Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lonnie Chisenhall and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Doc, @syracusepittfan: What would be the Steelers record with BB at QB?
Starkey: Thanks, Doc. Great question. Also impossible to answer for many reasons, one of which is that Roethlisberger did not play well in the game-and-a-half in which he appeared.
I’m going to say 3-3. I still feel like Russell Wilson would have done whatever needed to be done to win that game, and I feel like San Francisco is just a better team. I know your reply: Ben would have converted some of those early turnovers into touchdowns in San Fran.
My response: How do you know?
Do we know for sure that San Francisco would have run the exact same offensive plays, with the exact same results, if Roethlisberger had been the opposing quarterback?
Read More
Do we know if Ben would have played well against what has turned out to be one of the faster, more destructive defenses in the NFL?
We just don’t know, Doc.
We just don’t know.
Zack Henry, @zackoff39: With the lore of nicknames in sports and the recent push of Duck, what are some of the best and creative nicknames in sports and Pittsburgh sports history?
Starkey: Thank for the question, Zack. I will do this off the top of my head. My favorite five from the 2000s:
5. “The Bus” (Jerome Bettis)
4. Casey “Big Snack” Hampton
3. Douglas “Crankshaft” Murray
2. Johan “Moose” Hedberg
1. Devlin “Duck” Hodges
Colin Dunlap, @colin_dunlap: legitimate question: Phil Rivers and his wife have 9 children. Legitimately, what is the maximum you could handle and not go insane?
Starkey: Thank you, Colin. I honestly believe I would lose track of their names after five.
Quick timeout for this week’s intergalactically popular Twitter Poll segment. I tweeted a simple question: If Mason Rudolph is deemed healthy, who starts against the Dolphins, him or Duck? I left one hour for responses, and 82% of the 932 voters picked Rudolph.
What we learned: That just when you doubt them, football fans will behave sanely.
I love The Duck Story. It’s a classic against-all-odds tale. I think he played pretty well, too, managing the offense and moving the ball just enough. But he did not inspire confidence with his downfield throws (0 for 4 with an interception on passes that traveled at least 10 yards in the air). I’m not saying Rudolph has been Roger Staubach, but he has been the better of the two. His numbers are respectable — 67% completion rate (mostly on very short throws), seven touchdowns, two interceptions (one of which sailed right through Donte Moncrief’s hands) and a 102.5 passer rating.
Twitter Poll update: Just when you thought it was safe out there … my 93.7 The Fan colleague Andrew Fillipponi tweeted a question — “Better quarterback? Duck Hodges (or) Baker Mayfield” — and after an hour Hodges was hanging in there with 49% of the vote.
What we learned: That just when you trust them most, football fans will behave insanely.
Chris Hawthorne, @Hawthorneee: Does Pomp take both armrests too?
Starkey: The news that Bob Pompeani is indeed an airplane seat recliner left many of us deeply disturbed, Chris. That Bob claims he asks permission before reclining his seat hardly matters. Who’s going to say no to Bob Pompeani?
I have to be honest here: I’m rattled. I thought I knew the man. But it does spark a topic: The three most annoying kinds of airplane passengers …
3. EAT GROSS FOOD PERSON. Ran into this type a few weeks back on the way to San Francisco. Dude busted out a spicy noodle bowl two seats away from me. Then started slurping. Wanna eat a turkey sandwich? Go for it. Some foods, however, are clearly off limits on an airplane, just as, say, reheating fish in the office microwave is a no-no.
2. WON’T SHUT UP PERSON. They can’t take a hint. They just keep on talking. They want to know everything about you and tell you everything about them. Doesn’t matter if you bury your head in a book. Matters less if you put earphones in. They just keep on yakkin’.
1. SEAT RECLINER/ARMREST STEALER PERSON: Would hogging both armrests be OK if you asked permission, Bob?
I think we both know the answer to that.
Thank you, my yinz. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Click here to subscribe to our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.