Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lucius Allen and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Stephen Dotts, @sdotts136: Regardless of how the Penguins finish this postseason, if the organization were to choose Jarry over Murray, about how much money would that save them throughout the remaining Crosby/Malkin championship window, and how best could the Penguins allocate those savings?

Stephen Dotts, @sdotts136: I ask because everyone else seems to have a firm opinion on the situation, but I have no idea how to answer those two questions and haven’t seen any meaningful analysis on them, which means I can’t form any meaningful opinion on this really fun/popular controversy! Please help!

Starkey: Quite the fascinating situation, Dr. Dotts, is it not?

Advertise with us

First, there are several unknowns — how the postseason shakes out, how the ongoing pandemic shapes the NHL salary cap in coming years — so you’re not going to get definitive answers, no matter where you look. There are more questions than answers.

Just know this: The Penguins cannot afford both goalies long-term, quite clearly, and likely cannot afford both for even one more season. Each is slated to be a restricted free agent after the playoffs. One will likely have to go.

Which one?

That, my friend, might be one of the biggest questions in Penguins history. It was an easy call three years ago when the Penguins chose Murray over Marc-Andre Fleury. Murray was younger and cheaper and had just won two Stanley Cups.

This one isn’t so easy. What if Murray wins the Cup again? Are the Penguins really going to jettison a 26-year-old goalie with three championship rings?

Advertise with us

A pandemic-shrunken cap might answer that question for them. Like just about everything, the answer is tied to money. How much will Murray want? How much would he be worth? How much could the Penguins afford?

It would have been one thing if Murray’s relative contemporaries — the John Gibsons, Connor Hellebuycks and Braden Holtbys of the world — had set the bar. All of them signed in recent years for slightly more than $6 million per season. That might have been doable, even if Murray has more hardware.

But that was before Andrei Vasilevskiy raised the bar, big-time, on July 29 of last year. Unlike veteran goalies (Sergei Bobrovsky, for example) who signed mega deals as free agents, Vasilevskiy signed from a Murray-like leverage point: in his mid-20s, not yet at UFA status. Yet, Vasilevskiy secured an eight-year, $76 million extension — $9.5 million annually.

So again, what would Murray be worth? What would he want?

And what if he doesn’t win the Cup or even make it out of the playoffs as the No. 1 starter. What then?

Advertise with us

As you can see, Dr. Dotts, this gets complicated. How sold are you on Jarry? How sold are the Penguins?

To answer your question simply, as best I can at the moment, the Penguins would obviously save massive amounts of money over the next few years by choosing Jarry over Murray.

But at what cost?

Let’s revisit when the playoffs end.

Ryan Knee, @Elbowuindagut: Which one Pirate player is most deserving to play for a contending team right now? Skill and experience come into play here.

Advertise with us

Starkey: Colin Moran. And in keeping with their run to the No. 1 pick, I would trade him ASAP.

Speaking of which, Mr. Knee, did you see what manager Derek Shelton said about summoning Miguel Del Pozo to face Marwin Gonzalez in Tuesday’s loss?

Shelton said he “liked the matchup.” To which I say, no matchup that involves Miguel Del Pozo is one to like. Del Pozo has eight walks, no strikeouts and a 21.60 ERA. He once had a season in Class AA where he walked 11.3 batters per nine innings (perspective: that’s not good). He does not belong in the major leagues, which is precisely why the Pirates should keep him and pitch him often.

No. 1 pick, remember.

Jayson Lillie, @Jay_Lil75: More believable story? Milk run or Mueller with nine straight 3s??

Advertise with us

Starkey: By “milk run,” Mr. Lillie, you are referring to Derek Jeter’s tale of wayward Miami Marlins players, several of whom tested positive for COVID-19 after a stay in Atlanta.

Were they hitting the nightclubs? Jeter, the team owner, says no.

Jon Heyman’s tweet: “Jeter defends Marlins players, says they just let their guard down in Atlanta and weren’t running around. A few left the hotel but just for a milk, a coffee and in one case a dinner at a house. They didn’t do a good job of social distancing but they weren’t out carousing, he says.”

Who doesn’t appreciate a good milk run when they’re on the road?

Unbelievably, I’m going to take Mullsy’s claim of making nine straight 3s in a pickup game at Penn State as more believable than Jeter’s milk dud, though I’m not buying either.

Advertise with us

Todd McCollum, @mccollumT: Switch hitters, Bell, Reynolds and Cole are off to slow starts at the plate. What is the formula to get switch hitters on track when they’re not hitting from either side?

Starkey: Slow? Bell’s at .194, and Reynolds is hitting a pitcher-like .129. Tucker looks like Paul Goldschmidt compared to those two, at a robust .211.

I have no idea how to answer your question, Todd, and I apologize for that. The Pirates face mostly right-handers (although it’s lefty Rich Hill on Tuesday), so I would suggest getting going from the left side would be advisable. And in truth, I believe Bell and Reynolds will hit. This is a small sample size, as they say, although the harsh reality is that the whole season is a small sample size.

frank kingerski, @fski3: Why don’t we hold the Pirates as accountable as the Penguins as a town?

Starkey: Don’t we? I mean, don’t you? Fans basically stopped going to games in recent years, Frank. The Pirates sunk to fourth-worst in baseball in attendance in 2019, barely averaging 18,000 fans per game. That was a pretty loud message from the populace.

Advertise with us

What better way to hold a team accountable?

michael, @mwaters2016: What would the NHL do if one of the teams to reach the Stanley Cup final had multiple players testing positive for COVID-19?

Starkey: That’s the kind of question looming over every sport, Michael: What happens if key players are suddenly missing for the biggest games?

Do you make the Oilers play without Connor McDavid and five other players, for example, or do you postpone the games until they can field a representative team?

Popular opinion, I’m guessing, would be to make a team play as if it were dealing with any other injury/illness situation. Let’s hope we never get there.

Advertise with us

Euro, @Reitz_Crackers: What do you think is your highest caloric intake in a single day?

Starkey: I’ve had days packed with Genny Cream, Duff’s wings, Bocce’s pizza and Tim Horton’s donuts, Dr. Crackers. Not proud of it, by any means, and I didn’t feel especially well in the morning. But to your question, I would say something like 40,000-60,000 calories.

I may have approached six figures on a given Bills Sunday.

Cale Berger, @cale_berger: Best signature shot in basketball outside of the sky hook?

Starkey: Wonderful question, Dr. Berger — and as I’ve told you many times, your name is perhaps the greatest in culinary history. If one food item could represent new-age healthy eating, it might be kale (Cale), and if one could represent old-school caloric intake, it might be a cheeseburger (Berger).

Advertise with us

Cale. Berger. It’s a miracle!

I would say Tim Duncan’s bank shot is one. The Dream Shake. The Kevin McHale up-and-under. Rick Barry’s underhanded free throw. The Michael Jordan fadeaway (Dirk Nowitzki’s, too). The Elvin Hayes turnaround. The Steph Curry 3-pointer (of any type). But if you’re asking for one, it has to be this: The George Gervin finger roll. It even has its own GIF!

Feast your eyes on this, Cale Berger:

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.