Mike Tomlin on QB Paxton Lynch

Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Princell Brockenbrough and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Sunday Morning, @Shriverdown: News hound, the Steelers have an aging QB with nothing behind him; how will the Steelers remedy their future with only scalding mud at QB behind Roethlisberger?

Starkey: First, we must answer these questions, Mr. Shriverdown …

Will Ben even play next year, and will he be any good?

Advertise with us

Is his eventual replacement already on the roster?

You might have seen the winds swirling around that first question this week, when ESPN’s Chris Mortensen tweeted sources were telling him Ben “has some doubt” he’ll play again. That was quickly followed, after a storm of fan angst, by this Mortensen tweet:

“Clarity to calm down the masses — the @Steelers are now optimistic Ben Roethlisberger will recover from elbow surgery to reattach three tendons. Not cleared to throw yet but he is tracking better and Ben himself wants and expects to play in 2020 and beyond, per sources.”

That was quick.

News Hound conclusion: Roethlisberger can be optimistic and have “some doubt” about his future. Both can be true. How can there not be some doubt? He will be a 38-year-old quarterback with three reattached elbow tendons. Even if the elbow heals, what else might go wrong?

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, any rational observer has serious doubts as to whether his eventual replacement is on the roster. Duck Hodges, bless his beak, was never going to be the long-term answer. Mason Rudolph has a better skill set that Hodges, but his 10-game audition didn’t exactly scream “Future Star!”

Might Rudolph still develop into competent NFL starter? It’s possible. There might be a Neil O’Donnell in there somewhere. Rudolph deserves high marks for his return game against the Jets. He proved the traumatic events of the previous month didn’t ruin him. But he hasn’t proved much else — and don’t you want an elite player at that position, rather than just a competent one?

The Steelers certainly aren’t sold on Rudolph. You might have noticed he was still glued to the bench at the start of the Jets game, a week after Hodges threw four interceptions.

This is hardly an ideal situation moving forward, but as for next season, I would expect the Steelers to hope and pray on Roethlisberger, tentatively stick with Rudolph at No. 2 and perhaps bring in a veteran (Marcus Mariota? Ryan Fitzpatrick? Andy Dalton?) as insurance for Roethlisberger.

Joe Starkey, @Joestarkey1: Did you just say “Andy Dalton?”

Advertise with us

Starkey: Yes. Yes I did. I’ve never been a huge Dalton fan, but in the end, I think he’s gotten a terribly unfair rap. The man owns a 69-61-2 career record with 203 touchdown passes and 117 interceptions. He can still play, too. If the tank-job Bengals had used him against the Steelers in Cincinnati, they would have won that game. Just last week, he went 33 for 56 for 396 yards and four touchdowns against Miami. I think this Steelers defense could win with Andy Dalton if Ben isn’t right.

Did I just say that out loud?

Mark Miedel, @MM_VFP: Will Murray get the starting goalie gig back this season?

Starkey: I suspect yes, Mr. Miedel. My hunch is that Murray will get another run. Goaltending battles take some very strange turns, as you’ll remember from Fleury-Murray (example: Sully turned to Fleury in Game 5 vs. Tampa in 2016; if Fleury wins that game, he goes in Game 6 and who knows how much longer?).

That being said, Murray better take advantage of his next run. If not, Tristan Jarry — assuming he even approximates what he has done so far this season — will be the guy. Sully will not hesitate there. He is married to winning, not to any goalie.

Advertise with us

Timeout!

Let’s move to our intergalactically acclaimed Twitter Polls segment. I posted the following poll Monday and received more than 1,500 votes:

No. 1 reason for paltry Steelers running game this season ....

• Stacked box/No QB threat: 45.5%

• Poor O line play: 25.6%

Advertise with us

• Poor run game design: 13%

• RB injury/ineffectiveness: 16%

What we learned: People are smart. The offensive line has taken a lot of heat this season — too much, if you ask me. You could line up with five Hall of Famers in their primes, and if the other team senses no downfield passing threat and stacks the box and dares you to beat them, you wouldn’t be able to run the ball effectively, either. It’s hard to win (and run) if teams don’t respect your quarterback. Period. That doesn’t excuse the miserable failures in third- and fourth-and-1 situations (although QB sneaks nearly always work), but the lack of a running game comes down to simple math: Defenses have more people in tackling position than the Steelers have blockers.

All of the above can be true. Mike Tomlin said it well when he was asked Tuesday to identify the cause of the run game’s failures.

“Because we’ve got young QBs and young wideouts and people pack the box — and we could perform better.”

Advertise with us

Donald Hilenbrant, @Hildebeest24: What is the top 5 LOWEST Pittsburgh sports moments of the decade? Not getting into off field, just in-game moments.

Starkey:

5. Jerry Meals.

4. Kuznetsov, overtime, Game 7.

3. Toussaint fumble.

Advertise with us

2. Tebow.

1. Ryan Shazier injury

BTW, you can read all about such moments, the highs and the lows and everything in between, in our “The Decade That Was” in Pittsburgh sports project.

Ben, @BenjaminW_57: Greatest Sports Memory on Christmas.

Starkey:

Advertise with us

4. Bernard King goes for 60 (most underrated scorer of all-time shreds the Nets).

3. Longest game in NFL history (I wanted the Chiefs and was literally a member of the Ed Podolak Fan Club, and the Dolphins won, but it was still an incredible memory).

2. Mr. Big Chest beats the Ravens (they called it The Immaculate Extension).

1. Santa delivers savvy young news hound a brand, spanking new No. 32 Bills jersey nine days after O.J. Simpson reaches 2,003 yards in 1973 (and 21 years before O.J. is revealed as one of the worst people on the planet).

How odd it was to look down the field nine days ago and see a player named Senorise Perry wearing that number for the Bills. He became the first Bills player in 42 years — since Simpson left — to wear 32.

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Sign up for our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed, for free.