The Pirates are not void of talent. They have four of the best players in the National League, in fact, and some franchise-altering decisions to make.
They need starting pitching and an impact catcher, desperately, and those things likely will require serious cash and/or a willingness to deal from their Big Four core.
The problem is, if you deal from the core, you have to replace what you lost. Could Keone Kela step in for Felipe Vazquez and close games if Vazquez is dealt? Will the volatile Kela even be here?
And who would play center field if Starling Marte is traded? It has become clear that Bryan Reynolds — another of the Big Four — isn’t ready defensively for that position.
The other problem is that the Pirates don’t spend serious cash on anything (except, in relative terms, on a manager of all things). Their best hope, maybe their only hope, is for their rotation to miraculously round into shape, and counting on miracles is no way to build a champion.
In the meantime, they do have four very good players: Vazquez, Marte, Reynolds and first baseman Josh Bell.
Read More
All four are having special seasons.
Bell was second in the NL in RBIs going into Thursday’s game in Colorado. He has a real chance to become the first Pirate to hit 40 home runs since Willie Stargell hit 44 in 1973.
Vazquez is as good as any closer in baseball — a fact on full display Tuesday night in Philadelphia, when his wicked slider conspired with a heavy dose of 100-mph heat to melt Bryce Harper on the spot.
Reynolds went into Thursday’s game three points off the batting lead. He could become the first rookie in NL history to win the batting title.
Marte is a near-lock to pass the 100-run mark and has an outside chance to join the 30/30 club (30 home runs and 30 stolen bases). Only 62 players in major league history have accomplished that feat, including just one Pirate — Barry Bonds in 1990 and ’92.
Marte went into Thursday’s game with 23 home runs, 24 steals and 29 games left on the schedule. In his previous 29 games, he had six home runs and 12 steals, so it’s possible (unless, of course, he’s one short in each category in the season finale and Clint Hurdle double-switches him out of the game).
Much credit to Marte for having the best season of his career at age 30 — and for becoming perhaps the first player in history whose power increased after he was busted for PEDs.
So the question is, what do you do with the Big Four?
Well, you do nothing with Reynolds and Bell. That’s a given. Reynolds, 24, is under team control until he’s 30.
Bell is a different story. He’s under team control (arbitration) for three more years, and it seems highly unlikely he’ll pass up unrestricted free agency to sign here. Already 27, he might only have one chance at a monster contract, after the 2022 season.
That means we could be talking about a possible Bell trade a little more than a year from now, after the 2020 season. He would have two years of arbitration left, the same situation Gerrit Cole was in when the Pirates traded him.
This is what GM Neal Huntington said at the time: “The reality is that in Gerrit’s situation, while he’s going to be a very effective major league pitcher for the next two years, it was only going to be two more years in Pittsburgh before he tested free agency.”
Marte’s there now — two more years of team control, in the form of club options. If the idea is to sell high, sell now, I say.
Same with Vazquez, who is under team control for four more years. It’s not often a relief pitcher could net you a bounty of young talent.
Now, if the Pirates are serious about building around those guys — if they want to spend some big money — I’d argue to keep Marte and Vazquez.
But who's counting on that?
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.