Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lucius Allen and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Jim: This will be Kevin Colbert’s 21st draft with the Steelers. Who are your top five and bottom five Colbert first round picks?

My top five, in reverse order:

5) Cam Heyward – Three Pro Bowls, two All Pro first teams

Advertise with us

4) David DeCastro – Five Pro Bowls, two All Pro first teams, one All Pro second Ttams

3) Maurkice Pouncey – Eight Pro Bowls, two All Pro first teams, three All Pro second teams, NFL 2010s all-decade team

2) Ben Roethlisberger – Two Super Bowl wins, Six Pro Bowls

1) Troy Polamalu – In the discussion for the top five to ever play his position

My bottom five in reverse order:

Advertise with us

5) Kendall Simmons – Not bad for his first five seasons and did get a second contract, but injury and illness shorten his career. No Pro Bowls

4) Ziggy Hood – Didn’t get a second contract

3) Rashard Mendenhall – Only lasted 6 years in the league and cost the Steelers Super Bowl XLV

2) Artie Burns – Barely started and got worse as his career went on

1) Jarvis Jones – Only lasted four years in the league with a whopping six total sacks

Advertise with us

Starkey: I didn’t look at your picks before I made mine, Jim — and congratulations on asking the longest “question” in mailbag history (it was edited on account of it being too long, even for the internet).

Now, do I simply take the best players, or do I consider where the player was picked? Only once have the Steelers picked higher than 10th in all those years — and that was the very first one (Plaxico Burress, 8th).

TOP FIVE

5. T.J. Watt: With the 30th pick? Already a premier pass rusher.

4. Cam Heyward: With the 31st pick? A stellar presence for several years, no drop-off in game.

Advertise with us

3. Maurkice Pouncey: Possible Hall of Famer with 18th pick.

2. Troy Polamalu: Steelers boldly moved up to draft an all-time great safety.

1. Ben Roethlisberger: Cowher wanted an offensive lineman, Dan Rooney stepped in. But all of this falls on Colbert’s record, so we’ll give him credit for franchise-changing player.

Apologies to David DeCastro (24th), Santonio Holmes (25th), Heath Miller (30th), Casey Hampton (19th) and Ryan Shazier (15th).

BOTTOM FIVE

Advertise with us

5. Hard for me to take Kendall Simmons here, although it's all relative to the other picks. He did start on a Super Bowl-winning team. Meanwhile, the Steelers need Terrell Edmunds to make a Bud Dupree-like reversal. He took a step back last season.

4. Rashard Mendenhall: Mixed feelings here, because he did have a couple of very good seasons, but it’s all relative.

3. Ziggy Hood: Just sort of there, although he lasted a decade in the league.

2. Artie Burns: No explanation necessary.

1. Jarvis Jones: See above.

Advertise with us

Starkey: What about Plax?

Starkey: Great question, Joe. On one hand, he was drafted a pick ahead of Hall of Fame linebacker Brian Urlacher. On the other, he was way more productive than the other wide receivers taken in the first round, including Peter Warrick, who was taken four picks higher than him — fourth overall by the Bengals!

The other first-round WRs that year, for the record: Travis Taylor, Slyvester Morris and somebody named R. Jay Soward, who flamed out because of off-the-field issues after making all of 14 catches for the Jacksonville Jaguars.

It wasn’t a great first round that year, starting at the very top with Courtney Brown (good one, Browns). The Raiders took a kicker (Sebastian Janikowski), for goodness sake.

Overall then, Plax was a good pick — he had two 1,000-yard seasons here, including 1,325 in Year 3 — even if he declined late in his Steelers career (and do you remember that he returned to make three catches in 2012? Me neither).

Advertise with us

Jordan Lundquist, @jorr_94: Being that it’s already April 13th, is the Pirates undefeated season sustainable?

Starkey: This one’s getting old.

But yes, I think it’s sustainable.

Donald Hilenbrant, @Hildebeest24: If you had to cover ONE non-major sport full-time, (football, baseball, hockey, basketball off the table) what would it be?

Starkey: AnythingButGolf, Donald. Is that a sport?

Advertise with us

Tennis would be interesting — I once did a sit-down with Ilie Nastase — but I would probably opt for bowling. Can you imagine life on bowling beat? Would I wear a bowling shirt to events? Would I wear multi-colored bowling shoes around the house?

Mike Purpura, @papsferrari: Would you rather see the Steelers draft an offensive weapon in the second round or a defensive player?

Starkey: If they don’t have a quarterback they’re in love with — a potential upgrade on Mason Rudolph — I’d take a right-now weapon for Ben. If J.K. Dobbins is on the board, for example, I’m all over that. Could be the running back of the future and could help right away. The defense looks pretty good to me, Dr. Purpura, although there is always a need for depth.

not a pirate, @RevD98: Teams like to take a QB in the late rounds for competition. But sometimes they stick. Who’s your sleeper QB this year? E Kentucky kid?

Starkey: So you’re looking for this year’s Gardner Minshew, Mr. not a pirate?

Advertise with us

I’ll let the experts break this one down. Here’s an outstanding article from the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

Frankie J Ryan, @Frankie32110332: Steelers will have alot  of good players to choose from at pick 49. Should they add an offensive lineman if that is the BPA on their board or add another weapon for Ben? ... I would love to see them draft Antoine Winfield Jr., but doubt he will be available.

Starkey: Please refer to Mike’s question above — although I will say, Antoine Winfield Jr. would be an interesting player to add to the defensive backfield. And not just because his dad played for the Bills.

Several mock drafts I have seen placed him right around pick No. 49. CBSSports.com, for example, has Winfield going four picks later to the Eagles, dropping there because of injury concerns. There is little question he’s a first-round talent.

Winfield can play safety and slot corner. ESPN draft analysts Mel Kiper Jr. and Todd McShay project him as a first-round pick. That would be a help-now pick, I would think.

Advertise with us

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Click here to sign up for our FREE all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed