Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lonnie Chisenhall and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Actually, we’re going to start with our intergalactically popular Twitter Poll segment this week. I was curious about something: Given the Steelers’ issues in the passing game, would anybody out there want to see The Return of Mr. Big Chest?
Obviously, this is a fictional exercise. There’s a better chance Bob Nutting will fly a helicopter over Market Square and drop 100-dollar bills on his adoring fans.
Here’s how I phrased the question on Twitter: “This is nothing more than a sanity check, and I really hope it polls 99% one way. But I am curious. If Antonio Brown said he wanted to play for the Steelers again, you would say ….
• Yes!
• No!”
Read More
Clearly, this is not a scientific poll, but it’s the closest thing I got. And nearly 1,800 people responded. The results …
• Yes! (18%)
• No! (82%)
What we learned: That nearly one in five people would want Brown back. Which is astounding. Have you people lost your minds?
Antonio Brown is walking poison. He quit on this team at a critical time last season. He has been behaving irrationally for months (years?), with no sign of returning to reality.
Yet, this is a sampling of the responses:
Johnny Jackson, @JohnnyJackson66: Tell me how we could do any worse with him.
THE ARCHON, @GnosticManChild: They know how to manage him better than anyone else. BRING BACK.
Sandpip, @sjain316: I am with @Stephenasmith, if he is not guilty, apologizes, then sure bring him back. Of course he is probably guilty, and he will not properly apologize so....
I repeat: Have you people lost your minds?
OK, on to the questions …
Neil Parker, @NeilPar49897889: Is it safe to say that James Washington is a bust?
Starkey: No, it’s not, Mr. Parker, but it’s more than mildly concerning that Washington has virtually disappeared from the offense. Aside from that 45-yard catch at New England — a play on which he strangely ran out of bounds — Washington has five catches for 43 yards. I’m told he blocked pretty well on some of those wildcat plays the other night, but you don’t draft somebody 60th overall to block the wildcat. It’s reaching the point where Donte Moncrief might re-appear at Washington’s expense. He was only targeted once Monday night.
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: Have you ever been fired before and was it as bad as how the Pirates handled Hurdle?
Starkey: Yes, I was fired from two jobs. Sort of.
Let me explain. I was absolutely fired as a dishwasher at the Lord Amherst Hotel in Snyder, N.Y., 35 years ago for eating carrot cake out of the freezer. I was sort of fired from a landscaping job around that time, largely because I was terrible at landscaping. By “sort of” I mean I went to the usual pick-up spot early in the morning, and the pickup truck with the all the workers in it drove right past me. I figured that was a pretty clear sign.
And no, none of that was anywhere near as bad as how the Pirates handled Hurdle. Nothing could be that ill-timed and awkward. Bob Nutting should have fired Hurdle and Huntington on Monday. If they were just going to fire Hurdle, they should have done it two weeks, or two months, earlier. They soiled the Steve Blass celebration, for one thing. They also apparently left Hurdle with the impression he was staying.
It was as if Nutting woke up Sunday morning and said, “You know what, I think we should fire the manager!”
What a disgrace. And how is Huntington still here? He has developed pitchers about as well the Steelers have developed cornerbacks, despite excellent drafting position in many years. Tampa Bay and Oakland are proof you can have more than just one small window of contention as an under-funded team.
Lastly, did you see Hurdle’s smile as the left the ballpark Sunday? It was larger than the national deficit, and for good reason. He gets a $6 million parting gift and doesn’t have to live in this tire fire anymore (that being said, he really should have been fired months ago).
Levi Hutchison, @levihutch29: Best case scenario for a Jack Johnson trade?
Starkey: The best-case scenario for a Jack Johnson trade is just that: a Jack Johnson trade. The Penguins would find a taker and eat some salary and get out from under the contract. That’s it. That’s the return. GM Jim Rutherford scoffed at the notion he is actively trying to trade Johnson, but it’s no secret he has tried. It needs to happen.
Euro, @Reitz_Crackers: How would you grade Fichtner overall (Monday)?
Starkey: I’d give him an A — but I’m not sure that game plan works anybody but the dregs of the league. It was pretty much as conservative as the one Fichtner tried to execute in San Francisco, only against a defense that was not nearly as fast or talented. The 49ers are really good. The Bengals stink. At some point, you have to get the ball down the field.
However, as Mike Tomlin put it during his news conference Tuesday, the Steelers are in a “fragile” state right now. It was the perfect game plan for that particular night, against that particular opponent, in a desperate situation. Survive and advance, as they say.
Drew, @drew_pgh: More goals this year: Sid, Jake, or Gino?
Starkey: Well, last year it was Jake 40, Sid 35, Geno 21. The year before it was Geno 42, Sid 29, Jake 22. This year it will be Geno 38, Jake 35, Sid 34.
You’re welcome.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Click here to subscribe to our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.