Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Flowers and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Moon Unit #104, @EricHay88658128: How many more wins could Mason Rudolph realistically produce over Ben Roethlisberger if he took the helm with this version of the Steelers?

Starkey: I have no idea, Dr. Moon Unit (are you one of Frank Zappa's kids?), but I’d be willing to take that chance.

Question is, when will the Steelers take that chance?

Advertise with us

I keep hearing about how much they believe in Rudolph, how they’re convinced they can win with him, and yet I keep watching a quarterback who is becoming the football equivalent of that 7 billion-year-old rock they found in Australia (except the rock moves faster).

I guess the Steelers are so excited at the prospect of playing Rudolph that they brought back a slumping 39-year-old quarterback on a pay cut and continue to play him through late-stage-Jake-Delhomme outings like the one he turned in Sunday.

Would Rudolph be any better?

No guarantees, obviously. I’m not a huge Rudolph fan. But there’s a chance — and it’s probably better than one in seven billion.

First, Rudolph can move at least a tiny bit. He’s not Michael Vick, but he’s at least Nate Peterman, and the threat of a quarterback who could move a tiny bit would give Matt Canada a chance to open his playbook, which in turn might open things up for Najee Harris and ease the pressure on the offensive line.

Advertise with us

Also, Rudolph would give the Steelers a chance to hit more plays down the field. How much worse can they get on those types of plays (rare as they are)?

I happen to believe, for example, that Rudolph would have completed the two much-discussed throws to JuJu Smith-Schuster in Green Bay.

Ex-Steelers linebacker Vince Williams believes JuJu should have caught the first one (and I do so love it when former Steelers still try to stir the stuff in the locker room; it seems to happen here more than anywhere else). He tweeted: “True #1 Wideouts make that catch.”

I guess, if the true No. 1 wideout is Manute Bol on stilts. I had more of an issue with JuJu on the second one, where it looked like he couldn’t find the ball and then did not lay out for it. But that is all beside the point.

The point is this: Both throws were bad. So were many, many others. The Steelers had a chance at two touchdowns, and Ben failed to make the necessary throws. If Rudolph has a strength, it’s pushing the ball downfield. I think he makes both throws (although who knows if the second one presents itself if the first one connects).

Advertise with us

I have finally arrived at place where I believe Mason Rudolph might give the Steelers a better chance of winning than Ben does — and that’s saying something.

Bobby, @BuStA607: If the Steelers continue to struggle, should players like Haden and JuJu who are upcoming free agents be traded to stock pile draft picks?

Starkey: Absolutely yes, Dr. Bob. The trade deadline is Nov. 2, and if the Steelers are, say, 2-5 at that point, all bets are off and all trades should be on. Those two and James Washington would be realistic trade candidates.

The Steelers would be wise to get what they can.

JuJu, by the way, made a huge mistake coming back here instead of going to Kansas City. I kind of figured that would be the case.

Advertise with us

jay steele, @jsteelersbruno: Do you think Crosby should play in the 2022 Olympics coming off an injury?

Starkey: Sidney Crosby should do whatever he wants, Dr. Steele. He has more than earned that right. I seem to remember some controversy around Mario Lemieux participating in the 2002 Salt Lake City Olympics when he was struggling to stay healthy with the Penguins. He played. They won. He earned that right.

Armand Posipanka, @Posipanka: Who out of this group is back to the Steelers next year: Colbert, Tomlin, Canada, Butler, Ben?

Starkey: Very intriguing question, Dr. Posipanka. VERY intriguing question.

BACK: Tomlin, Colbert, Canada, Butler.

Advertise with us

NOT BACK: Ben.

I think they’ll want Canada to have a chance with a quarterback who can run, or at least walk — although there is hardly a guarantee he’ll be back. I’d put it at 60%.

Tomlin isn’t going anywhere.

Colbert is year to year at the moment, and there are two ways to view that one: Either his highly competitive nature won’t allow him to step down after a rotten season, or he’ll figure, at age 64, it’s the perfect time to walk away. I’m betting on the former.

Meanwhile, it remains a mystery how much of the defense Butler is responsible for. Does he make the majority of the calls on game days? Nobody will say. Tomlin has a huge hand in the defense, and he is very comfortable with Butler. Butler turns 66 before next season, but I’m betting he’ll be back.

Advertise with us

#NeverAgain, @moletru: Do you think the Pirates were the most enjoyable to watch really bad team in years?

Starkey: I don’t know. I stopped watching.

Having said that, Dr. @moletru, I did happen to catch a good part of Saturday night’s game, and it reminded me of better times at the ballpark. Good-sized crowd. Actual noise. An intriguing young player (Oneil Cruz) making his debut.

I’ll take more of all that moving forward. I remain of the opinion that Ben Cherington is doing this right so far. He is stocking the system with enticing prospects. He is trying to follow the Tampa Bay Rays’ blueprint. I’m not sure what else people expected him to do.

Whether he’ll get this team back into contention remains to be seen, but I’m actually more optimistic about the Pirates’ future than I am our other two teams at the moment.

Advertise with us

@joansmeltzer, @skjdad4: When Ben retires (hopefully after this season) do you think he will join the ranks of retired players in the booth?

Starkey: Ben is on the record saying he’ll live more of a Jack Lambert-like recluse life than anything else, so I wouldn’t bet on it, Dr. Smeltzer. Then again, I’ve been surprised before at who winds up in the booth or studio. Bill Cowher would be Exhibit A.

Todd McCollum, @mccollumT: Pirates starting pitching staff in 2022?

Starkey: Is that a punch line or a question, Dr. McCollum? Either way, I’ve got a good one for you, too: Pirates’ opening day starter in 2022?

Seriously, who would you pick? There’s no way Mitch Keller has earned that right. Steven Brault? JT Brubaker? Roansy Contreras? Who’s even in the rotation? Bryse Wilson, Miguel Yajure, Dillon Peters? Wil Crowe?

Advertise with us

I’ll go Wilson, Keller, Brubaker, Yajure and hopefully Contreras, although he’ll probably start in Class AAA. Also don’t discount the wily veteran free agent-to-be-peddled-at-the-deadline. That’s always fun.

And yet, somehow, I feel like the opening day starter will be Brault. Go figure.

DC Pitt Fan, @hailtopitt2005: What in the world is Snell still doing on this football team? With cap space allegedly still available, why haven’t the Steelers made any moves to try and address the o-line or defensive depth? Also, Pickett for Heisman?

Starkey: I’ll take those one at a time, Dr. @hailtopitt2005.

• Snell. He had a memorable performance Sunday, didn’t he? Holding penalty on kickoff, zero-yard run and a dropped pass. That’s a hat trick! I’d try Kalen Ballage if they’re going to give Najee Harris relief from time to time — and by the way, there is no way Harris survives the season taking the kind of pounding he’s taking.

Advertise with us

• Lines. There probably isn’t anyone out there worth taking, and yes, I know, you’re thinking: Could anyone be worse than some of the backups around here? You’re probably right.

• Pickett. He’s been phenomenal so far. Absolutely a Heisman candidate in my book (although I do not have a ballot). Check out this piece, in which you’ll find the following excerpt:

“Pickett’s 19 passing touchdowns are second in the nation behind SMU QB Tanner Mordecai. Furthermore, Pickett sits in the top 10 nationally for yards per attempt and yards per game while throwing just one interception. In a football landscape that demands a quarterback be able to impact the game on the ground too, Pickett also has the goods. His statistics won’t wow in the same way as Willis or Corral, but he can nonetheless alter the game with his legs.

“As Pitt emerges as a contender in the ACC, Pickett is ascending as a Heisman Trophy candidate. As a result, DraftKings has shortened his odds to +6000 following Week 5.”

Halvy Buckets, @halvybuckets: Kenny Pickett will be invited to the Heisman ceremony, true or false?

Advertise with us

Starkey: See above, Dr. Buckets. Pitt’s going to need to win just about every game from here on out — a show-out game against Clemson, regardless of its current state, would be huge for Pickett — in order for him to get to New York, but how could I rule it out with the way he’s playing?

Skip Bittman, @BittmanSkip: Should NextGen NFL stats implement a new stat measuring throws short of the sticks on fourth downs? The acronym should in some way honor the 2021 Steelers.

Starkey: I think they might already have something like that, Dr. Bittman. ESPN stats does, anyway. Check out this tweet from Brooke Pryor: “Ben Roethlisberger is now the only QB in the last 20 seasons to lose yardage on multiple 4th-down completions in the same season, per ESPN Stats and Info.”

I can’t think of a sadder stat.

Can you?

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.