Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lars Eller, Carl Eller and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Scott Murphy, @TheBenchHouse: Do the Steelers give JuJu Smith-Schuster a new contract after his rookie deal is up?
Starkey: His rookie deal is up after next season, Mr. Bench House, and the only reason the Steelers wouldn’t give him a new deal (and it could happen as early as this coming offseason) is if Smith-Schuster’s demands are way out of whack. And I’ll say this: He is an interesting case.
Does he deserve elite receiver money? Michael Thomas signed a six-year, $100 million with $61 million guaranteed. At one point, not long ago, Smith-Schuster could have made an argument he’s in that class.
Now, not so much, although I would argue his reduced production this season is more about the team’s quarterback issues than the absence of Antonio Brown (and all the coverage Brown seeped up).
Like Smith-Schuster, Thomas was a second-round pick. Thomas signed his new deal with one year left (this year) on his four-year rookie contract. If the Steelers went that route, they could sign Smith-Schuster to an extension as early as this offseason — and perhaps buy low.
Read More
I thought Smith-Schuster was terrific Monday night. It’s amazing what can happen when you simply give him a chance to make a play. He also drew double coverage on Diontae Johnson’s game-changing touchdown before the half (nice defensive call, Dolphins).
I wonder how many receivers, in Smith-Schuster’s same predicament this season, would be putting up monster numbers. He still has a chance to have a great season. And the bet here is that he’ll be the Steelers’ No. 1 receiver for a long, long time.
The question is, at what price?
AdamMac, @Adammcanulty1: Did Mason Rudolph do enough to win the game? Or did he not kill the Steelers and get bailed out by his receivers?
Starkey: In the end, Rudolph’s numbers (20-for-36, 251 yards, two touchdowns, one interception, 84.4 passer rating) were respectable, Mr. AdamMac. He did enough to win after a horrific start. He gave his receivers the chance to make plays.
Rudolph clearly gained confidence as the game went along. I thought the third-and-11 conversion deep in Steelers territory — a pretty good throw to Diontae Johnson with the Steelers trailing 14-0 — was a game-altering play.
As we move along here, Rudolph needs to play to his strength — and be allowed to play to his strength. His strength is getting the ball downfield.
Paper Football Hall of Fame, @PaperFBHOF: Has Tomlin run the wheels off of Conner?
Starkey: That was the first game all year James Conner carried the ball 20-plus times, Mr. Paper. Somebody else wondered why Conner was in the game with just over two minutes left. It was still a two-score game before the two-minute warning. You can only protect a guy so much.
Donnie, @dbt8819: Who’s the guy who does the voice-overs for the shows on The Fan?
Starkey: I think his name is Steve.
Drew, @drew_pgh: Stronger chance of survival (in our lifetime): MLB home plate umpire or the African elephant?
Starkey: I know this much, Drew: An elephant would have done a better job calling balls and strikes than Lance Barksdale did in Game 5 of the World Series. He was awful, although at least he didn’t threaten to start a civil war, like his counterpart Rob Drake (who still has a job!).
With millions of viewers watching a computerized strike zone on television, and seeing how badly Barksdale (and others) whiff on calls, it has become a terrible situation for Major League Baseball.
MLB has already experimented with robot umps in the independent Atlantic League, and it went fairly well
I’m going to make this call, and hope it’s better than many of Barksdale’s: By 2021, MLB will have computers calling balls and strikes.
Trade Mike Tomlin, @NeilPar49897889: Chances Mike Tomlin gets traded before the 4 p.m. deadline?
Starkey: About the same as the Miami Dolphins winning the Super Bowl, Mr. TMT. And that goes for the offseason, as well.
Euro, @Reitz_Crackers: What are you more impressed by today: Tomlin winning a challenge, Nutting firing Neal Huntington, or a Port Authority bus falling in a sinkhole?
Starkey: That is an incredible question, Mr. Euro, and I would put them in this order:
3. Nutting fires Huntington. This was mildly surprising, given the strong public vote of confidence Nutting gave his GM just four weeks ago. However, I don’t believe much of what Nutting says, so it can’t be that surprising. And it was the obvious right move.
2. Bus falls into sink hole. My only thought, like yours, was: Will this ever happen to me while I’m driving? That sink hole was bigger than 10 Al Villanuevas. How would you escape? How does it happen? Where’s the next one going to pop up? I might never drive downtown again.
1. Tomlin wins a challenge. This was more unlikely than the Miracle on Ice. And he couldn’t even enjoy the win. There still needed to be a measurement. But at least our long national nightmare is over.
Based on history, Tomlin will next win a challenge sometime in 2022.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.