Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Limas Sweed and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions, which this week were laced with Steelers-related angst …
Benedick, @BenedickUSA: Does Ben’s comeback mean we’re stuck with Coach Randy?
Starkey: “Stuck” is an interesting word choice, Mr. Benedick. I’m not sure Bill Walsh could have wrested anything more meaningful from this Steelers offense.
I mean, come on! Have we all lost our minds here? At one point, I forget which game, I looked down at the start of the second half and saw Johnny Holton at one receiver spot, a practice-squad guy at the other, a practice-squad running back, a fourth-string quarterback, a banged-up tight end and who knows what else?
That doesn’t absolve Fichtner for getting too enamored with the Duck story and ordering 40-some pass plays against the Bills. That was terrible. He’s the one who lost his mind in that situation. But overall I believe he did a decent job in a horrifying predicament.
Nobody was complaining about Fichtner last season (actually, they were), when his offense ranked sixth in scoring — the Steelers’ third-highest ranking since 1980 — at 26.8 points per game. They also led the NFL in red-zone touchdown percentage (a long-time issue with Todd Haley’s offenses) at 73.4%.
Read More
I’m not completely sold on Fichtner after two years. Not by a long shot. But the idea that his job should be in jeopardy is ludicrous.
Christopher Matich, @PghMatich: Do you believe the Steelers gave up on Josh Dobbs’ development too soon?
Starkey: No. They saw an opportunity to regain some lost draft capital and made their move, believing they had a good backup plan with Mason Rudolph.
I can’t blame them for not foreseeing that Roethlisberger would blow out his elbow, Myles Garrett would attack Rudolph with a helmet and accuse him of a slur, Duck would start a bunch of games and Rudolph would later injure his shoulder. I’m not sure they do better than 8-6 post-Ben if Dobbs was here.

Tim K., @timkjazz: Can the Penguins win the Cup with [Matt] Murray riding the bench throughout the playoffs?
Starkey: Yes, but that’s an unlikely scenario, Tim. What’s more likely is the Penguins will need both goalies. I believe, as in ’16, that it’s a major competitive advantage to have two really good goaltenders (and I still believe Matt Murray is one).
At some point, both will be needed.
dundermifflin, @jma343: Now that the Steelers are out and it’s “hockey season”, is it difficult to find show topics? Especially with the apathy towards NBA basketball.
Starkey: Not at all, Mr. dundermifflin, although I will say this: Mr. Big Chest gave us, and the entire talk-show industry, many bonus days last season. But it’s all good. The Penguins will give us plenty to talk about. The NFL is a 365-day-a-year topic gold mine. And you never know what story will break on any given day, or if we might go off the rails and talk about, say, cheap beers we used to drink in college and wonder if they still exist (that topic took off like Bryan Rust on a breakaway one day two months ago).
BTW, three such beers that never failed in a pinch …
3. Narragansett
2. Meister Brau
1. Koehler’s — which apparently is on the comeback trail:
fJB, @Jon_Brennan: Joe, why does the U.S., especially in hockey markets like BUF, Minneapolis-St Paul and Pittsburgh, still give the IIHF World Junior Hockey tournament such little coverage/exposure. It was long dominated by Canada but the U.S. is a top contender every year now. Your thoughts?
Starkey: First, I love the question, Mr. Brennan. I think the answer — if you’re talking about, say, newspapers sending a writer to cover the event or television stations covering it — is that it simply doesn’t generate enough interest in the United States. It just doesn’t. Now, if Pittsburgh’s bid to host the 2018 junior hockey world championships had succeeded (Buffalo got the bid), you would have seen way more coverage. It’s kind of like when the NCAA tournament comes here. It gets covered if it’s in town. I truly hope it does come here, btw, because it’s a fantastic event.
Tim, @timmshady: If you raced Lamar Jackson on a football field (he starts at the goal line needing 100 yards, you start at the 50 only needing 50) who would win? Essentially, you have a 50-yard head start — could you beat him?
Starkey: My first reaction, Dr. Shady, was, “Are you kidding? He would pass me at the 40.” But as always, your inquiry has given me pause.
Let’s say Lamar runs the 40 in 4.3 seconds (he was timed once at 4.34 but told ESPN he ran with turf toe that day). Let’s say I run the 40 in, what, 8 or 9 seconds? I’m basing that on watching the legendary video of sports business writer Darren Rovell run 20 yards in 4.04 very painful (and very comical) seconds.
Even with a blown-out Achilles, I gotta be faster than that guy, right?
Anyway, I’m guessing I would slow down over the last 10 yards and run 50 in about 11 seconds. Lamar can run 80 in less than nine seconds, easily. So he would probably cover 100 yards in less than 11.
I think I have a shot!
Joseph Page, @JosephP99454452: Why did Chickillo get a contract extension? He’s not a good pass rushing OLB
Starkey: No, he’s not, Joseph. He’s good on special teams, but special teams won’t guarantee him a roster spot next season. Even if Bud Dupree leaves (and I don’t think he will), the Steelers are going to have decide if Chickillo is worth a $4.5 million base salary plus a $500,000 roster bonus. I don’t think he is.
Cale Berger, @cale_berger: What are your top 5 albums of all time?
Starkey:
5. “Slow Train Comin’” Bob Dylan
4. “Tea for the Tillerman” Cat Stevens
3. “In My Tribe” 10,000 Maniacs
2. “Rumors” Fleetwood Mac
1. “Blood on the Tracks” Bob Dylan
And thank you for asking, Cale.
sto, @eskgantt: Think the Steelers would’ve traded for Minkah if Ben never got hurt?
Starkey: Did you see Kam Kelly play safety in Foxborough, Mr. Sto? The Steelers were desperate. The Dolphins presented them with an incredible opportunity. I think with Ben they might have been even more gung-ho about trading for Minkah. As it turned out, it was a great move. They have essentially already made their first-round pick next year — and in exchange for losing a year of contractual control, they gained a player they know is good. Very good.
jimi luketic, @jimi_luketic: If big Al goes, who will be the new guest on “At the Villa”? Or will it be the end of an era?!
Starkey: I don’t think Al will go. I don’t think he had a bad season, as many do. I’m with Pro Football Focus, which gave him a good grade as a pass blocker (there were bad grades all around for the Steelers’ run blocking, but as I’ve said many times, if the other guys know you can’t pass, they’re going to load up on the run, and five Hall of Famers in their primes would have a hard time generating a run game in that circumstance).
PFF said Villanueva only allowed two sacks this season. He took too many penalties (10). I think his bad plays are magnified because he is a giant and plays a high-profile position. People who don’t know the game look at a given play and say, “Wow, did you see Villanueva get knocked back? He’s having an awful year!” No, he’s not, actually.
Do you realize how many times the Steelers were stuck in third-and-longs with inexperienced, limited-mobility quarterback? That’s a nightmare for any tackle. Both Steelers tackles did OK under those circumstances, IMHO.
Mary Mac Bakehouse, @MaryMacMixes: Favorite Pittsburgh memories of the teen years (2013-2019)? Go!
Starkey:
3. Mr. Big Chest reaches over goal line.
2. Penguins beat Caps in Game 7 on way to second Cup.
1. Duck wins on “Sunday Night Football” in a high school stadium.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Click here to subscribe to our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.