Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Princell Brockenbrough and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Sandip, @sjain316: Do you agree with Mike Tomlin regarding his perception of the ESPN interview with Garrett? Would that be classified as poor journalism?

Starkey: Tomlin was not referring to the interview itself, Mr. Sandip, but rather the “Outside The Lines” panel discussion that followed — and that discussion was basically framed this way: “What if Myles Garrett is telling the truth?”

There was no discussion framed as, “What if Garrett is lying?”

Advertise with us

The discussion went to some very strange places.

One panelist, Ariel Helwani, said, “I kind of feel like (Rudolph’s) gotten off scot-free here.”

Sure, I mean, other than a potentially ruined reputation (and a $50,000 fine).

Another, Michele Steele, said, “I think it makes the Steelers look bad, and by extension it makes the league look bad, because the inference there is that you have a player saying racist things on the field with zero discipline.”

Huh? So is the inference there that the Steelers covered up a racial slur? That inference might have drawn Tomlin’s ire, and rightfully so. Imagine all the crap, all the bigotry, he endured on his way to becoming an NFL coach. You think he goes to the mat for a backup quarterback if he thinks the guy is lying?

Advertise with us

Steele on Rudolph: “He’s gonna have to speak up.”

He has. Multiple times.

A third panelist, Ryan Smith, said he spent a day with Garrett and, “He does not strike me as the kind of person who would throw out a false accusation for the entire country to see.”

Does Tomlin strike Smith that way? Because this has now become a case of Tomlin’s word versus Garrett’s word. Tomlin, via his ESPN appearance with Stephen A. Smith, has essentially called Garrett a liar.

I’m with another ESPN personality — Michael Wilbon — on this one.

Advertise with us

Wilbon’s words from PTI:

“Just from watching Mike Tomlin from afar, mostly, I think he’s the most unassailable, unimpeachable witness you could have in this situation, to speak out. When Mike Tomlin speaks out like this, to me, he has complete and utter credibility, and I believe him. … I’ve been involved in these situations where I’ve been called it, other people have been called it, and it comes out right away. Right away it comes out! It comes out while you’re swinging the helmet. You called me what? I mean, you don’t hold this back. … I believe [Tomlin] 100%.”

The one area where neither Tomlin nor anyone else will garner support is by citing the NFL and its integrity in conducting investigations — because it has none (destroying Spygate evidence, not securing Ray Rice video, etc.).

Tomlin’s mere presence was powerful testimony. He is almost never heard from this time of year. The fact he heard nothing from anyone in either organization — as he explained — in the aftermath of the incident also is damning of Garrett.

Meanwhile, this question looms: Why wasn’t Garrett asked about the apology he made to Rudolph less than 24 hours after the incident?

Advertise with us

The question would be: Why did you formally apologize to a man you now say insulted you in the most demeaning way imaginable?

If Garrett said it was because he wanted to mitigate the punishment and preserve his money, one might naturally follow up with this: “So you prioritized your bank account over a heinous slur?”

If he said it was because he didn’t want to attempt to justify his actions, one might ask: “Then why try to justify them now?”

Mike Moore, @MichaelMooreNB: Will MLB strip the Astros of championship?

Starkey: No, Mr. Moore, it will not. Commissioner Rob Manfred admitted he toyed with the idea but ultimately decided against it.

Advertise with us

Question is, should they be stripped of a championship? The answer is absolutely yes. The classic argument against stripping titles in these matters (blatant cheating) goes something like this, “Well, the championship happened, and everyone saw it, so what’s the point in taking it away now?”

Here’s what I would say to that: If you strip it, and thereby acknowledge it was ill-gotten, then every time somebody looks in a record book they will see there is no World Series champion for 2017. Every time somebody visits the Baseball Hall of Fame, they would see an empty space next to the 2017 champion (it doesn’t go the runner-up), and every time somebody even discussed the 2017 Houston Astros, part of the discussion would be about how their championship was taken away.

As it should be.

Tommy2Tone, @Tommy2Tone: I think Jean Pronovost is the most underrated Penguin of all time ... who do you think is?

Starkey:

Advertise with us

3. Matt Cooke (bad hits and deserved reputation as head hunter overshadowed the fact that he was a very good player on best third line in hockey).

2. Rick Kehoe (Team’s all-time points list goes like this: Lemieux, Crosby, Malkin, Jagr, Kehoe).

1. Martin Straka (sneaks into all-time Penguins top 10 in all kinds of categories — 10th in goals, eighth in even-strength goals, tied for ninth in shorthanded goals, tied for eighth in GW goals. It’s unreal. Plus, he had some huge playoff goals. And, he was Marty Straka).

Matt Saylor, @matt_saylor: Does the continued consistency that both the Penguins and Steelers have every year always being in playoff contention, maybe hurt our hopes and/or expectations that we have each year for the Pirates?

Starkey: No, Mr. Saylor, the Pirates do a pretty good job of that themselves. Also worth noting: The Steelers have missed the playoffs half the time over the past eight years.

Advertise with us

Mark Kaboly, @MarkKaboly: Why isn’t Fred Smerlas in the Hall of Fame?

Starkey: I’ve heard it’s Boston College nose tackle fatigue among voters.

I’m ok. Are you ok?, @ISeeAndHearYinz: What is your greatest XFL memory?

Starkey: That time Matt McGloin ripped the game plan on national TV at halftime, even though the highlights showed he had wide-open receivers and missed them by miles at a time (and how dare he take a shot at Kevin Gilbride).

EmpireMusic, @EmpireMusic: Over/under of 4 guitar lessons for you this year? We are hoping for over!

Advertise with us

Starkey: Definitely over — and after seeing “Yesterday,” well, yesterday, I will be focused heavily on Beatles songs. Starting with “Yesterday,” which is among the finest songs ever written.

The finest songs ever written:

3. “Tangled Up in Blue”

2. “Yesterday”

1. “Blues Run The Game (Jackson Frank)”

Advertise with us

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Sign up for our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.