Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lindy Ruff and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Ryan Knee, @Elbowuindagut: Can you give me Jimmy Rs reasoning on the Kahun trade? It’s not a bad trade but Kahun was playing well. Does he like Sheary and Rodrigues that much, fear not being able to afford Kahun later, just love the depth, all of the above?

Starkey: First, let’s be clear about this, Mr. Knee: They traded Dominik Kahun, not Dominik Hasek. Kahun had two goals in his past 21 games, albeit around some injuries. Evan Rodrigues has five goals in his past 13 games.

Don’t get me wrong. I liked Kahun. He seemed like a decent fit on Evgeni Malkin’s left wing. He is a clever playmaker. But I think the franchise survives. Maybe thrives, with more depth up front. That, I believe, is why Rutherford made the deal — perhaps sacrificing a small bit of quality (if you believe Kahun was the best player in the deal) for quantity.

Advertise with us

Conor Sheary is still only 27. He had 37 even-strength goals in his two full seasons here — and some very big playoff goals. I’m not sure what happened in Buffalo, but sometimes you can go home again. Ben Lovejoy did. Mike Sullivan now has more options up front, with three new versatile additions (including Patrick Marleau), and with his ability to juggle lines, chase matchups and keep players motivated through lineup decisions, that is a good thing.

Rodrigues is an interesting case. This was Lance Lysowski of the Buffalo News after Rodrigues signed back for this season, through an arbitrator’s decision:

“He emerged as a top-six forward last season, posting career highs in goals (9) and points (29) in 74 games, while ranking fourth among Sabres forwards in average time on ice (15:49). Additionally, among Sabres forwards with at least 70 games played, Rodrigues ranked fourth in on-ice 5-on-5 shot differential.He also ranked third on the team in faceoffs. Despite earning a more prominent role, Rodrigues struggled at times offensively, converting on only 5.4 percent of his shots on goal and enduring a few difficult stretches.”

Those stretches continued this season — actually, the whole first part of the season — but Rodrigues in this environment could be intriguing.

Meanwhile, to refresh your memory, here is Jason Mackey’s story on the circumstances surrounding Sheary’s departure from Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

J B, @Jon_Brennan: Joe, do you know who is the designated emergency goalie for home games in Pittsburgh? I remember a game back in I think the 90s where then head coach Eddie Johnston told the ref to give him 20 mins and he'd suit up after the second goalie went down with a potential injury.

Starkey: And I’ll bet E.J. would have played well, knowing him. Last I checked, JB, this was the Penguins’ emergency goalie situation.

Steve Bryan, @ohsteveb: What made you take the career path that you took? Any regrets?

Starkey: 1. Luck and love of sports — and Mike White answering the phone when I called to see if the Post-Gazette needed anyone to take high school football scores in 1991. Otherwise, I probably would have been a high school teacher/coach or something like that.

2. Mullsy.

Advertise with us

Skip Bittman,Human Scum, @BittmanSkip: Any XFL rule you’d like in the NFL?

Starkey: The kickoff rule, without question, Mr. Human Scum, and Lorenzo Reyes of USA Today said it very well in this excerpt:

“Essentially, the kicker stands at the 30-yard line and must put the ball in play between the opposing end zone and 20-yard line. The coverage team lines up at the 35-yard line on the receiving side of the field, while the return team lines up just five yards away at the 30-yard line. Both sides can’t move until the return man touches the ball. The tweaks have seemingly made the play safer, with the violent collisions apparently reduced. But the kickoff has remained interesting and exciting, with touchbacks less likely. Because if the return man can make a few players miss, there’s nothing but open field beyond, creating incentives to return the ball. Just look at what the BattleHawks did when safety Joe Powell took a reverse from receiver Keith Mumphrey and returned it 84 yards for the XFL’s first kickoff return touchdown in league history.”

Key phrase there: “The kickoff has remained interesting.” That is decidedly not the case in the NFL.

R M Perich, @RperichM: Based on your sponsors I need to ask ... are all listeners impotent gamblers in legal trouble with clogged toilets?

Advertise with us

Starkey: No, just half of them.

christopher manning, @christo53294495: Why was Eli Rogers discarded when he seemed to be a better route runner, better punt returner and more effective overall than Switzer? He seemed to be coming along. What don’t we know?

Starkey: A few things here, Mr. Manning. First, Eli hasn’t returned a punt since 2017 and has a lower career punt-return average (7.3) than Ryan Switzer (8.0), not that Switzer will remind anyone of Devin Hester. Switzer averaged an astoundingly low 3.6 yards on eight punt returns last season. Also, Rogers did have a decent game to end the 2018 season (nine catches, 57 yards) against the Bengals JV team, but I’m not sure I’d say he was “coming along.”

However, I agree with you: I thought he was a better option than Switzer going into 2020. You know who apparently didn’t, though? Ben Roethlisberger, who thought Switzer had the makings of the next Julian Edelman.

“I just think he’s got the abilities to do that,” Roethlisberger said before the season. “I mean, that’s high praise, because Edelman’s a really good receiver. Obviously, he’s been doing it for a while and everything, but I believe [Switzer] can do that, too.”

Advertise with us

Thankfully, Ben is not a scout. Switzer averaged less per reception (3.4) than per punt return. I get the idea of leaning toward your franchise quarterback when it’s a close race for the final receiver spot, but after Roethlisberger’s injury, Switzer’s roster spot became inexplicable.

Rogers, meanwhile, is off to a decent start with the XFL’s DC Defenders. He also never lost love for Roethlisberger, posting this about Roethlisberger after the Steelers released him:

“Thank You for your support throughout the years. You was a genuine person to me and there for me throughout the years if ever I needed guidance as a young player and I appreciate you for that. #Love"

Philip Lynch, @PhilLynch333: What is the best song with a question as the title?

Starkey: “Where Are You Tonight? (Journey Through Dark Heat)” — Bob Dylan, Street Legal

Advertise with us

Five most underrated Dylan songs:

5. To Ramona

4. Just Like Tom Thumb’s Blues

3. Every Grain of Sand

2. Dark Eyes

Advertise with us

1. Precious Angel — an absolute miracle off “Slow Train Comin’,” which is an acquired taste, but once consumed could change a life.

Steve Hunter, @adjectivesteve: Will you sign my copy of your book?

Starkey: Of course I will, Dr. Hunter, and I will take the opportunity here to inform the American people that my book — “Tales From the Pittsburgh Penguins Locker Room” — can still be bought at Amazon.com for $12.99 on Kindle or $8.95 hardcover. The customer reviews give it a 4.8 out of 5, not that I’m keeping track. Mike Lange’s foreword is a thing of beauty!

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Sign up for our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.