Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lars Eller, Carl Eller and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions, which were laced with Steeler rage …
Luke Bickerstaff, @LukeBickerstaff: Riddle me this: why was the first big shot down the field to Johnny Freaking Holton?????
Starkey: Because Johnny Freaking Holton can run, Mr. Bickerstaff, and that should have been a big play. It wasn’t a great throw, but here’s the question: Why didn’t Mike Tomlin throw a challenge flag on that play?
Holton was interfered with, quite clearly. You could make an argument cornerback Jonathan Jones literally tackled him before the ball arrived. (And who knew these two had a history) Jones absolutely hooked his arm. He was also guilty of face-guarding, which is only legal if no contact is made. Contact was made.
Why wasn’t a bigger deal made of this in the moment?
I was at the game, so I didn’t hear Cris Collinsworth’s take until now. And, wow. Even as he is watching Jones practically tackle Holton on replay, Collinsworth says, “Oh, that’s a great job by Jonathan Jones to hold off that one. Boy, it really looked like he may have hooked him on the way down, but watch: He just keeps his hands off and really a clean play. That was tremendous.”
Read More

Keeps his hands off? I’m looking at the replay, right now, and unless I’ve lost it, the one thing Jones did not do was keep his hands off. His hands are on. Very much on. He is hooking Holton’s arm. He is face-guarding him with contact. He jumped on his back.
I think the league would have been licking its chops to find a play even remotely like the New Orleans play from the NFC Championship to show off its new system. Obvious pass interference will be called even if the refs don’t throw a flag, right?
That was the case in the preseason. According to the Washington Post, “all seven (preseason pass interference) reversals came when pass interference was not called on the field and then was assessed via the replay review.”
I’m convinced Tomlin wins that challenge. Easily and quickly. And it was a huge point in a scoreless game. The Steelers could have had the ball around the Patriots’ 20.
The Steelers wouldn’t have won the game, of course, but at least Tomlin would have broken his multi-year challenge drought.
Mike Clarke, @mlc118: Please talk about why starters are in in a blowout by 30 points thus resulting in 3 key injuries. Local media should be all over this. first question to Tomlin tomorrow. No excuse.
Starkey: You can’t take everyone out of the game, Mike, but I do agree that a veteran with some injury history, such as Maurkice Pouncey, should be removed from a game like that — as much as he would hate it. Sometimes the coach has to overrule the player.
Plus, B.J. Finney could have used the work on timing his snaps
I am B.J. Finney at work this morning pic.twitter.com/kz9wAV4twk
— Zack (@NotTheRealZack) September 9, 2019
Zumu-iolo, @ZumoSinn: It's Getting There for the Steelers, but is it Dark Yet? After all, the Patriots are Knocking on Seven's Door. Can you give us some hope for New Morning?
Starkey: No, I really can’t, Zumu. Maybe Antonio Brown goes there and detonates a dynasty, but I doubt it. If he is deemed harmful to the cause of winning, he will be cut faster than you can say, “Boomin.” I have to believe Chesty posting a mural of himself in a Patriots uniform sitting on a stack of money probably wasn’t the best first impression.
In speaking with, and listening to, several Patriots talk of their family-oriented, everyone-is-equal culture after Sunday’s game — and how it all trickles down from the quarterback — I believe Brown will be given every opportunity to fit in. And will receive plenty of support. And if he screws up, he’ll be gone. Period.
Jay Caufield’s Cat, @JayCaufieldsCat: How many losses will it take for Mike Tomlin to get fired at the end of the year?
Starkey: I’m torn on that question, Cat. Part of me believes Tomlin would be safe no matter what. Part of me believes a second consecutive non-playoff year would prompt Art Rooney II to make a move. The pressure to do so would be immense, as it would then have been nine years with only three playoff wins — one of them a gift from the Bengals, another against Matt Moore.
Tim, @timmshady: right now, how would you rank the AFC North QBs?
Starkey: As always, a very thoughtful question from you, Mr. Shady. In terms of Week 1 performance, it would have to be: 1. Jackson. 2. Dalton. 3. Roethlisberger. 4. Mayfield.
But in terms of, who would I pick to quarterback my team this year? Still has to be: 1. Roethlisberger. 2. Mayfield. 3. Jackson. 4. Dalton.
One has to factor in competition, player history, etc., right? I’m not even sure games against the Dolphins should count in the standings, and I’m not ready to put Lamar Jackson ahead of Baker Mayfield. Nor am I ready to put anyone in this division above Ben.
I mean, if we were doing quarterback rankings after one week last season, Ryan Fitzpatrick would have been No. 1 and possibly headed to the Hall of Fame, right? He was 21 of 28 for 417 yards, four touchdowns and no picks in a 48-40 win over the Saints.
Week 1 can be deceiving.
Having said that, I love watching Jackson play, and he was unreal in that game.
Theodore,@Theodor96331836: How come the offensive game plan is the same every week for every team? Abandon the run and pass 55 times with every 3rd pass a long bomb. Doesn't this make it easy for defenses to prepare for?
Starkey: That might be overdoing it, Ted (may I call you Ted?). But I get your point, and I do believe, with this franchise in particular, that there is something to establishing a certain physicality on offense and running the ball.
That doesn’t mean a pass-heavy game plan won’t work on a given week. It’s just that when the Steelers offense has been at its very best in recent years — and, you know, the past 45 years — it has delivered a steady dose of power football. That might seem like antiquated thinking. But even in recent years, the offense has been at its best with lots of James Conner or Le’Veon Bell. Look it up. Think of the middle of last season.
The way I see it, you’re not taking advantage of a powerful offensive line if you’re not allowing it to exert its power.
Joe Stafford,@JoeStaf30683671: Why are Steelers linebackers covering wide receivers? Didn’t they learn from the Chargers game last year? Obviously not!
Starkey: I thought that problem was fixed, right Joe? I thought the Steelers were just shorthanded that night against the Chargers and had NO CHOICE but to periodically cover Keenan Allen with a linebacker. That wasn’t going to happen anymore, right? And then we saw Vince Williams lined up over Josh Gordon. That’s just coaching. One team better prepared. One team with an incredible scheme. The other looking totally disorganized and helpless on defense, drowning in a sea of bad or busted coverages. Its highly paid defensive line totally neutralized. Its secondary and linebackers exposed in coverage.
Brian Fennell, @@golferguy1202: As we approach most likely the final Pitt/Penn St. game for the long foreseeable future, are you more disappointed this “rivalry” is ending, or more looking forward to the restart of the Backyard Brawl between Pitt/WVU?
Starkey: Was your nickname “Seed” growing up? Because it really should have been — and I’m sure you’ll agree that fresh fennel seed is very underrated, Brian.
To answer your question, Seed, I’m more excited that Pitt-WVU is restarting because I like that rivalry slightly better. But I’m still extremely disappointed that Pitt-PSU is ending, because it is absolutely a rivalry and a great one. Check the atmosphere at the past three meetings to confirm that.
It is a built-in, in-state, historic rivalry that could cease for 100 years and still be plenty hot the second it resumed.
Contrary to popular belief, plenty of Penn State fans love this matchup, too. At least the ones I talk to. They want to see this game played, rather than, say, any of next year’s out-of-conference opponents: Nevada, Virginia Tech and San Jose State.
Although I am looking forward to the Penn State-Nevada game.

Thank you, my yinz. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Click here to subscribe to our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.