Who’s next?
Will Justin Champagnie make it to the weekend?
It wasn’t even three years ago — June 7, 2018, to be exact — that I sat in the not-yet-decorated office of new Pitt basketball coach Jeff Capel, marveling at the strength of his last-second recruiting class.
Capel had inherited a raging tire fire from Kevin Stallings but somehow managed to reel in the 35th-ranked class in the country.
I wrote: One four-star recruit (Trey McGowens) chose Pitt sight-unseen and reclassified to become eligible this season. Another four-star (Au’Diese Toney) also reclassified. A highly regarded combo guard named Xavier Johnson paid for his own visit after decommitting from Nebraska.
I called it a “minor miracle” to land three such players under the circumstances. Less than three years later, another miracle has occurred. Or maybe it’s a magic trick: All three have disappeared.
Read More
What in the world is going on with Pitt basketball?
Players transfer like crazy these days. I get it. Duke just said goodbye to potential NBA lottery pick Jalen Johnson.
But guess what? Pitt’s not Duke.
Duke can make a fantasy roster with different players every year. Pitt has to find lesser recruits, develop them and hope they stay awhile.
It wasn’t too eye-opening when McGowens, Ryan Murphy and others left earlier in Capel’s tenure. It’s quite different when two of your best three players enter the transfer portal 25 hours apart with three games left in the season (Capel said Toney might not have played, anyway, because of a concussion).
There is no normalizing this. The program appears to be in a state of turmoil. Confidence in a coach who once seemed like a slam-dunk hire has to be shaken.
Barely a month ago, after a victory over Duke, Champagnie declared, “Pitt is back.” It sure looked that way. The Panthers were 8-2 overall and 4-1 in the ACC. Capel’s old boss, Mike Krzyzewski, couldn’t say enough kind words about how Capel had “built his program.”
“[The players] played a lot of minutes last year and showed flashes of really playing well,” Krzyzewski said. “Now they're ready to take another step. Jeff's stuck with those kids. They look like they’ve got great rapport and they're playing really hard and well together.”
Not anymore. And the issues go way beyond sudden player exits …
• Capel has no recruits secured for 2021 or 2022. My colleague Craig Meyer tells me Pitt is the only ACC team without one for ’21 and that 91 of the top 100 recruits in the country are either signed or committed.
• Champagnie might head to the NBA, where some have him ranked among the top 25 prospects.
• Capel’s highest-rated recruit from the 2020 class, John Hugley, is indefinitely suspended while facing three felony charges related to a car theft last summer,
• The Panthers were crumbling down the stretch for the third consecutive season even with Toney and Johnson. They're 1-7 since the Duke game.
If Johnson had been the only one to leave, this would feel different. Capel had already benched him this season and ripped him after Johnson picked up a technical foul last week against N.C. State.
“Nothing I’ve said has worked,” Capel said, referencing Johnson’s behavior toward officials.
But now Toney, regarded by many as the heartbeat of the team, leaves the very next day?
Addressing the departures on his 93.7 The Fan radio show Thursday, Capel said, “It’s been an interesting week, to say the least,” but offered no insight as to what actually happened.
Which leaves the rest of us to speculate.
Were there outside influences contributing to the players’ decisions?
Irreconcilable differences with Capel that couldn’t wait to be addressed?
In-fighting among players?
It’s not uncommon for a new coach to reset the team culture by clearing out some players and sending stern messages to others. Ben Howland did it. But that was year one, not year three. These were Capel’s guys.
Capel claims the exodus will not have a lasting impact.
“Long-term, I don’t see any effects, to be honest with you,” he said.
We’ll see. He might ironically have to dig deeper into the transfer portal than he ever could have imagined. The Pitt Panthers could become the Pitt Transfers, although Capel has plenty of room to add talent via traditional means.
Who knows, maybe we look back on all this as something that needed to happen before things got really good. Could be, although that feels like a fairy tale at the moment.
Capel won’t be trying to clean up Kevin Stallings’ mess next season.
He’ll be trying to clean up his own.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.