH he’d be worth keeping around.

Starkey: My understanding, as relayed by the Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey, is that Cruz’s future free agency status would not be impacted by bringing him north to start the season. So bring him north, I say.

Darrin Havis, @YetiTheGreat: Do you think Alice Cooper will help Baker move since they are neighbors?

Starkey: Man, I hope so. I hope the commercials remain. They could make a whole series of Baker moving to Seattle.

Jonny Hammhause, @Big_Riverr: Do the Steelers take a pit stop from the Trubisky train in April and draft another QB?

Advertise with us

Starkey: My sense is no — but if Malik Willis is somehow there at No. 20, all bets are off, Dr. Hammhause.

Does a tiny part of me wonder if they’ve been playing possum all along and love Pickett? Yes. But only a tiny part.

not a pirate, @RevD98: Cruz going to be imprisoned by super 2?

Starkey: See answer above. I sure hope not. If keeping him with the team merely allows him to go to arbitration sooner, who cares? The Pirates should pay up if and when that time comes.

MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: How will you remember Dom Simon’s time in Pittsburgh and when do you think he’ll be back?

Advertise with us

Starkey: I won’t. And probably next season.

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.